COMPREHENSIVE INCOME ATTRIBUTABLE TO SHAREOWNERS OF THE COCA-COLA COMPANY

Comparative Analysis Case

The Coca-Cola Company and PepsiCo, Inc.

The financial statements of Coca-Cola and PepsiCo are presented in Appendices C and D, respectively. The companies’ complete annual reports, including the notes to the financial statements, are available online.

Instructions
Use the companies’ financial information to answer the following questions.

What was the effective tax rate in 2014 for Coca-Cola and PepsiCo? Why might their tax rates differ?

THE COCA-COLA COMPANY AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF INCOME
Year Ended December 31,201420132012
(In millions except per share data)
NET OPERATING REVENUES$ 45,998$ 46,854$ 48,017
Cost of goods sold17,88918,42119,053
GROSS PROFIT28,10928,43328,964
Selling, general and administrative expenses17,21817,31017,738
Other operating charges1,183895447
OPERATING INCOME9,70810,22810,779
Interest income594534471
Interest expense483463397
Equity income (loss) — net769602819
Other income (loss) — net(1,263)576137
INCOME BEFORE INCOME TAXES9,32511,47711,809
Income taxes2,2012,8512,723
CONSOLIDATED NET INCOME7,1248,6269,086
Less: Net income attributable to noncontrolling interests264267
NET INCOME ATTRIBUTABLE TO SHAREOWNERS OF THE COCA-COLA COMPANY$ 7,098$ 8,584$ 9,019
BASIC NET INCOME PER SHARE1$ 1.62$ 1.94$ 2.00
DILUTED NET INCOME PER SHARE1$ 1.60$ 1.90$ 1.97
AVERAGE SHARES OUTSTANDING4,3874,4344,504
Effect of dilutive securities637580
AVERAGE SHARES OUTSTANDING ASSUMING DILUTION4,4504,5094,584

1Calculated based on net income attributable to shareowners of The Coca-Cola Company.

THE COCA-COLA COMPANY AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF COMPREHENSIVE INCOME
Year Ended December 31,201420132012
(In millions)
CONSOLIDATED NET INCOME$ 7,124$ 8,626$ 9,086
Other comprehensive income:
  Net foreign currency translation adjustment(2,382)(1,187)(182)
  Net gain (loss) on derivatives35715199
  Net unrealized gain (loss) on available-for-sale securities714(80)178
  Net change in pension and other benefit liabilities(1,039)1,066(668)
TOTAL COMPREHENSIVE INCOME4,7748,5768,513
Less: Comprehensive income (loss) attributable to noncontrolling interests2139105
TOTAL COMPREHENSIVE INCOME ATTRIBUTABLE TO SHAREOWNERS OF THE COCA-COLA COMPANY$ 4,753$ 8,537$ 8,408
THE COCA-COLA COMPANY AND SUBSIDIARIES CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS
December 31,20142013
(In millions except par value)
ASSETS
  CURRENT ASSETS
    Cash and cash equivalents$ 8,958$ 10,414
    Short-term investments9,0526,707
  TOTAL CASH, CASH EQUIVALENTS AND SHORT-TERM INVESTMENTS18,01017,121
    Marketable securities3,6653,147
    Trade accounts receivable, less allowances of $331 and $61, respectively4,4664,873
    Inventories3,1003,277
    Prepaid expenses and other assets3,0662,886
    Assets held for sale679
  TOTAL CURRENT ASSETS32,98631,304
  EQUITY METHOD INVESTMENTS9,94710,393
  OTHER INVESTMENTS3,6781,119
  OTHER ASSETS4,4074,661
  PROPERTY, PLANT AND EQUIPMENT — net14,63314,967
  TRADEMARKS WITH INDEFINITE LIVES6,5336,744
  BOTTLERS’ FRANCHISE RIGHTS WITH INDEFINITE LIVES6,6897,415
  GOODWILL12,10012,312
  OTHER INTANGIBLE ASSETS1,0501,140
                 TOTAL$92,023$ 90,055Pepsico, Inc. is a leading global food and beverage company with a complementary portfolio of enjoyable brands, including Frito-Lay, Gatorade, Pepsi-Cola, Quaker, and Tropicana. Through its operations, authorized bottlers, contract manufacturers, and other third parties, PepsiCo makes, markets, distributes, and sells a wide variety of convenient and enjoyable beverages, foods, and snacks, serving customers and consumers in more than 200 countries and territories. To access PepsiCo’s complete annual report, including notes to the financial statements, follow these steps:Go to http://www.pepsico.com/Investors.Select SEC Filings and then the 10K, dated 2/12/2015 (select the pdf version).Select Entire document.The Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements begin on page 73.Consolidated Statement of IncomePepsiCo, Inc. and SubsidiariesFiscal years ended December 27, 2014, December 28, 2013 and December 29, 2012(in millions except per share amounts

Complete a worksheet for consolidated financial statements for 2016. Include columns for eliminations and adjustments, consolidated income, NCI, controlling retained earnings, and consolidated balance sheet.

