Using Sources Effectively

Response statement

Chapter 6-Using Sources effectively

 

Save your time - order a paper!

Get your paper written from scratch within the tight deadline. Our service is a reliable solution to all your troubles. Place an order on any task and we will take care of it. You won’t have to worry about the quality and deadlines

Order Paper Now

Please make sure that the document is 2 full pages, double-spaced, 1-inch margins, Times New Roman 12, a supporting title
The summary should cover:
a) the author’s main point—What is the main focus of the reading, the overarching thesis?
b) the assumptions he/she works from—What are the specific points that the author is attempting to get across?
c) the evidence or examples used to support the assertions made
d) the author’s overall purpose—What does the author attempt to accomplish by writing this piece?

2 other brmat,

fevelop-

tof sites |gyou?

\r her p. (^ V is [e, what lirWeb b a look

Iprofile, archer.

5 notes)

fpw this Nation-

CHAPTER 6 Using Sources Effectively

The abilities to find and document sources and to develop an argument about or interpretation of them have many applications in school and on the job. The genres of researched writing used in academic disciplines include the argumentative research paper (often called a term paper), the proposal, the annotated bibliography, the book review, the literature review, the personal research report (often called an “I-Search” paper, the name given to it by Ken Macrorie, an early advocate of this genre). You may be asked to a build a Web site based on library research. You may be asked to simply report on your research, or to use it as a starting point for experimentation or observation in the laboratory or on field observations. Usually oral presentations and the visuals that sup- port them are rooted in extensive research. Research reports in the sciences (lab reports) and social sciences, although their formats differ from papers in the humanities, usually begin with a review of the previous research that led to the hypothesis currently under investigation. All these genres of researched writing involve similar strategies for find- ing and evaluating sources, taking notes, and using quotations, summaries, and para- phrases skillfully. However, when and how sources are used and how they are cited vary for different kinds of writing and from field to field. Thus, these general information literacy and research writing skills must be adapted to meet discipline-specific expecta- tions for format, style, and means of presentation in specific academic fields.

SKILLS FOR ACADEMIC INQUIRY: QUOTATION, PARAPHRASE, SUMMARY, AND SYNTHESIS There are four basic means for using sources when writing researched papers and reports: quotation, paraphrase, summary, and synthesis. These techniques help writers progress from taking notes to drafting. It is always necessary to cite sources as you use them and to consistently distinguish between your own words and ideas and those of your sources.

1. Quotations are exact repetitions of a writer’s work. Quotations are less often used in disciplines that use APA (American Psychological Association) style than those who use MLA (Modern Language Association) style because arguments in most

101

 

 

102 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

disciplines that use APA depend more on summary and synthesis of previous research than on close analysis of texts.

2. Paraphrases are restatements of the writer’s ideas in your own words, following the source closely in the order in which an argument is developed or evidence is laid out. Paraphrases must be clearly identified as such, by direct attribution to the author, because they can be mistaken for your own thinking.

3. Summaries give an overall representation of a writer’s argument or part of one, and also must also be identified as representing the ideas of the original as they are moved from notes to drafts.

4. Syntheses draw on more than one source in order to show relationships among methodologies, assumptions, and conclusions.

Summaries and syntheses of other writers’ work make up the “literature review” that opens most academic papers and provides the context for most academic arguments. Any aspects of understanding or response that occur to you while taking notes and working with sources make drafting a researched paper easier, so write your interpreta- tions, questions, and responses into your notes, using a consistent method (font, color, etc.) to distinguish your voice from the voice of the author.

Quoting

Quotations always must be exact copies of the original, whether copied or cut and pasted, and in your notes they should always be enclosed in quotation marks and accompanied by a reference to the source. One convenient way to keep references attached to citations while taking notes and drafting is to attach a footnote to each quo- tation, which can then travel with the citation as you use the source for various projects. Add each source to your working bibliography, so that you can easily copy it into the reference pages of each project.

FOCUS POINTS: US

m Remember that whenever you reproduce a source’s wording, even for a few words, you must put quotation marks around it. You may not add or delete anything from the quoted text, unless you use brackets (for adding) or ellipses (for deleting).

a Be very careful not to take a quotation out of context in a way that changes or distorts its meaning. For example, Jacob Bronowski’s statement quoted in Chapter 1 would be severely misrepresented by cutting out a few words of that statement, even if ellipses were correctly used. Notice the difference between the following statements: [The book] will bring home to the nonsdentist how the scientific method really works: that

we invent a model and then test its consequences, and that it is this conjunction of imag- ination and realism that constitutes the inductive method.

