Provide two or three (2-3) major points to support your thesis statement. (Put each major point in a separate paragraph.)

Position Paper One – Media and Society
Due Week 5 and worth 200 points

This is the first of two (2) position papers based on the following scenario to be completed in this course.

Imagine that you are running for a state office (e.g., governor, senator, or Congressional representative) and you have to prepare a position paper for a debate on controversial issues in the news. (Select one (1) of the topics addressed in the first four weeks of this class.) Remember that you are addressing a significant segment of your state’s population and you want to be elected to public office, so your topic will have to have a broad appeal, such as the importance of family values, the fair treatment of women in the workplace (equal pay for equal work), the treatment of minorities, and the media and one’s self-image, among other topics from those chapters.

You will want your position paper to demonstrate critical thinking, sound logic, valid claims, personal passion, and credible support that is cited correctly because the paper will be provided to the news media before the debate and will be scrutinized by the media and reported on regarding these criteria.

Write a two to three (2-3) page (500 to 750 words) paper in which you:

  1. Introduce your position using a thesis statement in the first paragraph, including a quote, question, or statistic from your reliable sources and an overview of the main points you will cover. (It’s important to grab the audience’s interest and inform the audience of what the main and support points are.)
  2. Provide two or three (2-3) major points to support your thesis statement. (Put each major point in a separate paragraph.)
  3. Provide one (1) paragraph in which you identify and answer an expected argument against your view.
  4. Organize arguments and support your claims effectively.
  5. Demonstrate personal passion for your position and critical thinking with persuasive language, sound logic, valid claims, and credible support for the claims.
  6. Use the Strayer University Library at https://research.strayer.edu to locate and provide two to three (2-3) credible and reliable sources (in addition to the textbook) about current events, which have been published in the last five (5) years and are cited correctly in the position paper. (Wikipedia, dictionaries, and encyclopedias are unacceptable and will not count toward your number of credible sources.)

Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:

  • Be typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides; citations and references must follow Strayer Writing Standards. Check with your professor for any additional instructions.
  • Include a cover page containing the title of the assignment, the student’s name, the professor’s name, the course title, and the date. The cover page and the reference page are not included in the required assignment page length.

The specific course learning outcomes associated with this assignment are:

  • Apply critical thinking skills to the analysis of issues involving mass media and society.
  • Use technology and information resources to research issues in media and society.
  • Write clearly and concisely about media and society using proper writing mechanics.

What are the effects of couple counseling on strengthening the relationship between gay people in the United States?

Sampling

It is impossible to study the entirety of any particular population. However, researchers can collect data for their studies from a sample of a particular population. There are two methods of sampling available for researchers: probability sampling and nonprobability sampling. This week, you examine the terminology used for the sampling aspect of research as well as best practices for its implementation. Then you critique a research study’s use of sampling in order to further understand the relationship between sampling, causality, and generalizability.

Learning Objectives

Students will:
  • Create two sampling structures
  • Evaluate strengths and limitations of two sampling methods
  • Analyze samples in a case study
  • Analyze generalizability in a case study
  • Evaluate method and methodology used in a research study

Photo Credit: [Hero Images]/[Hero Images]/Getty Images

Learning Resources

Note: To access this week’s required library resources, please click on the link to the Course Readings List, found in the Course Materials section of your Syllabus.

Required Readings

Yegidis, B. L., Weinbach, R. W., & Myers, L. L.  (2018). Research methods for social workers (8th ed.). New York, NY:  Pearson.
Chapter 9, “Sampling Issues and Options” (pp. 202-222)

Optional Resources

Plummer, S.-B., Makris, S., & Brocksen S. M. (Eds.). (2014).Social work case studies: Foundation year. Baltimore, MD: Laureate International Universities Publishing. [Vital Source e-reader].
Social Work Research: Program Evaluation

Discussion 1: Sampling Structures

Probability and nonprobability are the two general categories of sampling. Probability sampling uses random selection, whereas nonprobability sampling does not. For example, if you wanted to study the effects of divorce on the psychological development of adolescents, you could gather a population of a certain number of adolescents whose parents were divorced. Then, out of that population, you could randomly select 25 of those people. If you wanted to use nonprobability sampling, you would choose specific people who had met predetermined criteria. For this Discussion, consider how samples would be chosen for both probability and nonprobability sampling structures.

By Day 3

Post your explanation of the following:

  • Using your research problem and the refined question you developed in Week 4, develop two sampling structures: probability and nonprobability.
  • Explain who would be included in each sample and how each sample would be selected.
  • Be specific about the sampling structures you chose, evaluating both strengths and limitations of each.

Please use the resources to support your answer.

