Discussion Post – Gaps In IQ Scores

Discussion post – one to two paragraphs

Given the importance of the intelligence quotient (IQ) in modern society, significant gaps continue to be measured based on social and cultural differences. In your initial post, utilize the module resources and your own research to explain the reason for these gaps in IQ scores. Clearly state if you think any of the existing hypotheses are sufficient in explaining this gap.

Social Equity Theory and Racial-Ethnic Achievement Gaps

Clark McKown Rush University Medical Center

In the United States, racial-ethnic differences on tests of school readiness and academic achievement continue. A complete understanding of the origins of racial-ethnic achievement gaps is still lacking. This article describes social equity theory (SET), which proposes that racial-ethnic achievement gaps originate from two kinds of social process, direct and signal influences, that these two kinds of processes operate across develop- mental contexts, and that the kind of influence and the setting in which they are enacted change with age. Evidence supporting each of SET’s key propositions is discussed in the context of a critical review of research on the Black–White achievement gap. Specific developmental hypotheses derived from SET are described, along with proposed standards of evidence for testing those hypotheses.

This article offers an account of the varied social processes that contribute to mean differences in test scores between children from different racial-ethnic groups, spanning preschool to high school (Jencks & Phillips, 1998; Lee, 2002; Lee & Burkam, 2002). In the United States, on measures of school readiness and academic achievement, Asian Americans achieve higher average scores than White students, who in turn achieve higher average scores than their Black and Latino peers (Jencks & Phillips, 1998; Lee, 2002; Reardon & Galindo, 2009). Because it has received a great deal of attention, the Black– White achievement gap is used to illustrate the major points of this article. The broad goal of this article, however, is to propose a model that applies to a variety of racial-ethnic and other achievement gaps.

Racial-ethnic achievement gaps are substantial life-span phenomena. By all accounts, the magni- tude of the Black–White achievement gap is consid- erable, ranging from .5 to 1.0 SD, depending on the sample and the measure (Jencks & Phillips, 1998; Lee, 2002; Reardon & Galindo, 2009; Reardon & Robinson, 2007; Vanneman, Hamilton, Anderson, & Rahman, 2009). The Black–White achievement gap affects individuals and the generation to which they belong, beginning in early childhood and spanning

all educational levels (Farkas, 2003). In terms of school readiness, research has consistently demon- strated that prior to school entry, Black students achieve lower average scores than White students (Brooks-Gunn, Klebanov, & Duncan, 1996; Duncan, Brooks-Gunn, & Klebanov, 1994; Lee & Burkam, 2002). Over the course of elementary school, the Black–White achievement gap appears to grow (Farkas, 2003; Fryer & Levitt, 2004, 2005; Phillips, Crouse, & Ralph, 1998).

The Black–White achievement gap is a highly consequential social problem. School readiness and academic achievement are associated with the kinds of jobs and wages people are able to secure. Racial- ethnic achievement gaps that begin at school entry and persist through school completion thus can influence racial-ethnic gaps in socioeconomic status (SES) across the life span (e.g., Levin, 2009; Reardon & Robinson, 2007). In turn, SES is robustly associ- ated with health (Adler, Boyce, Chesney, & Cohen, 1994; Levin, 2009). Furthermore, the health of any democratic society is predicated on the ability of its population to make informed choices at the ballot box. When large segments of the population are inadequately educated, democracy’s health is at risk.

As with any social problem, how policy makers, practitioners, and the public formulate the Black– White achievement gap’s cause will guide what is done, and what is not done, to solve the problem (Humphreys & Rappaport, 1993; McKown, 2005;

This study was made possible by a William T. Grant Founda- tion Scholar’s Award to Clark McKown. Thanks to Laura Gum- biner, Anne Gregory, Stephen Quintana, Michael Strambler, and Rhona Weinstein for their helpful comments on an earlier draft of this article.

Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Clark McKown, Rush NeuroBehavioral Center, 4711 Golf Road, Suite 1100, Skokie, IL 60076. Electronic mail may be sent to Clark_A_McKown@rush.edu.