[The book] will bring home to the nonsdentist how the scientific method really works: that we invent a model . . . and that it is this conjunction of imagination and realism that constitutes the inductive method.

m When taking notes, copv Quotations when von want tl-ia ova^f ™T™J;-~~ ~( –

Skills for Academic Inquiry: Quotation, Paraphrase, Summary, and Synthesis

understand a claim or a piece of evidence, making an exact copy allows you to go back to it later, when further reading in the field may give you a better under- standing of it. However, you should resort to that kind of copying as little as pos- sible, since it can lead to a paper that simply pieces together quotations rather than using them to make an argument. To write effectively you need to understand your sources, not just repeat them. When you use notes to draft a paper, it is advisable to state the point or purpose of a quotation before you use it and to integrate shorter quotations smoothly into com- plete sentences. This is a way to demonstrate your understanding of the source and guide your readers to share it. For example: Alfie Kohn claims that there is no data to confirm that more students in the present than

in the past receive higher grades for less real achievement: “The bottom line: No one has ever demonstrated that students today get A’s for the same work that used to receive B’s or C’s.”

It is important to distinguish word-for-word quotations of sources from paraphrases and summaries in your own words, and correct punctuation is the way to make this distinction clearly and effectively. The rules for punctuating quotations are relatively simple, but they need to be followed consistently. These rules follow Modern Language Association (MLA) style, because quotations are rarely used in fields that use American Psychological Association (APA) style.

Authors’ Names

The first time you use an author’s name, you should use the full name, without hon- orifics (Mr., Miss., Professor, Dr., etc.). For later reference, use only the last name. Never refer to an author by first name only.

Short Quotations

H In contemporary American practice, short quotes are put in double quotation marks. • In the following example from Benjamin Franklin’s biography, the spelling and

capitalization of the original are maintained, even though they are now obsolete. s If the author’s name is mentioned before the quote, only the page number goes

in the parenthetical citation. The period that ends the final sentence follows the final parenthesis.

• In the following example from the MLA Handbook, notice how the quotation is fused to the writer’s text to produce a single, grammatically correct sentence.

a Since the author is not cited before the quotation, the last name is included in the parenthetical citation.

Short Quote Following a Complete Sentence

Benjamin Franklin describes how he Learned to write through imitating The Spectator, an

English magazine: “I bought it, read it over, and was much deliahted with it. I thnuaht thp

 

 

104 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

Short Quote Integrated into a Sentence

It is crucial for students to learn to document sources well because it “not only recognizes

the work writers do; it also tends to discourage the circulation of error” (MLA Handbook 52).

Long Quotations

m A long quote (three or more lines; one or more complete sentences) should be set off by indenting the entire quote one inch—or ten spaces. Notice in the example below that when long quotes are set off, quotation marks are not used around them.

fa Use long, set-off quotations when it is important to get the exact words of a partic- ular passage or when the author’s style is very important and you need a long quote to get across its impact. However, they should be used sparingly, since they can look like “padding” and may suggest that you do not understand the material well enough to summarize it. Moreover, many readers admit to skipping over them, and this can dilute the impact of your argument.

m It is particularly important to introduce long quotes, so that your reader can see the point in a single reading. Use the same spacing (double or single) for the set-off quotation that you use for the document itself.

Punctuating Introductions to Quotations

e When using a quotation in a paper, it is more effective to introduce it than to just let it “speak for itself.”

0 If the introductory statement is a complete sentence, follow it with a colon.

B If the introductory statement is integrated with the quotation to make a complete sentence, use a comma only if you would use a comma if the quotation marks were not there. If the introductory statement would need a comma without the quotation, follow it with a comma.

Quote Following a Complete Sentence

Alfie Kohn claims that there are no data to confirm that more students in the present than in

the past receive higher grades for less real achievement: “The bottom line: No one has ever

demonstrated that students today get A’s for the same work that used to receive B’s or C’s.”

Quotes Integrated into Sentences

As Alfie Kohn argues, “the long history of indignation” over grade inflation is usually ignored.

Alfie Kohn observes that “the long history of indignation” over grade inflation is

usually ignored.

Quotes within Quotes

Put quotations within quotations in single quotation marks, as in the example below. However, quotes within set-off quotes are punctuated normally, with double quota- tion marks.

Skills for Academic Inquiry: Quotation, Paraphrase, Summary, and Synthesis 105

Quotes within Quotation Marks

Alfie Kohn observes that a report from “the National Center for Education Statistics

revealed that fully 33.5 percent of American undergraduates had a grade-point average of

C or below, a number that ought to quiet ‘all the furor over grade inflation,’ according to a

spokesman for the Association of American Colleges and Universities.”