By Day 5

Respond to a colleague’s post by suggesting an alternative sampling structure for their research question as well as an alternate way of selecting the sample. Please use the resources to support your answer.

Discussion 2: Generalizing Study Results

Generalizability is the extent to which research findings from your sample population can be applicable to a larger population. There are many best practices for ensuring generalizability. Two of those are making sure the sample is as much like the population as possible and making sure that the sample size is large enough to mitigate the chance of differences within the population. For this Discussion, read the case study titled “Social Work Research: Program Evaluation” and consider how the particular study results can be generalizable.

By Day 5

Post your explanation of who the sample is. Also explain steps researchers took to ensure generalizability. Be sure to discuss how the study results could possibly be generalizable. Please use the resources to support your answer.

By Day 7

Respond to a colleague’s post by suggesting two alternative ways that the study results could be generalizable. Please use the resources to support your answer.

Assignment: Research Design and Sampling

Using the empirical research article that your instructor approved in the Week 5 assignment, ask yourself: “Is this a quantitative research article or a qualitative research article?” Remember, in quantitative research, the emphasis is on measuring social phenomenon because it is assumed that everything can be observed, measured, and quantified. On the other hand, in qualitative research, it is assumed that social phenomenon cannot be easily reduced and broken down into concepts that can be measured and quantified. Instead, there may be different meanings to phenomenon and experiences. Often in qualitative research, researchers use interviews, focus groups and observations to gather data and then report their findings using words and quotations.

Consider how these different methods affect the sampling design and recruitment strategy, and ask yourself how the recruitment of research participants will affect the findings.

For this Assignment, submit a 3-4 page paper. Complete the following:

  • Read your selected empirical research article, and identify whether the study is a quantitative or qualitative study. Justify the reasons why you believe it is a quantitative or qualitative study. (Your instructor will indicate to you if you are correct in identifying the research design. This will point you to whether you will use the “Quantitative Article and Review Critique” or the “Qualitative Article and Review Critique” guidelines for the final assignment in week 10.)
  • Using the empirical research article, focus on the sampling method in the study and begin to evaluate the sampling method by answering the following:
    • Describe the sampling methods in your own words (paraphrase, do not quote from the article).
    • Describe the generalizability or the transferability of the research finding based on the sampling method.
    • Discuss the limitations the article identified with the sample and how those limitations affect the reliability or credibility.
    • Explain one recommendation you would make to improve the sampling plan of the study that would address these limitations in future research.

 

The Effectiveness of LGBT Couple Counseling in Enhancing the Wellbeing of Gay People in the United States.

Introduction 

In America, gay rights have come a long way since its legalization in 2015. With gay rights making a bid advance in the United States, more people of similar gender have come out to eliminate the stereotype that their relationships are always superficial. Instead, they present their relationships to be identical to those of the heterosexual people with the ability to remain committed and loving (Gonsiorek, 2014). Again, they are faced with similar challenges which include household chores, financial conflicts, family, as well as parenting. Despite the Supreme Court ruling that allowed equality and protection for the LGBT people in the United States, gay people continue to face discrimination in terms of housing, imprisonment, jobs and even parenting.

According to the new Gallup estimate, American adults identified as either lesbians, gay, bisexual or transgender totaling to 4.5 % of the entire population. This is approximately 11 million citizens. With the legalization, the number continues to rise wherein 2016 they comprised 4.1% and 3.6% in 2012. Despite the legalization and acceptance of gay people in the United States, they continue to suffer and live under fear of exploitation and discrimination on issues such as crimes and segregation (Curry, 2017). In America, 5% of the total hate crime committed is as a result of sexual orientation while 2% are due to individual gender identity. The society has not yet come to terms with accepting them as usual and part of the population thus making them quite a vulnerable group.

People identifying as lesbians, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, and asexual considers social stigma as the primary source of stress and anxiety in their lives. Thus, they tend to seek therapy from qualified therapists who can help them overcome the challenges (Blondeel et al., 2018). In that case, the LGBT people tend to be afraid and feel threatened for the expected reaction from the society especially in matters concerning their relationships and marriage. The common challenges among gay couples have led to the rise in the use of LGBT couple counseling before the wedding.

Research Objectives

General Objective

The general objective of the study will be to establish the effectiveness of LGBT couples counseling in enhancing the wellbeing of gay people in the United States.

Specific Objective

The specific objectives of the project will entail:

1. To establish how self-confidence from couple counseling enhances the well-being of gay people in the United States.

2. To determine the effects of couple counseling for improving the relationship between gay couples in the United States.

3. To establish how couple counseling promotes acceptance thus enhancing the wellbeing of gay people in the United States.

