Response 7: Sir Gawain And The Green Knight (50 Pts.)

More praise for Simon Armitage’s

SIR G�W�IN �Nb Ch E GREEN i<.NJGh “C

“The English poet Simon Armitage has provided a free and

Save your time - order a paper!

Get your paper written from scratch within the tight deadline. Our service is a reliable solution to all your troubles. Place an order on any task and we will take care of it. You won’t have to worry about the quality and deadlines

Order Paper Now

wonderfully offbeat version of this unusual masterpiece . . . . His Sir

Gawain is fresh and startling, as though it had been written yesterday;

it is rough-knuckled and yet it sings . . . . f1rom start to finish, Mr.

Armitage has clearly had great fun; each of his words has been tasted

with gusto.” -Eric Ormsby, New York Sun

“Full of make-believe and festivity, this wonderful narrative poem

possesses a Mozartean lightness and wit. Luckily, several modern

versions, particularly those by W. S. Merwin and Simon Armitage,

deftly replicate much of the feel and rhythm of the Middle English

original. ” -Michael Dirda, Wall Street Journal

“I enjoyed it greatly for its kick and music; its high spirits, its many

memorable passages. I enjoyed it because, like the Gawain poet,

Armitage is some storyteller. ”

-Kevin Crossley-Hoiland, The Guardian

“Armitage makes it utterly, even compulsively readable, and as fresh

as it must have been in 1400.” -Brian Morton, Sunday Heralc�

“[Armitage] captures the narrative power of the Old English epic

perhaps even better than Tolkien does. ”

-Chauncey Mabe, NBCC Most Recommenckd: Winter List

“Armitage keeps structure, rhyme and alliteration, but messes

about genially with the vocabulary. The result . . . is alert, alive and

 

 

accessible. The lyricism, the power and the drive of the original are

triumphantly present. ” -Murrough O’Brien, The Independent

“Simon Armitage has translated this perfect read-aloud poem into

idiomatic English, convey{ing} the spirit and alliteration of the

original . ” -Fritz Lanham, Houston Chronicle

“This new translation by English poet Simon Armitage brims

with brawny life, boasting such elements as a giant, other-worldly

adversary, the code of chivalry and a comely and wanton maiden. If

you liked ‘Spamalot,’ here’s a chance to get even better acquainted

with those Knights of the Round Table.” -Boston Herald

“{A} supple new translation . . . . Irresistible . . . . Armitage meticulously

maintains . the singsong alliteration . . . rarely, if ever, hitting a

strained or duff note . . . . That Armitage, a celebrated Yorkshire­

born poet, has injected a spot of northern dialect back into the poem,

is delicious. Occasionally, he even improves on the original. . . . This

is a translation to be savoured for its own linguistic merits: Armitage

has pored over and polished every word. In the introduction, he

writes that his ambition was to produce an independent, living piece

of ‘poetry.’ He has certainly done that.”

-Alistair Sooke, Daily Telegraph

“{Armitage} does get across the epic’s emotional authenticity and

subtlety and its tough, tricky, sardonic core. This translation reveals a

writer closely attuned to centuries-old local influences and traditions

of language. ” -Wall Street] ournal

“The story is rich, eerie and intoxicating as it follows Gawain

from Camelot to his likely doom among the forests and crags and

icy streams of the mysterious north . . . . Armitage never lacks for

 

 

boldness. His enjoyment of the original’s thickly consonantal four­

stress alliterative line drives the narrative on at great pace. Nor does

he neglect the poem’s concern with pattern, colour and bejewelled

decoration of castles, ladies’ costumes and knightly equipment, seen

flashing and glowing amid the inhospitable winter landscapes that

dominate the poem . . . [Armitage] honours the original and will win

it readers. ” -Sean O’Brien, Sunday Times

“Joining translators such as JRR Tolkien and Ted Hughes, Simon

Armitage has taken on one of the earliest stories in English literature .

. . . [He] meets this poetic challenge courageously, staying faithful to

the story’s structure and style but filling the Middle English rhythms

with his trademark sound . . . . In the story of Gawain, Armitage has

found a language capable of change. By insisting on that change,

he had found a new poetry, a method of survival. Six hundred years

away, Gawain is closer than he has ever been.” -The Observer

“The idiom Armitage develops is delicately responsive to the aural

_intricacies of the Middle English, but also has a free-flowing,

colloquial twang that allows the poem to partake of the energies of

contemporary speech . . . . Amitage’s translation . . . captures much

of this great poem’s beguiling mixture of dreamy magic and bracing

vigour. ‘” -Mark Ford, Financial Times

 

 

BY Cb€ 5.\ffi€ .\UCbOR

POETRY

Zoom!

