Was Dr. Caldwell’s treatment of Melanie and the other hungries justified?
following the template
you do not need read all the text, only pick up 4 useful quote
this is a debate, not academic writing
Save your time - order a paper!
Get your paper written from scratch within the tight deadline. Our service is a reliable solution to all your troubles. Place an order on any task and we will take care of it. You won’t have to worry about the quality and deadlines
Order Paper NowTHE SCENARIO
In an ALTERNATIVE REALITY of The Girl With All the Gifts, Dr. Caroline Caldwell survives her
wounds and is not killed but hungries. The world of The Girl With All of the Gifts also changes—humans
and the hungries have come to an agreement that they will create a society where they co-exist. In an
effort to forge this new society, both the hungries and the humans have decided to put Dr. Caroline
Caldwell on trial for her masterminding of the hungry experiments that took place at the army base in
Home Counties.
Note: We may assume that The Girl With All of the Gifts world is the same as ours. This means that the
historical events we have learned about in this course also happened in the world of The Girl With All of
the Gifts.
THE QUESTION up for debate AT THE TRIAL is:
Was Dr. Caldwell’s treatment of Melanie and the other hungries justified?
• The “Defense” will be defending Dr. Caldwell’s actions as justified, and will be demanding her
full exoneration from the alleged “crimes.”
• The “Prosecution” will be condemning Dr. Caldwell’s actions as unjustifiable, and will be
demanding that she be held responsible. You are not arguing for a specific form of punishment.
Due via ELMS by 11:59 pm the day before your discussion section
Files accepted: .doc, .docx, .pdf
Prosecution Evidence
(Against Caldwell—treatment NOT justified)
QUOTE #1
Quote #1 Citation (Use the bibliography format for Chicago-Style citations.)
[add citation here]
Quote #1 (Course assigned materials only! Films are allowed, but lectures are not!)
[add quote here]
Context for Quote #1 (What is the context of this quote in the original text? What themes/issues are present in the original text that will be valuable for your argument? You will explicitly link these themes/issues to your argument in the “explanation” below.)
[add context for quote #1 here]
Explanation of Quote #1 (How does this quote support your argument? Provide a detailed explanation—do not assume that the quote speaks for itself.)
[add explanation for quote #1 here]
QUOTE #2
Quote #2 Citation (Use the bibliography format for Chicago-Style citations.)
[add citation here]
Quote #2 (Course assigned materials only! Films are allowed, but lectures are not!)
[add quote here]
Context for Quote #2 (What is the context of this quote in the original text? What themes/issues are present in the original text that will be valuable for your argument? You will explicitly link these themes/issues to your argument in the “explanation” below.)
[add context for quote #2 here]
Explanation of Quote #2 (How does this quote support your argument? Provide a detailed explanation—do not assume that the quote speaks for itself.)
[add explanation for quote #2 here]
Defense Evidence
(In Support of Caldwell—treatment was justified)
QUOTE #1
Quote #1 Citation (Use the bibliography format for Chicago-Style citations.)
[add citation here]
Quote #1 (Course assigned materials only! Films are allowed, but lectures are not!)
[add quote here]
Context for Quote #1 (What is the context of this quote in the original text? What themes/issues are present in the original text that will be valuable for your argument? You will explicitly link these themes/issues to your argument in the “explanation” below.)
[add context for quote #1 here]
Explanation of Quote #1 (How does this quote support your argument? Provide a detailed explanation—do not assume that the quote speaks for itself.)
[add explanation for quote #1 here]
QUOTE #2
Quote #2 Citation (Use the bibliography format for Chicago-Style citations.)
[add citation here]
Quote #2 (Course assigned materials only! Films are allowed, but lectures are not!)
[add quote here]
Context for Quote #2 (What is the context of this quote in the original text? What themes/issues are present in the original text that will be valuable for your argument? You will explicitly link these themes/issues to your argument in the “explanation” below.)
[add context for quote #2 here]
Explanation of Quote #2 (How does this quote support your argument? Provide a detailed explanation—do not assume that the quote speaks for itself.)
[add explanation for quote #2 here]
Page 1 of 1