Research Questions

1. How does self-acceptance gained through couple counseling enhances the wellbeing of gay people in the United States?

2. What are the effects of couple counseling on strengthening the relationship between gay people in the United States?

3. How does LGBT couple counseling promote acceptance among gay people in the United States?

The significance of the Study

The study is considered important because it will give insight into the various challenges that the LGBT people in America face. Again, it will elaborate on the role of the social workers in ensuring equality and protection of the gay community. Besides, the findings of the research can be used to establish policies meant to enhance inclusion in America as well as provide the basis for conducting further studies on the issues affecting the LGBT people at large.

Limitations of the Study

Among the challenges that are likely to be faced during the study include limited time and budget for the research. The review will be extensive thus requiring enough time and money to cater to the entire research process. Additionally, LGBT people may not be willing to take part in the study as they fear discrimination and victimization. As a result, it might be difficult to access relevant and reliable information for the research.

Literature Review

Concept Definition

LGBT

The term LGBT is an acronym for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender. It is a word used to describe the people of other sexual orientation and gender identity other than the heterosexual. A lesbian refers to a woman who is sexually and emotionally attracted to fellow women. Gay is the male with sexual attraction towards fellow men. However, in some instances, the word gay is used to refer to lesbians, gay, and bisexuals all together. For Bisexuals, they are attracted to people of both sexes while transgender refers to people whose inner identity contradicts with the role associated with the portrayed gender.

Challenges Faced by LGBT People

Besides the rapidly growing cultural acceptance of diverse sexual and romantic orientation together with gender identification, LGBT people are also faced with oppression, discrimination, and marginalization. Prolonged cases of bias can result in stigma, depression, and stress cases. Research shows that LGBT people have a high chance of becoming suicidal and self-harm especially when they experience discrimination based on their sexual and gender identity (Graham et al., 2011). Besides, students associated with the grouping are said to have a high rate of experiencing bullying, social rejection, as well as a sexual assault which can lead to chronic stress among the victims (Higa et al., 2014).

Lytle et al. (2014) argues that in more than 37 states, LGBT people are discriminated against obtaining health insurance. The prevalence of discrimination has adverse effects on gay people. Often, they feel pressured to fit in the conventional ideas of the community of either being a male or a female (Curry, 2017). Based on their difference from the normal genders, they hide and stay segregated from the rest of the people to avoid being ridiculed, intimidated, and at times even sexually abused. The increased pressure can lead to the development of mental instability such as stress and depression that they need the guidance and advice of the social worker to manage and overcome. Besides obtaining the support and help in dealing with the toxic and harmful response from society, gay couples also seek to see counselors to understand their gender roles and stage disparities.

LGBT Couple Counseling

Kelley (2015) states that like other persons, LGBT people seek counseling for help while faced with many of the same challenges that affect the heterosexual individuals such as anxiety, depression, grief, and even couple therapy. They seek therapeutic assistance as a way of dealing with the stigma of mental health issues and the LGBT orientation.

In most cases, therapists address multiple issues that the gay people need to take into consideration especially in the case where they have chosen to become public. They give them directions and counsel on how to overcome the current challenges in society as a result of their orientation. The counseling sessions help to prepare the couple on dealing with the worst that the community can give ranging from discrimination to being abused and victimized.

1. Self-Confidence

During the counseling sessions, therapists are in a position to explore the issues of the couple and address the challenges effectively. This involves acting as the advocates for the marginalized group and encouraging them on the importance of accepting themselves as they are. Maintaining awareness increases the knowledge of the LGBT people both on their rights and privileges as the law in the nation provides them. The counselor often advises them to step out instead of confining themselves in the closets thus increasing their vulnerability.

2. Excellent Relationships

Engaging in constant communication and sharing experience between the gay people opens their minds and increase their interest in understanding one another. Counseling promotes positivity and enthusiasm where they learn to approach things and situations in life with optimism (Henry, 2013). This is not only for the social relation but also for the couple relationship where they learn to understand and support one another throughout the relationship.

3. Social Acceptance

Often, social workers engage in creating awareness beyond the LGBT community. According to research, the people around gay people are the primary source of adverse reactions that result in rejection and developing suicidal ideas. Therefore, the counselor advises the couple on the best behaviors to depict to ensure that they attract little rejection from society.

Gap

From the review, most of the studies conducted about the LGBT community are associated with the challenges that they face despite the legalization and protection under the law. However, a few studies have been undertaken about establishing the usefulness and effectiveness of the couple therapy and counseling in dealing with the challenges in the community. Objectively, the research will be conducted to determine how couple counseling improve the life of LGBT individuals in the United States. As a result, it will provide the answers to the research questions that relate to enhancing their confidence, deal with social rejection, as well as promote their relationship.