Problem 3-3 (LO 4) Sophisticated equity method adjustments, consolidated worksheet.

(This is the same as Problem 3-2, except that the sophisticated equity method is used.) On January 1, 2015, Paro Company purchases 80% of the common stock of Solar Company for $320,000. On this date, Solar has common stock, other paid-in capital in excess of par, and retained earnings of $50,000, $100,000, and $150,000, respectively. Net income and dividends for two years for Solar Company are as follows:

20152016
Net income$60,000$90,000
Dividends20,00030,000

On January 1, 2015, the only undervalued tangible assets of Solar are inventory and the building. Inventory, for which FIFO is used, is worth $10,000 more than cost. The inventory is sold in 2015. The building, which is worth $30,000 more than book value, has a remaining life of10 years, and straight-line depreciation is used. The remaining excess of cost over book value is attributable to goodwill.

The trial balances for Paro and Solar are as follows:

Paro CompanySolar Company
Inventory, December 31100,00050,000
Other Current Assets136,000180,000
Investment in Solar CompanyNote 1
Land50,00050,000
Buildingsand Equipment350,000320,000
Accumulated Depreciation(100,000)(60,000)
Goodwill
Other Intangibles20,000
Current Liabilities(120,000)(40,000)
Bonds Payable(100,000)
Other Long-Term Liabilities(200,000)
Common Stock—Paro Company.(200,000)
Other Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Paro Company(100,000)
Retained Earnings—Paro Company(203,600)
Common Stock—Solar Company(50,000)
Other Paid-In Capital in Excess of Par—Solar Company(100,000)
Retained Earnings—Solar Company(190,000)
Net Sales(520,000)(450,000)
Cost of Goods Sold300,000260,000
Operating Expenses120,000100,000
Subsidiary IncomeNote 1
Dividends Declared—Paro Company50,000
Dividends Declared—Solar Company30,000
Note 1: To be calculated

Required

    1. Prepare a value analysis and a determination and distribution of excess schedule.

    2. Paro Company carries the investment in Solar Company under the sophisticated equity method. In general journal form, record the entries that would be made to apply the equity method in 2015 and 2016.

    3. Compute the balance that should appear in Investment in Solar Company and in Subsidiary Income on December 31, 2016 (the second year). Fill in these amounts on Paro Company’s trial balance for 2016.

    4. Complete a worksheet for consolidated financial statements for 2016. Include columns for eliminations and adjustments, consolidated income, NCI, controlling retained earnings, and consolidated balance sheet.

Compare the new alternative (Cloud-Integrated Communications System) with the previously selected one (in the 2nd question) under the new conditions (including salvage values and for nine years).

Middle East Technical University (METU) is currently using a Voice over IP (VoIP) phone system that was installed in 2007. The system is owned by Aftermath and is jointly managed by the METU telecommunications staff and Aftermath. The university staff is responsible for the day-to-day management, while Aftermath is responsible for the hardware and software maintenance, and licensing. Early cost models suggest that the university could save at least $56,000 annually and increase service by implementing and managing its own telecommunications infrastructure such as the Unified Communications System.

The main component of the existing VoIP system is shown in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Main component of the existing VoIP System

While the current VoIP implementation system serves well, the university seeks an advanced VoIP system, so-called the “Unified Communications System”. A market search on the new system reveals that the main services offered by the new system are: e-mail services, security systems, emergency communications systems. The “Unified Communications System” also provides mobility solutions using single-number reach and softphones installed on mobile devices and laptop computers, video, collaboration and conferencing tools, and instant messaging. Those features increase the attractiveness of the system for every increasing number of mobile professionals.

All relevant financial data for the existing and proposed VoIP systems are described in Table 1 and Table 2.