Xancrdu

Kid

Book of Matches

The Dead Sea Poems

Moon Country (with Glyn Maxwell)

ClottdCttckooLand

Killing Time

Selected Poems

Travelling Songs

The Universal Home Doctor

The Sho11t

Homer’s Odyssey

Tyrannoscmrtts Rex Verstts the Cord11roy Kid

DRAMA

Eclipse

Mister Heracles (after E11ripides)

]er11salem

PROSE

All Points North

Little Green Man

The White Sttt[f

 

 

 

SIR G�W�IN �Nb

ChE GREEN ](N1GhC

A NEW VERSE TRANSLATION

SlffiON �RffiiL”�GE

W. W. NORCON &: comp�NY

New York London

 

 

Copyright © 2007 by Simon Armitage

First American edition 2007

Frontispiece© British Library Board. All rights reserved. (Cotton Nero A.x (art.3) folio 95 (old ink numbering 91)

Middle English text of Sir Gawain and the Gree11 Knight reprinted by permission of Everyman’s Library, an imprint of Alfred A. Knopf.

Copyright© Everyman’s Library 1962.

All rights reserved

Printed in the United S<aces of America

First published as a Norton paperback 2008

For informacion about permission co reproduce selections from chis book,

write ro Permissions, W. W. Norton & Company, Inc., 500 Fifth Avenue,

New York, NY 10110

For information about special discounts for bulk purchases, please contact

W. W. Norton Special Sales at specialsales@wwnorton.com or 800-233-4830

Manufacturing by RR Donnelley, Bloomsburg

Book design by JAM Design

Producrion manager: Anna Oler

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Daca

Gawain and the Grene Knight. English & English (Middle English)

Sir Gawain and rhe Green Knight : a new verse translation I [rranslated by] Simon Armitage. – lsc American ed.

p. em.

Middle English rext, parallel English translation.

ISBN 978-0-393-06048-5

1. Gawain (Legendary character)–Romances. 2. Knights and knighchood-Poecry.

3. Arthurian romances. I. Armicage, Simon, 1963- II. Tide.

PR065.G3A328 2007

821.1–dc22 2007028520

ISBN 978-0-393-33415-9 pbk.

W. W. Norton & Company, Inc.

500 Fifch Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10110

www.wwnorcon.com

W. W. Norton & Company Ltd.

Casde House, 75176 Wells Screec, London WIT 3QT

1234567890

 

 

CONL”ENL”S

INTRODUCTION by Simort Armitage

9

A NOTE ON MIDDLE ENGLISH METER byjames Simpson

17

SIR G.).W.).IN .).j’jb ChE GREEN I<.NIGhC

19

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

ABOUT THE GAWAIN POET

195

ABOUT THE TRANSLATOR

197

 

 

INt”RObU CLION

W e know next to nothing about the author of the poem that

has come to be called Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. It

was probably written around 1400. In the early seventeenth century

the manuscript was recorded as belonging to a Yorkshireman, Henry

Saville of Bank. It was later acquired by Sir Robert Cotton, whose

collection also included the Lindisfarrie Gospels and the only exist­

ing manuscript of Beowulf The poem then lay dormant for over two

hundred years, not coming ro l ight until Queen VictOria was on

the throne, thus leapfrogging the attentions of some of our greatest

writers and critics. The manuscript, a small, unprepossessing thing,

would fit comfortably into an average-size hand, were anyone actu­

ally allowed to rouch it . Now referred to as CottOn Nero A.x . , i t

i s considered not only a most brilliant example of Middle English

poetry but one of the jewels in the crown of English Literature, and

sits in the British Library under conditions of high security and con­

trolled humidity.

To cast eyes on the manuscript, or even to shuffle the unbound

pages of the Early English Text Society’s facsimile edition, is to be

intrigued by the handwriting; stern, stylish letters, like crusading

chess pieces, fall into orderly ranks along faintly ruled lines. But the

man whose calligraphy we ponder, a jobbing scribe, probably, was

not the author. The person who has become known as the Gawain

poet remains as shadowy as the pages themselves. Among many

Introduction 9

 

 

other reasons, it is partly this anonymity that has made the poem so

attractive to latter-day translators. The lack of authorship seems to

serve as an invitation, opening up a space within the poem for a new

writer to occupy. Its comparatively recent rediscovery acts as a further

draw; if Milton or Pope had put their stamp on it, or if Dr. Johnson

had offered an opinion, or if Keats or Coleridge or Wordsworth had

drawn it into their orbit, such an invitation might now appear less

forthcoming.