Variables 

The study will contain both the independent and dependent variables. The independent refers to the variable that can stand on its own (couple counseling) while the dependent needs and id influenced by the independent one (wellbeing of the LGBT people).

Independent Variables (Effective Couple Counseling) Improved Well-being 

 

Social acceptance

References

Blondeel, K., de Vasconcelos, S., García-Moreno, C., Stephenson, R., Temmerman, M., & Toskin, I. (2018). World Health Assembly». Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 96, 29-41L.

Curry, C. (2017). “9 Battles the LGBT Community in the US Is Still Fighting, Even in 2017. The Globl Citizen. Accessed from https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/9-battles-the-lgbt-community-in-the-us-is-still-fi/

Gonsiorek, J. C. (2014). Introduction to the first issue of Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity.

Graham, R., Berkowitz, B., Blum, R., Bockting, W., Bradford, J., de Vries, B., & Makadon, H. (2011). The health of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people: Building a foundation for better understanding. Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine.

Henry, M. M. (2013). Coming out: Implications for self-esteem and depression in gay and lesbian individuals (Doctoral dissertation, Humboldt State University).

Higa, D., Hoppe, M. J., Lindhorst, T., Mincer, S., Beadnell, B., Morrison, D. M. … & Mountz, S. (2014). Negative and positive factors associated with the well-being of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and questioning (LGBTQ) youth. Youth & Society, 46(5), 663-687.

Kelley, F. A. (2015). The therapy relationship with lesbian and gay clients. Psychotherapy, 52(1), 113.

Lee, C., Oliffe, J. L., Kelly, M. T., & Ferlatte, O. (2017). Depression and suicidality in gay men: Implications for health care providers. American journal of men’s health, 11(4), 910-919.

Lytle, M. C., Vaughan, M. D., Rodriguez, E. M., & Shmerler, D. L. (2014). Working with LGBT individuals: Incorporating positive psychology into training and practice. Psychology of sexual orientation and gender diversity, 1(4), 335.

The research question

Introduction to Research Proposal

Name

Institution Affiliation

The Effectiveness of LGBT Couple Counseling in Enhancing the Wellbeing Gay People in the United States.

Introduction 

In America, the gay right has come a long way till its legalization in 2015. With gay rights making a bid advance in the United States, more people of similar gender have come out to eliminate the stereotype that their relationships are always superficial and belief. Instead, they present their relationships to be identical to those of the heterosexual people with the ability to remain committed and loving (Gonsiorek, 2014). Again, they are faced with similar challenges which include household chores, financial conflicts, family, as well as parenting. Despite the Supreme Court ruling that allowed equality and protection for the LGBT people in the United States, gay people continue to face discrimination in terms of housing, imprisonment, jobs and even parenting.

According to the new Gallup estimate, American adults identified as either lesbians, gay, bisexual or transgender total to 4.5 % of the entire population. This is approximately 11 million citizens. With the legalization, the number continues to rise wherein 2016 they comprised 4.1% and 3.6% in 2012. Despite the legalization and acceptance of gay people in the United States, they continue to suffer and live under fear of exploitation and discrimination on issues such as crimes and segregation (Curry, 2017). In America, 5% of the total hate crime committed is as a result of sexual orientation while 2% are due to individual gender identity. The society has not yet come to terms with accepting them as usual and part of the population thus making them quite a vulnerable group.

People identifying as lesbians, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, questioning, and asexual considers social stigma as the primary source of stress and anxiety in their lives. Thus, they tend to seek therapy from qualified therapists who can help them overcome the challenges (Blondeel et al., 2018). In that case, the LGBT people tend to be afraid and feel threatened for the expected reaction from the society especially in matters concerning their relationships and marriage. The common challenges among gay couples have led to the rise in the use of LGBT couple counseling before the wedding.

Research Objectives

General Objective

The general objective of the study will be to establish the effectiveness of LGBT couples counseling in enhancing the wellbeing of gay people in the United States.

Specific Objective

The specific objectives of the project will entail:

1. To establish how self-confidence from couple counseling enhances the well-being of gay people in the United States.

2. To determine the effects of couple counseling for improving the relationship between gay couples in the United States.

3. To establish how couple counseling promotes acceptance thus enhancing the wellbeing of gay people in the United States.

Research Questions

1. How does self-acceptance gained through couple counseling enhances the wellbeing of gay people in the United States?

2. What are the effects of couple counseling on strengthening the relationship between gay people in the United States?

3. How does LGBT couple counseling promote acceptance among gay people in the United States?

The significance of the Study

The study is considered important because it will give insight into the various challenges that the LGBT people in America face. Again, it will elaborate on the role of the social workers in ensuring equality and protection of the gay community. Besides, the findings of the research can be used to establish policies meant to enhance inclusion in America as well as provide the basis for conducting further studies on the issues affecting the LGBT people at large.