Table 1: Expenditure Data for the Existing VoIP System

Financial Data for the Existing VoIP System
QuantityVoIP RateVoIP MonthlyAnnual
Standart Phone120.0020.452454.0029448.00
Soft Phone Only0.0016.75
Advanced Phone100.0015.751575.0018900.00
Staff (Salaries)84900.00
VoIP Monthly Est.20475.00
VoIP Annual (including staff)214600.00
Contract renewal per 10 years110000.00
Expected life time: 25 Years

Table 2: Expenditure Data for the Proposed System, Unified Communications System

Financial Data for the Proposed Unified Communications System
Life(in years)QuantityUnit Cost (in Turkish Lira (TL))Total
Hardware8535514.00177570.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance8178100.00781.00Annual payment starting year 0
Conference Phone10208880.00177600.00At the beginning of each life cycle
License10202075.0041500.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance10208.40168.00Annual payment starting year 2
Standard Phone5400250.00100000.00At the beginning of each life cycle
License5400130.7552300.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance54009.153660.00Annual payment starting year 1
Soft Phone Only1010173.731737.30At the beginning of each life cycle
License101043.92439.20At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance101020.45204.50Once in 2 years, starting year 0
Professional Service (Installation)One time192850.0092850.00At the beginning
Staff (Salaries)Annual105850.00105850.00Starting year 1

After the proper engineering economic analysis of the existing and proposed systems, another alternative has investigated. The Cloud-Integrated Communications System makes use of the cloud technology and provides larger amount of data storage area. The relevant financial data for the IC communications system are given in Table 3.

Table 3: Expenditure Data for the new alternative – Cloud Integrated Communications System

Financial Data for the New alternative — Cloud-Integrated Communications Syste
Life(in years)QuantityUnit Cost (in Turkish Lira (TL))Total
Hardware4642000.00252000.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance42147.00294.00Annual payment starting year 0
Conference Phone10207140.00142800.00At the beginning of each life cycle
License102025417.00508340.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance10209.00180.00Annual payment starting year 2
Standard Phone7250255.0063750.00At the beginning of each life cycle
License7250128.0032000.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance725017.874467.50Annual payment starting year 1
Soft Phone Only108147.001176.00At the beginning of each life cycle
License108347.002776.00At the beginning of each life cycle
Support and Maintenance1084.4535.60Once in 2 years, starting year 0
Professional Service (Installation)One time147850.0047850.00At the beginning
Staff (Salaries)Annual83850.0083850.00Starting year 1

After the proper engineering economic analysis of the existing and proposed systems, another alternative has investigated. The Cloud-Integrated Communications System makes use of the cloud technology and provides larger amount of data storage area. The relevant financial data for the IC communications system are given in Table 3.

Table 3: Expenditure Data for the new alternative – Cloud Integrated Communications System

As a new alternative for the METU is introduced, a new engineering economy analysis between the previously selected and the Cloud-Integrated Communications System should be conducted. Considering the ever increasing advances in electronics technology, the university administration plans to change its communications system together with its components after 9 years of use. The estimated salvage values at the end of year 9, are 3,750,000?, 5,450,000? and 7,000,000?, for the existing, Unified Communications and Cloud-Integrated Systems respectively.

Questions and Discussions

METU uses 2% real interest rate per year. Since inflation estimates differ for each year, the university wants to use adjusted rates for the next ten years. The estimate of the tenth year will be used for all times. Unsurprisingly, the junior engineering economy (IE 347) class is well known by the METU, so, administrators ask for your help for the inflation estimates and market interest rates. Perform a small research on the long-term yearly inflation rate estimates for Turkey and discuss. Report the estimates you selected along with proper references and citations.

Compare the existing VoIP system with the proposed Unified Communications System by Annual Worth or Present Worth Analysis. For the existing system, use the market rate(s) you have found in the 1st question and, use the market rate of 1.0087% per month compounded monthly for the proposed system. Please, clearly show the steps of your analysis and indicate which alternative is better.

Compare the new alternative (Cloud-Integrated Communications System) with the previously selected one (in the 2nd question) under the new conditions (including salvage values and for nine years). Before conducting an analysis, define the type of investments for the two alternatives and find corresponding rates (Rate of Return or Internal Rate of Return) accordingly. After deciding the promise of the alternatives, conduct an Incremental Rate of Return Analysis to find the best alternative.

How sensitive are your findings against different realizations of the yearly inflation rate and real interest rate? For fixed real rate of return, compare the alternatives under 1% higher and 1% lower inflation rate cases. Select the best plan in each case and discuss. For fixed inflation rate, compare the alternatives under 1% higher and 1% lower real interest rate cases. Select the best plan in each case and discuss.

Remarks

State your assumptions clearly.

Present all your work in an appropriately organized report.

Use Excel as much as possible. If necessary, make your calculations in separate sheets of an Excel file.