© 2012 The Author Child Development © 2012 Society for Research in Child Development, Inc. All rights reserved. 0009-3920/2013/8404-0002 DOI: 10.1111/cdev.12033

Child Development, July/August 2013, Volume 84, Number 4, Pages 1120–1136

 

 

Seidman, 1983). Almost all accounts of racial-ethnic achievement gaps acknowledge the influence of multiple processes in multiple settings (e.g., Boykin, 1986; Garcia-Coll, 1990; Weinstein, 2002; Weinstein & McKown, 1998). Nevertheless, much prior work on the Black–White achievement gap has focused on specific processes operating in a limited range of contexts. For example, some have argued that racial differences in genetic endowment cause the gap (Jensen, 1969; Rushton & Jensen, 2005). Others have focused on the contribution of SES and family fac- tors (Brooks-Gunn, Klebanov, Smith, Duncan, & Lee, 2003), cultural values (Ogbu, 2002; Thernstrom & Thernstrom, 2002), academic stereotypes (Steele & Aronson, 1995), and degree of match between home and school environments (Brice-Heath, 1983; Tharp, 1989).

More focused accounts are sometimes criticized because they do not account for the entire racial- ethnic achievement gap, even though they are often interpreted as doing so. For example, in a critical review, Sackett, Hardison, and Cullen (2004) acknowledged that one social process—stereotype threat—can depress Black students’ test scores. However, they strongly questioned common inter- pretations of the research that stereotype threat is the sole cause of the Black–White test score gap, and that if it were eliminated, the gap would there- fore disappear.

That theory and research have developed in a targeted way is understandable—evaluating multi- factorial accounts of the gap’s origin is challenging. The conceptual challenge is to broaden inquiry without mounting atheoretical “fishing expeditions” that provide few insights. The practical challenge is to muster resources to meaningfully evaluate the combined influences of multiple social processes across key developmental contexts. What is needed is a theory broad and flexible enough to account for varied sources of social influence, yet specific enough to provide a parsimonious account of the achievement gap.

The purpose of this article is to describe social equity theory (SET), a novel account of social pro- cesses that together give rise to racial-ethnic achievement gaps. SET provides a heuristic for organizing and integrating research on racial-ethnic achievement gaps. SET is proposed as a theory because: (a) it makes specific commitments about the social processes that are relevant to understand- ing the achievement gap, (b) it offers a causal explanatory framework to explain the racial-ethnic achievement gap, and (c) it generates specific, falsi- fiable hypotheses.

SET Defined

SET describes social processes that contribute to racial-ethnic achievement gaps. SET explains mean differences in achievement by members of different racial-ethnic groups. There is, of course, consider- able within-group variability in academic readiness and achievement. Within-group and between-group differences in academic readiness and achievement are distinct. SET does not address the causes of individual variability in achievement. Rather, it explains factors that together create between-group differences in school readiness and achievement.

In the context of SET, the term social processes refers to transactions between individuals, including verbal and nonverbal communication directed from one person to another. The term social processes also refers to communications between individuals and social settings, in which an event or characteristic of the setting—apart from interpersonal interactions— communicates something of social consequence. For example, a poster depicting a civil rights event on a classroom wall may communicate something of social consequence without involving an interper- sonal communicative transaction.

SET adopts an ecological perspective (Bronfen- brenner, 1977; Kelly, 1987; Spencer, 1999; Weinstein, 2002) to formulate what social processes in what contexts create and maintain racial-ethnic achieve- ment gaps. SET includes four propositions about the origins of racial-ethnic achievement gaps:

1. Two classes of social process influence racial- ethnic achievement gaps. Direct influences are social processes that support achievement. Direct influences contribute to the racial-ethnic achievement gap when they are distributed dif- ferently to people from different racial-ethnic groups. Signal influences are cues that commu- nicate negative expectations about a child’s racial-ethnic group. When children from nega- tively stereotyped groups detect such cues, this can erode achievement.