Limitations of the Study

Among the challenges that are likely to be faced during the study include limited time and budget for the research. The review will be extensive thus requiring enough time and money to cater to the entire research process. Additionally, LGBT people may not be willing to take part in the study as they fear discrimination and victimization. As a result, it might be difficult to access relevant and reliable information for the research.

Literature Review

Concept Definition

LGBT

The term LGBT is an acronym for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender. It is a word used to describe the people of other sexual orientation and gender identity other than the heterosexual. A lesbian refers to a woman who is sexually and emotionally attracted to fellow women. Gay is the male with sexual attraction towards fellow men. However, in some instances, the word gay is used to refer to lesbians, gay, and bisexuals all together. For the Bisexuals, they are attracted to people of both sexes while transgender refers to people whose inner identity contradicts with the role associated with the portrayed gender.

Challenges Faced by LGBT People

Besides the rapidly growing cultural acceptance of diverse sexual and romantic orientation together with gender identification, LGBT people are also faced with oppression, discrimination, and marginalization. Prolonged cases of bias can result in stigma, depression, and stress cases. Research shows that LGBT people have a high chances of becoming suicidal and self-harm especially when they experience discrimination based on their sexual and gender identity (Graham et al., 2011). Besides, students associated with the grouping are said to have a high rate of experiencing bullying, social rejection, as well as a sexual assault which can lead to chronic stress among the victims (Higa et al., 2014).

Lytle et al. (2014) argues that in more than 37 states, LGBT people are discriminated against obtaining health insurance. The prevalence of discrimination has adverse effects on gay people. Often, they feel pressured to fit in the conventional ideas of the community of either being a male or a female (Curry, 2017). Based on their difference from the normal genders, they hide and stay segregated from the rest of the people to avoid being ridiculed, intimidated, and at times even sexually abused. The increased pressure can lead to the development of mental instability such as stress and depression that they need the guidance and advice of the social worker to manage and overcome. Besides obtaining the support and help in dealing with the toxic and harmful response from society, gay couples also seek to see counselors to understand their gender roles and stage disparities.

LGBT Couple Counseling

Kelley (2015) states that like other persons, LGBT people seek counseling for help while faced with many of the same challenges that affect the heterosexual individuals such as anxiety, depression, grief, and even couple therapy. They seek therapeutic assistance as a way of dealing with the stigma of mental health issues and the LGBT orientation.

In most cases, therapists address multiple issues that the gay people need to take into consideration especially in the case where they have chosen to become public. They give them directions and counsel on how to overcome the current challenges in society as a result of their orientation. The counseling sessions help to prepare the couple on dealing with the worst that the community can give ranging from discrimination to being abused and victimized.

1. Self-Confidence

During the counseling sessions, therapists are in a position to explore the issues of the couple and address the challenges effectively. This involves acting as the advocates for the marginalized group and encouraging them on the importance of accepting themselves as they are. Maintaining awareness increases the knowledge of the LGBT people both on their rights and privileges as the law in the nation provides them. The counselor often advises them to step out instead of confining themselves in the closets thus increasing their vulnerability.

2. Excellent Relationships

Engaging in constant communication and sharing experience between the gay people opens up their minds and increase their interest in understanding one another. Counseling promotes positivity and enthusiasm where they learn to approach things and situations in life with optimism (Henry, 2013). This is not only for the social relation but also for the couple relationship where they learn to understand and support one another throughout the relationship.

3. Social Acceptance

Often, social workers engage in creating awareness beyond the LGBT community. According to research, the people around gay people are the primary source of adverse reactions that result in rejection and developing suicidal ideas. Therefore, the counselor advises the couple on the best behaviors to depict to ensure that they attract little rejection from society.

Gap

From the review, most of the studies conducted about the LGBT community are associated with the challenges that they face despite the legalization and protection under the law. However, a few studies have been undertaken about establishing the usefulness and effectiveness of the couple therapy and counseling in dealing with the challenges in the community. Objectively, the research will be conducted to determine how couple counseling improve the life of LGBT individuals in the United States. As a result, it will provide the answers to the research questions that relate to enhancing their confidence, deal with social rejection, as well as promote their relationship.

Variables 

The study will contain both the independent and dependent variables. The independent refers to the variable that can stand on its own (couple counseling) while the dependent needs and id influenced by the independent one (wellbeing of the LGBT people).

Independent Variables (Effective Couple Counseling) Improved Well-being 

 

Social     acceptance

References

Blondeel, K., de Vasconcelos, S., García-Moreno, C., Stephenson, R., Temmerman, M., & Toskin, I. (2018). World Health Assembly». Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 96, 29-41L.

