|
. Create an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in Exercise 3, beginning with this claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55- mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.” Weight: 15%
|
Thoroughly created an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in Exercise 3, beginning with this claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55-mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.”
23.0 pts
|
Satisfactorily created an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in Exercise 3, beginning with this claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55-mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.”
20.0 pts
|
Partially created an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in Exercise 3, beginning with this claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55-mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.”
17.0 pts
|
Did not submit or incompletely created an argument map based on the influence diagram presented in Case 1.3 and complete all the criteria provided in Exercise 3, beginning with this claim: “The U.S. should return to the 55-mph speed limit in order to conserve fuel and save lives.”
0.0 pts
|
|
23.0 pts
|
|
Include in the map as many warrants, backings, objections, and rebuttals as possible. Weight: 15%
|
Thoroughly included in the map as many warrants, backings, objections, and rebuttals as possible.
23.0 pts
|
Satisfactorily included in the map as many warrants, backings, objections, and rebuttals as possible.
20.0 pts
|
Partially included in the map as many warrants, backings, objections, and rebuttals as possible.
17.0 pts
|
Did not submit or incompletely included in the map as many warrants, backings, objections, and rebuttals as possible.
0.0 pts
|
|
23.0 pts
|
|
Assume that the original qualifier was “certainly”; indicate whether the qualifier changes as we move from a simple, static, uncontested argument to a complex, dynamic and contested argument. Weight: 10%
|
Thoroughly assumed that the original qualifier was “certainly”; thoroughly indicated, whether the qualifier changes as we move from a simple, static, uncontested argument to a complex, dynamic and contested argument.
15.0 pts
|
Satisfactorily assumed that the original qualifier was “certainly”; satisfactorily indicated whether the qualifier changes as we move from a simple, static, uncontested argument to a complex, dynamic and contested argument.
13.0 pts
|
Partially assumed that the original qualifier was “certainly”; partially indicated, whether the qualifier changes as we move from a simple, static, uncontested argument to a complex, dynamic and contested argument.
11.0 pts
|
Did not submit or incompletely assumed that the original qualifier was “certainly”; did not submit or incompletely indicated whether the qualifier changes as we move from a simple, static, uncontested argument to a complex, dynamic and contested argument.
0.0 pts
|
|
15.0 pts
|
|
Apply the argument mapping procedures presented in Chapter 8 to analyze the pros and cons (or strengths and weaknesses) of the recommendations that the United States should not intervene in the Balkans. (Refer to Demonstration Exercise 3, Chapter 8.) Weight: 15%
|
Thoroughly applied the argument mapping procedures presented in Chapter 8 to analyze the pros and cons (or strengths and weaknesses) of the recommendations that the United States should not intervene in the Balkans.
22.0 pts
|
Satisfactorily applied the argument mapping procedures presented in Chapter 8 to analyze the pros and cons (or strengths and weaknesses) of the recommendations that the United States should not intervene in the Balkans.
19.0 pts
|
Partially applied the argument mapping procedures presented in Chapter 8 to analyze the pros and cons (or strengths and weaknesses) of the recommendations that the United States should not intervene in the Balkans.
16.0 pts
|
Did not submit or incompletely applied the argument mapping procedures presented in Chapter 8 to analyze the pros and cons (or strengths and weaknesses) of the recommendations that the United States should not intervene in the Balkans.
0.0 pts
|
|
22.0 pts
|
|
Write a one (1) page analysis that uses critical thinking to assess the overall plausibility of the claim: “The conflict in Bosnia is somebody else’s trouble. The U.S. should not intervene militarily.” Weight: 20%
|
Thoroughly wrote a one (1) page analysis that uses critical thinking to assess the overall plausibility of the claim: “The conflict in Bosnia is somebody else’s trouble. The U.S. should not intervene militarily.”
30.0 pts
|
Satisfactorily wrote a one (1) page analysis that uses critical thinking to assess the overall plausibility of the claim: “The conflict in Bosnia is somebody else’s trouble. The U.S. should not intervene militarily.”
26.0 pts
|
Partially wrote a one (1) page analysis that uses critical thinking to assess the overall plausibility of the claim: “The conflict in Bosnia is somebody else’s trouble. The U.S. should not intervene militarily.”
23.0 pts
|
Does not meet the required number of references.
0.0 pts
|
|
30.0 pts
|
|
Complete an argument map to illustrate your analysis. Weight: 10%
|
Thoroughly completed an argument map to illustrate your analysis.
15.0 pts
|
Satisfactorily completed an argument map to illustrate your analysis.
13.0 pts
|
Partially completed an argument map to illustrate your analysis.
11.0 pts
|
Did not submit or incompletely completed an argument map to illustrate your analysis.
0.0 pts
|
|
15.0 pts
|
|
2 references Weight: 5%
|
Meets number of required references; all references high quality choices.
7.0 pts
|
Meets number of required references; most references quality choices.
6.0 pts
|
Meets the required number of references; some or all references poor quality choices.
5.0 pts
|
Does not meet the required number of references.
0.0 pts
|
|
7.0 pts
|
|
Clarity, writing mechanics, and formatting requirements Weight: 10%
|
0-2 errors present
15.0 pts
|
3-4 errors present
13.0 pts
|
5-6 errors present
11.0 pts
|
More than 6 errors present
0.0 pts
|
|
15.0 pts
|
|
Total Points: 150.0
|