The diction of the original tells us that its author was, broadly

speaking, a northerner. Or we might say a midlander. The linguis­

tic epicenter is thought to be located somewhere between north

Staffordshire and south Lancashire. Some researchers claim to have

identified Swythamley Grange as the Castle of Hautdesert, or the

jagged peaks of The Roaches as those “rughe knokled knarres with

knorned stones,” (21 66). Lud’s Church, a natural fissure in the rocks

near the village of Flash, in Debyshire, has been proposed as the site

of the Green Chapel. “Hit hade a hole on the ende and on ayther syde,

I And overgrowen with gresse in glodes anywhere; I And a! was holw

inwith, nobot an olde cave I Or a crevisse of an olde cragge” (2180-

2 183). It may or may not be the place, but to stand in that mossy

cleft that cannot have changed much over the centuries is to believe

that the author had an actual landscape in mind when he conceived

the poem, and lured his young protagonist into a northern region to

legitimize his vocabulary and to make good use of his surrounding

geography. A similar strategy has informed this translation; although

my own part of England is separated from Lud’s Church by the swol­

len uplands of The Peak District, coaxing Gawain and his poem back

into the Pennines was always part of the plan.

Of course, to the trained medievalist the poem is perfectly read­

able in its original form; no translation necessary. And even for the

nonspecialist, certain lines, such as, “Bot Arthure wolde not ete til a!

were served,” (85), especially when placed within the context of the

I o I n t1·od11ction

 

 

narrative, present little problem. Conversely, lines such as “Forthi,

iwysse, bi yowre wylle, wende me bihoves,” ( 1 065) are incompre­

hensible to the general reader. But it is the lines that fall somewhere

between those extremes-the majority of lines, in fact-which fas­

cinate the most. They seem to make sense, though not quite. To the

untrained eye, it is as if the poem is lying beneath a thin coat of ice,

tantalizingly near yet frustratingly blurred. To a contemporary poet,

one interested in narrative and form, the urge to blow a little warm

breath across that layer of frosting eventually proved irresistible.

And even more so to a northerner who not only recognizes plenty

of the poem’s dialect but who detects an echo of his own speech

within the original. Words such as “bide” (wait), “nobut” (nothing

but), “childer” (children), “layke” (play), “karp” (talk), “bout” (with­

out), “brid” (bird), “sam” (gather up), and “barlay” (truce) are still

in usage in these parts, though mainly (and sadly) among members

of the older generation.

Not all poems are stories, but Sir Gawain and the Green Knight most

certainly is. After briefly anchoring its historical credentials in the

siege of Troy, the poem quickly delivers us into Arrhurian Britain, at

Christmastime, with the knights of the Round Table in good humor

and full voice. But the festivities at Camelot are to be disrupted by

the astonishing appearance of a green knight. Not just a knight wear­

ing green clothes, but a weird being whose skin and hair is green,

and whose horse is green as well. The gate-crasher lays down a seem­

ingly absurd challenge, involving beheading and revenge. Alert to

the opportunity, a young knight, Gawain, Arthur’s nephew, rises

from the table. What follows is a test of his courage and a test of his

heart, and during the ensuing episodes, which span an entire calen­

dar year, Gawain must steel himself against fear and temptation. The

poem is also a ghost story, a thriller, a romance, an adventure story,

and a morality tale. For want of a better word, it is also a myth, and

like all great myths of the past its meanings seem to have adapted and

Introd!lction I I

 

 

evolved, proving itself eerily relevant six hundred years later. As one

example, certain aspects of Gawain’s situation seem oddly redolent

of a more contemporary predicament, namely our complex and deli­

cate relationship with the natural world. The Gawain poet had never

heard of climate change and was not a prophet anticipating the onset

of global warming. But medieval society lived hand in hand with

nature, and natu _ re was as much an enemy as a friend. It is not just

for decoration that the poem includes passages relating to the turn­

ing of the seasons, or detailed accounts of the landscape, or graphic

descriptions of our dealings with the animal kingdom. The knight

who throws down the challenge at Camelot is both ghostly and real.