Curry, C. (2017). “9 Battles the LGBT Community in the US Is Still Fighting, Even in 2017. The Globl Citizen. Accessed from https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/9-battles-the-lgbt-community-in-the-us-is-still-fi/

Gonsiorek, J. C. (2014). Introduction to the first issue of Psychology of Sexual Orientation and Gender Diversity.

Graham, R., Berkowitz, B., Blum, R., Bockting, W., Bradford, J., de Vries, B., & Makadon, H. (2011). The health of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people: Building a foundation for better understanding. Washington, DC: Institute of Medicine.

Henry, M. M. (2013). Coming out: Implications for self-esteem and depression in gay and lesbian individuals (Doctoral dissertation, Humboldt State University).

Higa, D., Hoppe, M. J., Lindhorst, T., Mincer, S., Beadnell, B., Morrison, D. M. … & Mountz, S. (2014). Negative and positive factors associated with the well-being of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and questioning (LGBTQ) youth. Youth & Society, 46(5), 663-687.

Kelley, F. A. (2015). The therapy relationship with lesbian and gay clients. Psychotherapy, 52(1), 113.

Lee, C., Oliffe, J. L., Kelly, M. T., & Ferlatte, O. (2017). Depression and suicidality in gay men: Implications for health care providers. American journal of men’s health, 11(4), 910-919.

Lytle, M. C., Vaughan, M. D., Rodriguez, E. M., & Shmerler, D. L. (2014). Working with LGBT individuals: Incorporating positive psychology into training and practice. Psychology of sexual orientation and gender diversity, 1(4), 335.

Here is a link to the article that was approved

Evaluating Qualitative Research for Social Work Practitioners Cynthia A. Lietz Luis E. Zayas Abstract:

Diane Sharkey RE: Discussion 1 – Week 7COLLAPSE

Using your research problem and the refined question you developed in Week 4, develop two sampling structures: probability and nonprobability.

The question I created in week 4 was: “which treatment strategy is most effective at decreasing PTSD symptoms in college-aged female sexual assault victims?”

For probability, I would use the simple random sampling and create a sampling frame of 100 cases with participating colleges throughout the state (Yegidis, Weinbach, and Myers, 2018).

My research question lends itself better to a non probability sampling. I feel a mixture between snowball and convenience sampling would be best suited for my research question (Yegidis et al., 2018).

Explain who would be included in each sample and how each sample would be selected.

100 female, college-aged sexual assault victims would be included in all of the samples I use.

With probability sampling, the information about the study could be disseminated via fliers that are passed out on each college campus. I could partner with organizations such as National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) who can provide volunteers to visit the participating colleges and get the word out. This distribution of information may have to occur multiple times at colleges until 100 participants Once the list of 100 participants has been created, I would assign each person a number and use a computer program to randomly generate 25 numbers that I would then correlate with the correct names.

In reference to non probability convenience sampling, I could contact colleagues throughout the state who would be willing to speak with their (eligible) clients and ask if they would be amenable to joining my study (Yegidis et al., 2018). Additionally, using the snowball sampling I could ask participants as they contact me to reach out to anyone they know who might be interested in participating (Yegidis et al., 2018). Once I have enough participants, I would then begin the study.

Be specific about the sampling structures you chose, evaluating both strengths and limitations of each.

Regarding the probability sampling method, a strength is using fliers to help create the base for the sample. If I was able to obtain a list of potential participants from police records (which would be unethical and also illegal), it would limit my study to only women who have reported the crime. However, using the distribution of pamphlets it allows for the possibility of victims who have not reported their assaults. Alimitation would be the amount of time it could take to get 100 people willing to participate in the research study as many college students do not take fliers and if they do many throw them away without reading them. Additionally, victims may not want to relive their experience or disclose to strangers therefore making it (potentially) more difficult to obtain the sample frame.

Yegidis et al. (2018) discuss the importance of limiting bias as much as possible in all sampling methods. However, they place emphasis on the significance of limiting bias especially in quantitative studies, which mine is (Yegidis et al., 2018). A limitation of using snowball sampling would be geographic location. Going by word of mouth usually means most of the people will be located in the same general area, composing similar populations. Furthermore, the participants could have discussed their experiences with each other (since they know one another) and this could potentially bias/impact the recollection of their attacks. If I used convenience sampling from my colleagues, many of the women may have already received counseling services and may already have opinions regarding what works best. A strength of both of these non probability sampling methods is the large number of participants I could find in a short amount of time.

Reference

Yegidis, B. L., Weinbach, R. W., & Myers, L. L.  (2018). Research methods for social workers (8th ed.). New York, NY:  Pearson.