2. Signal influences depend on children’s ability to detect cues signaling a stereotyped expecta- tion, and this ability increases significantly dur- ing the elementary grades.

3. Social processes affecting the achievement gap operate across a limited range of key develop- mental settings, and the relevant settings change lawfully with age.

4. Together, relevant direct and signal influences across developmental contexts account for the achievement gap.

Social Equity Theory 1121

 

 

From these propositions, it is possible to develop specific and falsifiable developmental hypotheses about the origins of racial-ethnic achievement gaps. What follows is a review of evidence supporting the existence of direct and signal influences on the achievement gap, their combined influence, and the contexts in which they influence racial-ethnic achievement gaps. The review focuses on research into the Black–White achievement gap. A sub- sequent section articulates specific hypotheses uniquely derived from SET. The article finishes with proposed standards of evidence to guide future work on SET and its component parts.

Evidence in Support of SET Propositions

Direct Influence on the Achievement Gap

Direct influences, defined. Direct influences are social processes that promote academic achieve- ment similarly for all children in all racial-ethnic groups. SET proposes that direct influences contrib- ute to racial-ethnic achievement gaps when they are systematically and unequally distributed to mem- bers of different racial-ethnic groups. Direct influ- ences on racial-ethnic achievement gaps may unfold at home, in school, with peers, and in neighbor- hoods.

Home. In the home, particularly for young chil- dren, parent–child interactions and the relationships within which they take place are important contexts for children’s development. A substantial body of research suggests that the characteristics and qual- ity of parent–child interactions influences preaca- demic and academic outcomes. For example, Baumrind (1966; see also Baumrind & Black, 1967), focusing largely on White middle-class samples, examined the relation between parenting styles and a variety of life outcomes among children. They examined two dimensions of parenting style: sup- portiveness and demandingness. Supportiveness referred to the level of expressed parental love, nur- turance, and responsiveness. Demandingness referred to the clarity of rules and the firmness and fairness of parental discipline practices. They found that when parents provided a combination of high support and high demand—what they called “authoritative” parenting—children had better aver- age academic, social, and emotional outcomes.

There is some evidence that what normative par- enting is varies from one racial-ethnic group to the next. Mandara and Murray (2002) found that Baumrind’s (1966) parenting styles typology charac- terized Black parenting, but that Black authoritative

parenting included greater demand and less com- promise than White authoritative parenting. In addition, the relation between parenting and aca- demic outcomes can differ for different groups. For example, at least two independent research groups have found that among Black children, the higher the overall neighborhood distress, the more strict parenting is associated with positive academic out- comes (Baldwin, Baldwin, & Cole, 1990; Gonzales, Cauce, Friedman, & Mason, 1996).

Prior research thus suggests that the same par- enting practices do not always promote the same academic outcomes for children from different racial-ethnic groups, leaving open the question of whether parenting is a direct influence. The litera- ture cited above suggests that what is optimal par- enting for the development of academic outcomes may be different for children from different racial- ethnic groups and in different contexts. However, the same research suggests that for children from all racial-ethnic groups, achievement-supporting parenting—in whatever form that takes for the child’s racial-ethnic group and context—plays a key role in the development of children’s preacademic and academic skills.

For optimal parenting practices to exert a direct influence on the Black–White achievement gap, it must be present at different average levels in Black and White homes. In an important review article, Brooks-Gunn and Markman (2005) reported that there are racial-ethnic differences in parenting prac- tices. They reported that, compared to White par- ents, Black parents on average engaged less frequent warm and sensitive parenting and more frequent negative and intrusive parenting. It is important to note that effect sizes were small, indi- cating a high degree of overlap in the distributions of parenting behavior. In addition, they reported differences in the frequency and richness of lan- guage exposure and availability of books and other stimulating materials, with Black parents on aver- age engaging in less frequent conversation and having fewer books and other media available.

