the writer’s arguments effective?

I need to prove is the writer’s arguments are effective ? we are not gonna talk about the content of the essay we just want to prove if the authors arguments make sense ? is he or she using statistics to prove his point ? i need a clear thesis statament showing the 3 reasons as to why the writer is not effective . the I form is not allowed. you dont need an extra source. you use the articile i provided you …Choose one article only …..there should be in text citation doesnt matter APA OR MLA