Angelica Wiggins RE: Discussion 2 – Week 7COLLAPSE

Per Yegidis, Weinbach & Myers (2018), “a sample is a subset of cases selected for study from among people or objects within a defined population. It is chosen to represent the population.” In the study, the sample is low income families in California that are receiving TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) which in California is known as CalWORKS. Recipients have options of immediate job readiness (Job Club) help, remedial education for recipients lacking basic skills, and vocational training at local community colleges and adult education centers for those seeking higher level education and skills (Plummer, Makris & Brocksen, 2014).

According to Plummer, Makris & Brocksen (2014), “generalizability is important in explanatory research, which attempts to identify relationships between variables within research samples and provide evidence that the same relationships exist beyond those samples.” In the study, generalizability was ensured by using large enough sample sizes that provided diversity and covered all aspects of the populations in California. Single mothers were represented in the sample and there was a clear relationship present with single mothers and assistance in childcare services. With this study being so large there will be a wide range of results at the end of the study.

Reference

Plummer, S.-B., Makris, S., & Brocksen, S. M. (2014). Social work case studies: Foundation year. Baltimore, MD: Laureate International Universities Publishing.

Yegidis, B. L., Weinbach, R. W., & Myers, L. L. (2018). Research methods for social workers (8th ed.). New York, NY: Pearson.

Data Collection and Measurement

Data Collection and Measurement

This week, you are introduced to preparation and operationalization procedures for measuring data. In addition, you are introduced to a variety of ways to acquire quantitative data, including secondary data, systematic observation, interviews, questionnaires, and surveys. Regardless of which method for acquiring data you use, be aware of the potential for distortion and/or response bias, or forms of measurement error. For these reasons, it is imperative to understand issues of reliability and validity in measurement.

Learning Objectives

Students will:
  • Analyze how to measure a phenomenon
  • Analyze measurement instruments
  • Evaluate measurement instruments used in a research study

Photo Credit: [Hero Images]/[Hero Images]/Getty Images

Learning Resources

Note: To access this week’s required library resources, please click on the link to the Course Readings List, found in the Course Materials section of your Syllabus.

Required Readings

Yegidis, B. L., Weinbach, R. W., & Myers, L. L.  (2018). Research methods for social workers (8th ed.). New York, NY:  Pearson.
Chapter 10, “Measurements Concepts and Issues” (pp. 223-245)
Chapter 11,” Methods for Acquiring Research Data” (pp. 246-275)
Chapter 12, “Data Collection Instruments” (pp. 277-294)

Windle,   G., Bennett, K. M., & Noyes, J. Windle, G., Bennett, K. M., &   Noyes, J. (2011). A methodological review of resilience scales. Health and Quality of Life Outcomes, 9, 2-18. Retrieved from Walden Library databases

Walker, K. E., & Arbreton, A. J. A. (2001). Working together to build Beacon Centers in San Francisco: Evaluation findings from 1998–2000. Philadelphia, PA: Public/Private Ventures. (see pp. 96-99 for measures). Retrieved from http://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED464212.pdf
See pp. 96–99 for measures

Document: Tips When Evaluating Instruments

Discussion 1: Methods of Measuring

The center point of research studies is the body of data collected to answer the research question. These data must be measured, which is the act of taking an abstract concept (e.g., depression, anger, etc.), sorting them out and quantifying them in some cohesive way in order to construct meaning—but how can you measure something that is not easily quantifiable?

Choosing an appropriate measurement tool requires consideration of a number of different issues including reliability, validity, appropriateness for use with a specific group or culture, availability, and potential cost. Sometimes, social workers will attempt to create their own set of questions to tap into or measure a concept. This may appear to be an easy thing to do; however, writing questions to measure a phenomenon is more challenging than it would seem. For example, how do we know it measures what we want it to measure?  In the first discussion this week, you will have the opportunity to create your own questions to measure a phenomenon of your interest. In the second discussion, you will compare the measure you created with an existing instrument that measures the same phenomenon.

To prepare: Choose one phenomenon or issue that a client may be dealing with (for example, depression, anxiety, or family conflict). Consider how you would evaluate the client’s progress in this area. Create questions with response options that would capture this phenomenon or client issue.

By Day 3
  • Identify the phenomenon you would measure and explain how you conceptualize this phenomenon.
  • Provide at least 3 questions you would use to measure this phenomenon and explain how these questions operationalize the phenomenon.
  • Define reliability in 2-3 sentences and give one example of how you would establish reliability for the questions you created.
  • Define validity in 2-3 sentences and give one example of how you would establish validity for the questions you created.
  • Create a measurement plan to assess the phenomenon.
    • Describe the methodology you would use to collect data using your measurement tool (your method for acquiring this research data).
    • Explain the advantages and disadvantages of your choices.
By Day 5

Respond to a colleague’s post by suggesting two alternative methods for measuring their phenomenon. Explain why your suggestions have value. Please use the resources to support your answer

 

Discussion 2: Evaluating Existing Measures

In discussion 1, you considered how you might create an instrument for measuring a phenomenon or client issue. For this week’s Discussion 2, choose and evaluate an existing instrument to measure the concept you identified in Discussion 1. Consider how you would compare your original measurement to the existing measurement.