Parenting is thus associated with preacademic and academic skill development, and optimal parenting is, on average, more available to White children than to Black children. That does not mean that these factors necessarily explain the Black– White achievement gap. It is possible, for example, that parenting and achievement gaps both arise from a third variable, such as Black–White socioeco- nomic differences. If this were true, in empirical models with SES and parenting as independent variables and academic score as the dependent vari-

1122 McKown

 

 

able, SES, but not parenting, would be associated with academic outcomes. Existing evidence runs contrary to this conclusion. Examining the ECLS–K data, when Lee and Burkam (2002) controlled for SES, the magnitude of the racial-ethnic school readi- ness gap was reduced, but not eliminated. Simi- larly, in secondary analyses of several large data sets, Magnuson and Duncan (2006) found that SES accounts for some, but not all, of the Black–White test score gap among young children. Furthermore, in middle childhood and adolescence, accounting for SES reduces, but does not eliminate the Black– White test score gap (Phillips, Brooks-Gunn, Duncan, Klebanov, & Crane, 1998).

When SES and racial-ethnic differences in parent- ing practices are accounted for, the size of the school readiness gap is dramatically reduced. For example, two studies found that among preschool- ers, maternal warmth and engagement account for much of the Black–White gap that remained when SES was accounted for (Brooks-Gunn et al., 1996, 2003). Another study found that when controlling for SES, all the residual early childhood Black– White reading readiness gap and much of the resid- ual math readiness gap was accounted for by family factors such as the frequency of reading (Lee & Burkam, 2002).

Parenting also helps explain the Black–White achievement gap in older children. For example, Mandara, Varner, Greene, and Richman (2009) examined the relation between parenting practices and the Black–White adolescent achievement gap. They examined multiple parenting practices, such as involving adolescents in decision making, paren- tal monitoring, number of household chores, school orientation, and maternal warmth. They reported that: (a) White parents generally engage in more achievement-promoting practices than Black par- ents, (b) this difference is largely accounted for by racial-ethnic differences in SES, and (c) accounting for multiple parenting practices that promote achievem

Changes To The DSM-4 To DSM-5.

Highlights of Changes from DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5

Changes made to the DSM-5 diagnostic criteria and texts are outlined in this chapter in the same order in which they appear in the DSM-5 classification. This is not an exhaustive guide; minor changes in text or wording made for clarity are not described here. It should also be noted that Section I of DSM-5 con- tains a description of changes pertaining to the chapter organization in DSM-5, the multiaxial system, and the introduction of dimensional assessments (in Section III).

Terminology The phrase “general medical condition” is replaced in DSM-5 with “another medical condition” where relevant across all disorders.

Neurodevelopmental Disorders Intellectual Disability (Intellectual Developmental Disorder) Diagnostic criteria for intellectual disability (intellectual developmental disorder) emphasize the need for an assessment of both cognitive capacity (IQ) and adaptive functioning. Severity is determined by adaptive functioning rather than IQ score. The term mental retardation was used in DSM-IV. However, intellectual disability is the term that has come into common use over the past two decades among medical, educational, and other professionals, and by the lay public and advocacy groups. Moreover, a federal statue in the United States (Public Law 111-256, Rosa’s Law) replaces the term “mental retarda- tion with intellectual disability. Despite the name change, the deficits in cognitive capacity beginning in the developmental period, with the accompanying diagnostic criteria, are considered to constitute a mental disorder. The term intellectual developmental disorder was placed in parentheses to reflect the World Health Organization’s classification system, which lists “disorders” in the International Classifica- tion of Diseases (ICD; ICD-11 to be released in 2015) and bases all “disabilities” on the International Classification of Functioning, Disability, and Health (ICF). Because the ICD-11 will not be adopted for several years, intellectual disability was chosen as the current preferred term with the bridge term for the future in parentheses. Communication Disorders The DSM-5 communication disorders include language disorder (which combines DSM-IV expressive and mixed receptive-expressive language disorders), speech sound disorder (a new name for phono- logical disorder), and childhood-onset fluency disorder (a new name for stuttering). Also included is social (pragmatic) communication disorder, a new condition for persistent difficulties in the social uses of verbal and nonverbal communication. Because social communication deficits are one component of autism spectrum disorder (ASD), it is important to note that social (pragmatic) communication disorder cannot be diagnosed in the presence of restricted repetitive behaviors, interests, and activities (the oth- er component of ASD). The symptoms of some patients diagnosed with DSM-IV pervasive developmen- tal disorder not otherwise specified may meet the DSM-5 criteria for social communication disorder.