Submit your Excel file along with your report. The quality of your Excel file will be a part of grading. To get a credit, your file should be neat, easily understandable and flexible such that the results of varying parameters can be obtained easily

Using the same forecast as in requirement 1 construct Manny’s budget for raw materials purchases in June and the total for the 2nd quarter (You will also have to complete the budget for May) Complete the template provided which already has information for April and May.

Manny Fold owns a factory that specializes in making titanium valves for high performance engines on a just in time basis. Thus, Manny produces what he sells in a particular month. There are no inventories of finished goods or work in process. However, Manny does require that an inventory of                direct raw materials equal to 20% of next month’s production requirement be available at the end of each month. To build his business and gain new customers Manny has extended generous credit terms to his customers. While Manny is confident about the fundamentals of his business, he is concerned about the possible income and cash flow implications.

The variable costs of producing a valve are budgeted at $7.20 per valve for direct materials (3/4 pound of titanium alloy costing $9.60 per pound), $2.80 per valve for direct labor, and $5.50 per valve for variable manufacturing overhead. Fixed manufacturing overhead is budgeted at $74,700 per month during the 2nd quarter. The detailed components of variable and fixed overhead are as listed below.

For variable overhead, electric power is budgeted at $2.30 per unit, indirect labor is budgeted at $2.50 per unit, and supplies are budgeted at $.70 per unit. For fixed overhead depreciation is budgeted at

$10,000 per month, Supervision and other factory salaries are budgeted at $40,000 per month, property tax and insurance combined are budgeted at $8,000 per month (which have been paid in advance through June 15 – see below), maintenance is budgeted at $7,000 per month, licensing fees and permits to use proprietary technology are budgeted at $3,400 per month, and other miscellaneous fixed overhead expenses are budgeted at $6,300 per month.

Manny’s customers drive a hard bargain because they can easily switch suppliers. They all do pay eventually, but many of them take their time about doing so and Manny is reluctant to get tough with them for fear they will take their business elsewhere. He tells you that all his sales are on credit (no cash sales). He typically collects only 10% of sales in the month of the sale, 30% of sales in the month after the sale and 60% of sales two months later (for example 10% of June sales would be collected in June, 30% in July and 60% in August). On the other hand, he must pay for 70% of his materials purchases in the same month of the purchase and 30% in the month after. Cash costs of labor and overhead other than depreciation, property taxes and insurance are paid in the same month they are incurred. Property taxes and insurance are paid in advance through June 15. The amount due for the next 6 months (starting June 16) must be paid in early June.

All of the selling and administrative expenses are fixed. Monthly fixed selling and administrative costs, other than interest, amount to $43,600, of which $6,000 is depreciation. These operating costs, excepting depreciation, are paid in cash in the month incurred. Manny has large tax loss carry forwards from a previous unsuccessful business venture. Therefore, he does not expect to pay any income taxes this year. (In other words you may ignore income taxes).

Manny plans to buy new equipment costing $80,000 during the month of June. This equipment will be ready for use starting in July.

The budgeted selling price of valves for April, May, and June is $23 per valve. Because of market competition there is not much flexibility to adjust the price and the price is expected to be stable during the 2nd quarter. Manny budgeted sales in units for April at 17,000 units. For May he expects to sell only 18,500 units. He has projected sales of 20,000 units for June and 18,000 units for July.

Manny requires a minimum cash balance of $10,000 at the end of each month. If the budgeted month end cash balance will fall below this level Manny plans to borrow enough cash at the beginning of that same month to keep his ending balance up to the minimum level. Manny’s bank charges him interest at the rate of ½ % per month on the balance outstanding during that month. Manny’s bank charges him interest at the rate of ½ % per month on the balance outstanding during that month. Manny pays the interest at the beginning of the following month and plans to repay as much as he can at the beginning of that month without letting his budgeted cash balance go below $10,000 at month end. (On the budgeted income statement round interest expense to the nearest dollar)

The company’s managerial accountant has resigned unexpectedly before the 2nd quarter budget could be completed. You have been contracted to complete the master budget for June and for the 2nd quarter (including some missing numbers from May). Balances as of March 31 for all relevant accounts have already been calculated by this accountant together with some of the amounts for April and May. You may assume that these balances and amounts shown in the tables below are correct.