Set-Off Quotes

Alfie Kohn raises serious questions about the reality of grade inflation by citing highly

reliable sources:

To get a more accurate picture of whether grades have changed over the years, one needs

to look at official student transcripts. Clifford Adelman, a senior research analyst with the

U.S. Department of Education, did just that, reviewing transcripts from more than 3,000

institutions and reporting his results in 1995. His finding: “Contrary to the widespread

lamentations, grades actually declined slightly in the last two decades.” Moreover, a

report released just this year by the National Center for Education Statistics revealed that

fully 33.5 percent of American undergraduates had a grade-point average of C or below in

1999-2000, a number that ought to quiet “all the furor over grade inflation,” according

to a spokesperson for the Association of American Colleges and Universities.

Sentence-Ending Punctuation

The basic rule is that commas go inside quotation marks, and periods do so if the sentence ends with the last quotation mark. However, there are several important variations:

a When a parenthetical citation immediately follows the quotation, the sentence does not end with the final quotation mark, and so the period follows the final parenthesis.

a Question marks and exclamation points go inside only when they are part of the quotation. When they are not part of the quotation, they go outside. Commas go within the quotation marks, but semicolons and colons go outside them. For example:

Alfie Kohn asserts, “The bottom line: No one has ever demonstrated that students today get

A’s for the same work that used to receive B’s or C’s.”

Mike Rose admits that “there is no single profile of the Good Teacher” (9).

Why did Mike Rose reject the idea that “there is no single profile of the Good Teacher” (9)?

Ellipses, Brackets, and [Sic]

» Use ellipses when you cut away a piece of a quotation. Be very careful not to change the author’s meaning by cutting a part away. Do not use ellipses at the beginnings or ends of quotations, unless there is a real possibility of misunderstanding without

 

 

106 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

them. Ellipses consist of three dots, separated by spaces. Use a period before the ellipses to show that a sentence ends before the ellipses begin (and thus the number of dots totals four in those cases).

E Use brackets to add to the quotation any material necessary to understand it. The bracketed material can clarify words or expressions in the original text that could be ambiguous when read out of context. In the following example, the bracketed material replaces and clarifies what the author is referring to by “the two.”

• The term “sic” set in brackets is used to indicate that the preceding material is original to the source, not the invention or mistake of the quoter. For example, the archaic capitalization and contractions in the quotation from Franklin above could have been followed by [sic] to indicate that they were part of the original. Using [sic] is a judgment call, but it is preferable to avoid it unless there is the possibility of serious confusion or misreading. This did not seem to be the case in quoting Franklin.

Ellipses. . .

Alfie Kohn draws on the distinction between kinds of motivation:

With the exception of orthodox behaviorists, psychologists have come to realize that

people can exhibit qualitatively different kinds of motivation: intrinsic, in which the

task itself is seen as valuable, and extrinsic, in which the task is just a means to the

end of gaining a reward or escaping a punishment. The two are not only distinct but

often inversely related. . . . But the reality is that it doesn’t matter how motivated

students are; what matters is how students are motivated. A focus on grades creates, or

at least perpetuates, an extrinsic orientation that is likely to undermine the love of

learning we are presumably seeking to promote.

Brackets [ ]

Alfie Kohn observes that “the two [intrinsic and extrinsic motivation] are not only distinct

but often inversely related.”

PARAPHRASING EFFECTIVELY

Paraphrases follow the thinking and wording of the author closely and may include some short quotations like those in the examples above. As when you use quotations, the best way to distinguish your thinking from that of the source is to name the source at the beginning of the paraphrase and (when using MLA style) to follow the para- phrase with the page number in the source from which it was taken. Paraphrasing when taking notes can be used to follow a line of reasoning in detail, but it is risky because it is easy to reword it when actually writing the paper, bringing it back so close to the original (whether or not you intend to) that it will seem like plagiarism— using another writer’s words without attribution. If you feel you must closely follow the reasoning of a source by using a paraphrase, consider quoting directly in your

Summarizing Appropriately 107

notes and writing the paraphrase later, when you draft the paper. If there are cases where this is not possible, leave reminders to yourself when you paraphrase, so that you know what you have in your notes when using them later. As with a direct quo- tation, introduce each paraphrase, end it with a page number (when available), and attach a reference.

Alfie Kohn observes that people who blame grade inflation on the liberal excesses of the

1960s are ignoring the fact that people have been complaining about it for centuries.