Autism Spectrum Disorder Autism spectrum disorder is a new DSM-5 name that reflects a scientific consensus that four previously separate disorders are actually a single condition with different levels of symptom severity in two core

 

 

 

2 • Highlights of Changes from DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5

domains. ASD now encompasses the previous DSM-IV autistic disorder (autism), Asperger’s disorder, childhood disintegrative disorder, and pervasive developmental disorder not otherwise specified. ASD is characterized by 1) deficits in social communication and social interaction and 2) restricted repetitive behaviors, interests, and activities (RRBs). Because both components are required for diagnosis of ASD, social communication disorder is diagnosed if no RRBs are present.

Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder The diagnostic criteria for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in DSM-5 are similar to those in DSM-IV. The same 18 symptoms are used as in DSM-IV, and continue to be divided into two symp- tom domains (inattention and hyperactivity/impulsivity), of which at least six symptoms in one domain are required for diagnosis. However, several changes have been made in DSM-5: 1) examples have been added to the criterion items to facilitate application across the life span; 2) the cross-situational requirement has been strengthened to “several” symptoms in each setting; 3) the onset criterion has been changed from “symptoms that caused impairment were present before age 7 years” to “several inattentive or hyperactive-impulsive symptoms were present prior to age 12”; 4) subtypes have been replaced with presentation specifiers that map directly to the prior subtypes; 5) a comorbid diagnosis with autism spectrum disorder is now allowed; and 6) a symptom threshold change has been made for adults, to reflect their substantial evidence of clinically significant ADHD impairment, with the cutoff for ADHD of five symptoms, instead of six required for younger persons, both for inattention and for hyperactivity and impulsivity. Finally, ADHD was placed in the neurodevelopmental disorders chapter to reflect brain developmental correlates with ADHD and the DSM-5 decision to eliminate the DSM-IV chapter that includes all diagnoses usually first made in infancy, childhood, or adolescence.

Specific Learning Disorder Specific learning disorder combines the DSM-IV diagnoses of reading disorder, mathematics disorder, disorder of written expression, and learning disorder not otherwise specified. Because learning deficits in the areas of reading, written expression, and mathematics commonly occur together, coded speci- fiers for the deficit types in each area are included. The text acknowledges that specific types of read- ing deficits are described internationally in various ways as dyslexia and specific types of mathematics deficits as dyscalculia.

Motor Disorders The following motor disorders are included in the DSM-5 neurodevelopmental disorders chapter: devel- opmental coordination disorder, stereotypic movement disorder, Tourette’s disorder, persistent (chron- ic) motor or vocal tic disorder, provisional tic disorder, other specified tic disorder, and unspecified tic disorder. The tic criteria have been standardized across all of these disorders in this chapter. Stereotypic movement disorder has been more clearly differentiated from body-focused repetitive behavior disor- ders that are in the DSM-5 obsessive-compulsive disorder chapter.