Supernatural, yes, but also flesh and blood. He is something in the

likeness of ourselves, and he is not purple or orange or blue with yel­

l,ow stripes. Gawain must negotiate a deal with a man who wears the

colors of the leaves and the fields. He must strike an honest bargain

with this manifestation of nature, and his future depends on it.

Over the years there have been dozens, possibly hundreds of trans­

lations of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, ranging from important

scholarly restorations, to freehanded poetic or prose versions, to exer­

cises in form and technique by students of Middle English, many

of them posted on the Internet: Some translators, for perfectly valid

reasons and with great success, have chosen not to imitate its highly

alliterative form. But to me, alliteration is the warp and weft of the

poem, without which it is just so many fine threads. In some very

elemental way, the story and the sense of the poem is directly located

within its sound. The percussive patterning of the words serves to

reinforce their meaning and to countersink them within the memory.

So in trying to harmonize with the original rather than transcribe

every last word of it, certain liberties have been taken. This is not an

exercise in linguistic forensics or medieval history; the intention has

always been to produce a living, inclusive, and readable piece of work

in its own right.

12 Introduction

 

 

Readers of this parallel text edition are offered the opportunity of

allowing their eye to travel across the gutter of the book from an orig­

inal line to its corresponding translation. Occasionally they will be

presented with something like a mirror image, or at least a striking

resemblance. The first line of the poem, for example, aside for the odd

bit of touching-up, is a fairly honest reproduction. Other lines, how­

ever, will be less recognizable in their altered state. There is plenty to

argue with here, and for some commentators, this kind of approach

will always be unacceptable. But this is a poem, not a crib or a glos­

sary, and in imitating the alliterative style of Sir Gawain and the Green

Knight i t is inevitable that the translator will be led away from the

words of the original and their direct contemporary equivalents. Take

the much discussed issue of the Gawain poet’s many words for “knight”

or “man.” Terms at his disposal included “freke,” “hathel,” “burne,”

“tulk,” “segge,” “schalk,” and “gome.” In a literal translation, with the

use of a dictionary, each of those obsolete words could be replaced by a

modern word of the same meaning, without too much agonizing over

its acoustic properties or pronunciation. But in an alliterative transla­

tion those agonies must be experienced; in trawling for appropriate

substitute words the net must be cast wider. In the “bob and wheel”

sections where meter and rhyme also enter the equation, further devi­

ations are inevitable. Lines 8 1-82 read: “The comlokest to discrye I

Ther glent with yyen gray” (Broadly speaking, the fairest to behold I

looked on with gray eyes). A literal translation gives us the cold facts of

Guinevere’s beauty, yet the unspoken poetic intelligence suggests that

her eyes are precious- stones, more priceless than the “best gemmes”

mentioned in the previous line. Of all the jewels that surround her, it

is her own eyes that glint and gleam the most. My own poetic response

has been to introduce “quartz” and “queen,” despite neither of those

words being present in the original lines. I hope that readers will be

able to see this as a kind of controlled and necessary flirtation, rather

than carefree unfaithfulness or mindless infidelity.

Introduction r 3

 

 

Aside from the technical requirements of the poem, there are other

reasons for departing from the literal, and those reasons are to do with

the very nature of poetry itself. Poetry is not just meaning and infor­

mation. Poetry is about manner as much as it is about matter-the

manner in which words behave under certain conditions and in par­

ticular surroundings. Such behaviors give poems their unique char­

acter. Over time these behaviors change, or come to signify different

things, and their latter-day counterparts are more likely to be found

in the imagination than in the dictionary or the encyclopedia. For

this reason the poet who works as a translator will rarely be content

with a tit-for-tat exchange of one language into another, no matter

how scrupulous the transfer. Here is line 113 7:

By that any daylight lemed upon erthe

“By the time that some daylight shone upon earth” would be a rea­

sonable l iteral translation. At first sight this not a particularly appeal­

ing line. To begin with, it is one of the moments in the poem when

the alliteration falters. Also, for a description of the life-bringing

dawn, and as a curtain-raiser to one of the greatest hunting scenes

i n all literature, it ·seems pretty tame. But there is power. here, and

much of that power is invested in that single word “lemed,” from an

Old Norse word, ” lj6ma,” meaning “to shine.” It is not a word used

in English these days, which is a pity, because as a verb it has much