REQUIREMENTS:

1)                      Construct Manny’s budgeted income statement for June and the total for the 2nd quarter. April and May have already been provided. Complete the template provided below. Show any necessary calculations. (7 points)

2)                      Using the same forecast as in requirement 1 construct Manny’s budget for raw materials purchases in June and the total for the 2nd quarter (You will also have to complete the budget for May) Complete the template provided which already has information for April and May. (2 points)

3)                      Using the same forecast as you used in requirement 1 construct Manny’s cash budgets for June and the total for the 2nd quarter (You will also have to provide the missing number for May payments for purchases). Complete the templates provided below which already have information for April and May. Show any necessary calculations. (3 points)

4)                      Using the same forecast as you used in requirement 1 construct Manny’s budgeted balance sheet at the end of June. Complete the template provided which already has the March 31 balances. (3 points)

5)                      During March Manny actually produced and sold 16,500 valves. Actual sales revenues were $381,950. Actual costs and the original March budget based on 16,000 valves were as detailed in the table below. Complete the table by constructing a flexible budget based on 16,500 valves and determining the variances for the performance report. Use the template provided below for your answer. (7 points)

6)                      Write a brief report explaining some possible reasons why Manny’s profits were different from the amount projected in the master budget for March (2 points).

REQUIREMENT 1

Budgeted Income Statement

AprilMayJune2nd Quarter
SALES REVENUES$391,000$425,500
DIRECT MATERIALS USED($122,400)($133,200)
DIRECT LABOR($47,600)($51,800)
VARIABLE OVERHEAD($93,500)($101,750)
CONTRIBUTION MARGIN$127,500
FIXED OVERHEAD($74,700)($74,700)
FIXED OPERATING EXPENSES($43,600)($43,600)
OPERATING INCOME$ 9,200
INTEREST EXPENSE$0
NET INCOME$9,200

REQUIREMENT #2   BUDGETED PURCHASES OF TITANIUM ALLOY (direct material)

AprilMayJune2nd Quarter
Valves to be produced17,00018,50020,000
X Pounds per unit0.750.75
Titanium to be used12,75013,875
Desired ending inventory (20%)2,775
Pounds of Titanium Needed15,525
Less: Beginning Inventory2,5502,775
Pounds to be purchased12,975
Cost per pound$9.60
Cost of Purchases$124,560

REQUIREMENT #3

COMPUTATION OF CASH COLLECTIONS (Use this to calculate March & Feb sales)

AprilMayJune2nd Quarter
Sales Made 2 Months Ago$213,900$220,800
Sales Made 1 Month Ago$110,400$117,300
Sales Made this Month$39,100$42,550
Total Cash Collections$363,400$380,650

COMPUTATION OF CASH PAYMENTS

AprilMayJune2nd Quarter
Payments for purchases of materials$122,184 (used to calculate March purchases)
Payments for direct Labor$47,600$51,800
Payments for Variable Overhead$93,500$101,750
Payments for Fixed Overhead$56,700$56,700
Payments for Property Taxes and Insurance$0$0
Payments for other operating expenses$37,600$37,600
Capital Expenditures$0$0
Total Cash Payments$357,584
AprilMayJune2nd Quarter
Beginning Balance of Cash$10,324$16,140
Cash Collections$363,400$380,650
Total cash available$373,724$396,790
Less: Cash Payments$357,584
Ending Cash Balance Before Financing:$16,140
Borrowings$0
Repayments$0
Interest Payments$0
End Cash Balance$16,140

REQUIREMENT #4: BUDGETED BALANCE SHEET FOR JUNE 30

March 31June 30
ASSETS:Current Assets
Cash$10,324
Accounts Receivable$545,100
Inventory (raw materials)$24,480
Prepaid Insurance and Property Taxes$20,000
Total Current Assets$599,904
Equipment and Furniture$880,000
Accumulated Depreciation($540,000)
Equipment & Furniture (net)$340,000
Total Assets$939,904
LIABILITIES AND EQUITY
Liabilities (all current)
Accounts Payable$34,992
Interest Payable0
Bank Loans Payable0
Total Liabilities$34,992
Owner’s Equity(Net income increases this)$904,912
Total Liabilities and Equity$939,904

Actual Costs and Template for Requirement #5 Use this page to answer this requirement.

Performance Report for March

Cost ItemActual resultsFlexible Budget VarianceFlexible Budget for 16,500 unitsSales Volume VarianceStatic Master Budget for 16,000 units
Sales Revenues$381,950$368,000
Direct Materials used$118,720$115,200
Direct Labor$45,600$44,800
Electric Power$38,454$36,800
Indirect Labor$49,360$40,000
Supplies$16,686$11,200
Supervision and other salaries$37,858$40,000
Maintenance$8,925$7,000
Insurance and property tax$8,000$8,000
Permits and license fees$3,400$3,400
Factory depreciation$10,000$10,000
Other Overhead expenses$8,650$6,300
Total Production Expenses?$322,700
Total Selling & Administrative Expenses$39,867$43,600
Total Expenses?$366,300
Operating Income?$1,700