Schizophrenia Spectrum and Other Psychotic Disorders Schizophrenia Two changes were made to DSM-IV Criterion A for schizophrenia. The first change is the elimination of the special attribution of bizarre delusions and Schneiderian first-rank auditory hallucinations (e.g., two or more voices conversing). In DSM-IV, only one such symptom was needed to meet the diagnostic requirement for Criterion A, instead of two of the other listed symptoms. This special attribution was

 

 

Highlights of Changes from DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5 • 3

removed due to the nonspecificity of Schneiderian symptoms and the poor reliability in distinguishing bizarre from nonbizarre delusions. Therefore, in DSM-5, two Criterion A symptoms are required for any diagnosis of schizophrenia. The second change is the addition of a requirement in Criterion A that the individual must have at least one of these three symptoms: delusions, hallucinations, and disorganized speech. At least one of these core “positive symptoms” is necessary for a reliable diagnosis of schizo- phrenia.

Schizophrenia subtypes The DSM-IV subtypes of schizophrenia (i.e., paranoid, disorganized, catatonic, undifferentiated, and residual types) are eliminated due to their limited diagnostic stability, low reliability, and poor validity. These subtypes also have not been shown to exhibit distinctive patterns of treatment response or lon- gitudinal course. Instead, a dimensional approach to rating severity for the core symptoms of schizo- phrenia is included in Section III to capture the important heterogeneity in symptom type and severity expressed across individuals with psychotic disorders.

Schizoaffective Disorder The primary change to schizoaffective disorder is the requirement that a major mood episode be pres- ent for a majority of the disorder’s total duration after Criterion A has been met. This change was made on both conceptual and psychometric grounds. It makes schizoaffective disorder a longitudinal instead of a cross-sectional diagnosis—more comparable to schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and major depres- sive disorder, which are bridged by this condition. The change was also made to improve the reliability, diagnostic stability, and validity of this disorder, while recognizing that the characterization of patients with both psychotic and mood symptoms, either concurrently or at different points in their illness, has been a clinical challenge.

Delusional Disorder Criterion A for delusional disorder no longer has the requirement that the delusions must be non- bizarre. A specifier for bizarre type delusions provides continuity with DSM-IV. The demarcation of delusional disorder from psychotic variants of obsessive-compulsive disorder and body dysmorphic disorder is explicitly noted with a new exclusion criterion, which states that the symptoms must not be better explained by conditions such as obsessive-compulsive or body dysmorphic disorder with absent insight/delusional beliefs. DSM-5 no longer separates delusional disorder from shared delusional dis- order. If criteria are met for delusional disorder then that diagnosis is made. If the diagnosis cannot be made but shared beliefs are present, then the diagnosis “other specified schizophrenia spectrum and other psychotic disorder” is used.

Catatonia The same criteria are used to diagnose catatonia whether the context is a psychotic, bipolar, depres- sive, or other medical disorder, or an unidentified medical condition. In DSM-IV, two out of five symp- tom clusters were required if the context was a psychotic or mood disorder, whereas only one symp- tom cluster was needed if the context was a general medical condition. In DSM-5, all contexts require three catatonic symptoms (from a total of 12 characteristic symptoms). In DSM-5, catatonia may be diagnosed as a specifier for depressive, bipolar, and psychotic disorders; as a separate diagnosis in the context of another medical condition; or as an other specified diagnosis.

 

 

4 • Highlights of Changes from DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5

Bipolar and Related Disorders Bipolar Disorders To enhance the accuracy of diagnosis and facilitate earlier detection in clinical settings, Criterion A for manic and hypomanic episodes now includes an emphasis on changes in activity and energy as well as mood. The DSM-IV diagnosis of bipolar I disorder, mixed episode, requiring that the individual simulta- neously meet full criteria for both mania and major depressive episode, has been removed. Instead, a new specifier, “with mixed features,” has been added that can be applied to episodes of mania or hy- pomania when depressive features are present, and to episodes of depression in the context of major depressive disorder or bipolar disorder when features of mania/hypomania are present.

Other Specified Bipolar and Related Disorder DSM-5 allows the specification of particular conditions for other specified bipolar and related disorder, including categorization for individuals with a past history of a major depressive disorder who meet all criteria for hypomania except the duration criterion (i.e., at least 4 consecutive days). A second condi- tion constituting an other specified bipolar and related disorder is that too few symptoms of hypoma- nia are present to meet criteria for the full bipolar II syndrome, although the duration is sufficient at 4 or more days.