To Prepare: Review the following at the Walden Library on how to find existing instruments:

http://academicguides.waldenu.edu/library/testsmeasures

By Day 5

Posta brief explanation of the existing measurement instrument that you identified. Then, compare your original measurement approach to the existing instrument. Next, explain how you would revise or replace your original measurement plan. Finally explain the advantages and/or disadvantages of using existing instruments for measurement. Please use the Learning Resources to support your answer.

By Day 7

Respond to a colleague’s post by suggesting one alternative advantage or disadvantage of their chosen existing instrument of measurement. Explain why your suggestions have value. Please use the resources to support your answer.

Colleague’s  Response for Discussion 1

Respond to a colleague’s post by suggesting two alternative methods for measuring their phenomenon. Explain why your suggestions have value. Please use the resources to support your answer

Angelica Wiggins RE: Discussion 1 – Week 8COLLAPSE

Per Yegidis, Weinbach & Myers (2018), “In research, measurement is the process of sorting and, when possible, quantifying information in a consistent, systematic fashion. It entails collecting data in relation to certain variables and assigning the appropriate value categories or values to individual cases.” The phenomenon I would measure is depression. There are different kinds of depression which require different measures and treatment. Clinicians may use interviews to evaluate current problems or symptoms and to gather previous history whether it is family related or stressors that are encountered.

The first question I would ask is “do your symptoms interfere with your daily life and functioning?” second, “how long do your symptoms last?” third, “how do you handle these symptoms?” These questions can determine what approach needs to be taken. As aforementioned every treatment is different and it should be fitting for the person receiving treatment. When using operationalization, you want to make sure the variable is in alignment with the culture of the individual.

Reliability can be defined as a way to show consistency and ensure that the measurement produced the same results each time its tested. Test-Retest reliability would be used to ask the same questions to the client or participants.

According to Yegidis, Weinbach & Myers (2018), “When evaluating measurement, validity refers to the degree of fit between the construct we are trying to measure and the instrument or method we are using to measure it.” To establish validity, we can evaluate the client’s progress on a follow up and note any changes pertaining to the questions previously noted.

A plan that I would use is an assessment of questions or a questionnaire. Inputting a scale or a score range on the questionnaire could help make the assessment more precise.

An advantage would be that the tools selected would be aligned with the culture of the client so the outcome is expected to be positive. A disadvantage would be if client information during assessment was not accurate or true.

Discussion 2 response

Angelica Wiggins RE: Discussion 2 – Week 8COLLAPSE

I chose to measure depression and focused on its effect on the people experiencing it. The questions aligned with this measurement were, “do your symptoms interfere with your daily life and functioning?” second, “how long do your symptoms last?” third, “how do you handle these symptoms?” I used a questionnaire to test this measurement. The measurement instrument that I located through research provided a survey to test depression as well. The questionnaire consisted of a 64-item measure utilizes a dichotomous response format of agree and disagree for all items (Fajkowska, Domaradzka & Wytykowska, 2018).

The use of surveys and questionnaires is very popular. I would not replace this method, I would revise it by making it more individualistic and not so generic with the same questions on it for each person. I would also ensure that it is done in person to assure that it is being completed. One advantage is that there will be a higher response rate. A problem that is encountered when it is not in person and a researcher uses the option of mail, is low rate of return of completed instruments (Yegidis, Weinbach & Myers, 2018).

By explaining any concerns you have about the generalizability of the study (external validity) and what aspect of the research design might limit generalizability

There are several different types of research designs. Each design is intended to respond to a particular type of research question. The type of research design depends on the type of research questions asked. For this Discussion, select one of the articles from the reading list and consider several classifications of group research designs.

Post your response to the following: Describe which groups are compared in the research. Then, classify the research design as follows:

  1. By explaining whether the study is pre-experimental (cross-sectional, one-shot case study, and longitudinal), experimental (control group with pretest and posttest, posttest only, or four-group design), or quasi-experimental (comparing one group to itself at different times or comparing two different groups)
  2. By indicating what the researchers report about limitations of the study
  3. By explaining concerns you have regarding internal validity and the ability of the study to draw conclusions about causality
  4. By explaining any concerns you have about the generalizability of the study (external validity) and what aspect of the research design might limit generalizability

Please use the resources to support your answer.