Anxious Distress Specifier In the chapter on bipolar and related disorders and the chapter on depressive disorders, a specifier for anxious distress is delineated. This specifier is intended to identify patients with anxiety symptoms that are not part of the bipolar diagnostic criteria.

Depressive Disorders DSM-5 contains several new depressive disorders, including disruptive mood dysregulation disorder and premenstrual dysphoric disorder. To address concerns about potential overdiagnosis and overtreat- ment of bipolar disorder in children, a new diagnosis, disruptive mood dysregulation disorder, is includ- ed for children up to age 18 years who exhibit persistent irritability and frequent episodes of extreme behavioral dyscontrol. Based on strong scientific evidence, premenstrual dysphoric disorder has been moved from DSM-IV Appendix B, “Criteria Sets and Axes Provided for Further Study,” to the main body of DSM-5. Finally, DSM-5 conceptualizes chronic forms of depression in a somewhat modified way. What was referred to as dysthymia in DSM-IV now falls under the category of persistent depressive dis- order, which includes both chronic major depressive disorder and the previous dysthymic disorder. An inability to find scientifically meaningful differences between these two conditions led to their combi- nation with specifiers included to identify different pathways to the diagnosis and to provide continuity with DSM-IV.

Major Depressive Disorder Neither the core criterion symptoms applied to the diagnosis of major depressive episode nor the req- uisite duration of at least 2 weeks has changed from DSM-IV. Criterion A for a major depressive episode in DSM-5 is identical to that of DSM-IV, as is the requirement for clinically significant distress or impair- ment in social, occupational, or other important areas of life, although this is now listed as Criterion B rather than Criterion C. The coexistence within a major depressive episode of at least three manic symptoms (insufficient to satisfy criteria for a manic episode) is now acknowledged by the specifier “with mixed features.” The presence of mixed features in an episode of major depressive disorder in-

 

 

Highlights of Changes from DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5 • 5

creases the likelihood that the illness exists in a bipolar spectrum; however, if the individual concerned has never met criteria for a manic or hypomanic episode, the diagnosis of major depressive disorder is retained.

Bereavement Exclusion In DSM-IV, there was an exclusion criterion for a major depressive episode that was applied to depres- sive symptoms lasting less than 2 months following the death of a loved one (i.e., the bereavement exclusion). This exclusion is omitted in DSM-5 for several reasons. The first is to remove the implication that bereavement typically lasts only 2 months when both physicians and grief counselors recognize that the duration is more commonly 1–2 years. Second, bereavement is recognized as a severe psy- chosocial stressor that can precipitate a major depressive episode in a vulnerable individual, generally beginning soon after the loss. When major depressive disorder occurs in the context of bereavement, it adds an additional risk for suffering, feelings of worthlessness, suicidal ideation, poorer somatic health, worse interpersonal and work functioning, and an increased risk for persistent complex bereavement disorder, which is now described with explicit criteria in Conditions for Further Study in DSM-5 Section III. Third, bereavement-related major depression is most likely to occur in individuals with past personal and family histories of major depressive episodes. It is genetically influenced and is associated with similar personality characteristics, patterns of comorbidity, and risks of chronicity and/or recurrence as non–bereavement-related major depressive episodes. Finally, the depressive symptoms associated with bereavement-related depression respond to the same psychosocial and medication treatments as non–bereavement-related depression. In the criteria for major depressive disorder, a detailed footnote has replaced the more simplistic DSM-IV exclusion to aid clinicians in making the critical distinction be- tween the symptoms characteristic of bereavement and those of a major depressive episode. Thus, al- though most people experiencing the loss of a loved one experience bereavement without developing a major depressive episode, evidence does not support the separation of loss of a loved one from other stressors in terms of its likelihood of precipitating a major depressive episode or the relative likelihood that the symptoms will remit spontaneously.

Specifiers for Depressive Disorders Suicidality represents a critical concern in psychiatry. Thus, the clinician is given guidance on assess- ment of suicidal thinking, plans, and the presence of other risk factors in order to make a determination of the prominence of suicide prevention in treatment planning for a given individual. A new specifier to indicate the presence of mixed symptoms has been added across both the bipolar and the depressive disorders, allowing for the possibility of manic features in individuals with a diagnosis of unipolar de- pression. A substantial body of research conducted over the last two decades points to the importance of anxiety as relevant to prognosis and treatment decision making. The “with anxious distress” specifier gives the clinician an opportunity to rate the severity of anxious distress in all individuals with bipolar or depressive disorders.

Anxiety Disorders The DSM-5 chapter on anxiety disorder no longer includes obsessive-compulsive disorder (which is included with the obsessive-compulsive and related disorders) or posttraumatic stress disorder and acute stress disorder (which is included with the trauma- and stressor-related disorders). However, the sequential order of these chapters in DSM-5 reflects the close relationships among them.

 

 

6 • Highlights of Changes from DSM-IV-TR to DSM-5

Is there such a thing as a midlife crisis?

 

After completing the readings in Unit 6 and further researching the topic, post a two-paragraph response to the following:

Is there such a thing as a midlife crisis? Discuss the idea of a midlife crisis in terms of the physical, cognitive, and psychosocial changes in middle adulthood. Also:

  • If you believe there is such a thing as a midlife crisis, what developmental changes in middle adulthood might be the cause? Why do some middle-aged people experience it and others do not?
  • If you do not believe that a midlife crisis exists, explain why you think this myth perpetuates in our society. What developmental changes (or perhaps stages, i.e. Erikson or Maslow) might be mistaken for a midlife crisis?

Please make sure that your discussion comments abide by the Netiquette policy outlined in the syllabus.

Describe what you discovered in this content analysis.

In 1978, Gerbner, Gross, Jackson-Beeck, Jeffries-Fox, and Signorielli defined violence as “The overt expression of physical force (with or without weapon) against self or other, compelling action against one’s will on pain of being hurt or killed, or actually hurting or killing. Must be plausible and credible; no idle threats, verbal abuse, or comic gestures with no credible violent consequences. May be intentional or accidental; violent accidents, catastrophes, acts of nature are included.”

For this assignment, you will watch three television shows and analyze them for verbal and physical violence portrayed in the show. Use the attached document “Nonexperimental Designs,” located under the assignment tab, to complete the first part of the assignment.

In 250  words, do the following:

1.Describe what you discovered in this content analysis.

2.State the findings of your experiment. Explain how your experiment is reliable and/or valid.

3.Identify any variables in your experiment.

4.Copy and paste the tally sheet from “Nonexperimental Designs” at the end of your paper so it is included it in your study.

Prepare this assignment in the APA Style

PSY 452 – Experimental Psychology

Non-Experimental Designs Instructions

 

To better understand the concept of non-experimental designs, be sure to read all the assigned readings for this Topic before beginning the assignment:

 

1. For this assignment, you will watch three television shows from the genres listed below and analyze them for verbal and physical violence portrayed in the show. Choose a show that fits the following genres:

a. Situation comedy

b. Cartoon

c. Drama

Tally Sheet

 

1. On the Tally Sheet template below, tally the number of times you see a mode of aggression on the selected program.

a. Rate the overall violence using a 5-point scale from 1 (not at all violent) to 5 (extremely violent).

2. Collapse your data within each program category.

3. Determine the mean rate of acts per program hour for each modes of aggression.

4. Determine the overall mean violence rating for each category.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  Program #1 Program #2 Program #3
Program Name      
Time/Date      
Length in Minutes      
Number of Acts involving:

1. Violence to Body

     
2. Use of Weapon      
3. Physical Threat      
4. Verbal Threat      
5. Symbolic/Joking      
Total number of Aggressive Acts      
Overall Violence Rate:

1 (none) to 5 (extremely violent)