Alfie Kohn argues that there is no documented evidence that grade inftation has

taken place.

SUMMARIZING APPROPRIATELY

Summaries, an important aspect of note-taking, are also written in your own words, but they cover more of the source in a more general way. Being able to summarize what a writer said accurately, briefly, and without distorting the meaning is a crucial academic skill. A summary of a whole work (sometimes called an abstract) recapitulates the major claim the author makes in a piece, the reasons that support the argument, and the conclusion reached. Although summaries are sometimes assigned and written for their own sake to demonstrate that you have read and understood an article, in research writing they are primarily used to establish the context of an argument and to bring in evidence from other researchers to support a line of reasoning. Keep those uses in mind while summarizing sources and when deciding how much detail to include from a par- ticular source. Like other uses of sources, summaries should be clearly distinguished from your response to the material; although your response is important, the summary should never change or distort the meaning of the original piece. The length of any summary should depend on how you plan to use it in the project and on how central its argument, reasoning, or evidence is to your own developing argument.

• Attach a reference to the summary so that you have the material for a bibliographic entry. Remember that the source for a summary needs to be cited, even if you are describing a writer’s general approach or argument, and even if you are not using any direct quotations in it.

• Clearly indicate in the notes when you are speaking for yourself and when you are summarizing another work. The clearest way to distinguish your own thinking from that of your source is to name the source before summarizing, just as you would before quoting or paraphrasing it. If you consistently mark your responses (by highlighting or using a different font) while taking notes, you can easily dis- tinguish them from your summaries of sources.

• If you use an author’s summary—from an abstract or concluding paragraph—as a starting place for your own, make sure that you do not simply copy it into your paper. Try restating the author’s summary in your own words, and then decide what additional information is needed for the purposes of your project. It may help to close the source while you summarize, so that you are forced to think through the

 

 

108 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

main ideas until you fully understand them before putting them in your own words. Then check that the summary accurately represents the source. If it does not, a quotation might be preferable at this stage of your inquiry.

m Let the author do some of the work of summarizing by looking at the central argument (or thesis) of the piece, which usually can be found at the end of the introduction, and which is often reiterated at the beginning of the conclusion and referred to at the beginnings of some paragraphs. You can usually find the major claims, rea- sons, and organization of the evidence in a piece by skimming it. Try highlighting the first sentence of each paragraph of a source you are working with, as well as the first and last sentences of the introduction and conclusion. How close do the highlighted parts bring you to a summary?

Unfortunately, when dealing with any sizable work, following this method closely will produce a summary that is far too long and that includes explana- tions, supporting elements, and other peripheral material. In a piece from a news- paper or magazine—like Alfie Kohn’s piece on grade inflation and Robert Rivard’s piece on plagiarism in the Readings—the paragraphs are usually too short for this to be an effective strategy. But reading for the writer’s statements of argument and purpose—wherever they are located—can provide a good start for summarizing.

& Identify key words by skimming first lines and construct a summary around them.

A Simple Format for Learning to Summarize

If you are new to summarizing, here is a simple framework for getting started. This strat- egy is adapted from instructions for formulating a thesis given in The Craft of Research} If you are already experienced at summarizing, you may find this process to be too rigid and formulaic to let you say what you need to say, so do not hesitate to adapt the process to suit the texts you are working with and to your purpose in summarizing them—or to drop the process when it fails to help you frame your understanding of a source:

a The author [full name] raises [name the problem] with [state the purpose]; ffi The author [last name or pronoun] argues that [state main claim] by observing that [state

main reasons]; m The author [last name or pronoun] concludes [describe conclusion and/or recommenda-

tions]; and m The author [last name or pronoun] proposes [state significance or implications where

appropriate].

EXAMPLE 6.1 Building the Summary Here is a summary of Alfie Kohn’s article on grade inflation that follows the process described above:

Alfie Kohn raises the issue of grade inflation in order to argue that it is not really a problem

in most universities. He observes that contemporary students are at least as knowledgeable

Summarizing Appropriately 109

as those of a century ago and suggests that concerns about grade inflation rest on misreadings

of data not directly relevant to measuring student learning. He concludes that claims about

grade inflation derive from an uncritical acceptance of the idea of competitive grading, and

proposes that competitive grading itself is destructive of intellectual effort and detrimental to

educational excellence.

This is a very short summary, only ninety words, yet it gives a precise overview of Kohn’s piece and gives appropriate weight to the points Kohn stresses. Here’s how it works:

1. Alfie Kohn raises the issue of grade inflation in order to argue that it is not really a problem in most universities. [The first sentence of the summary states the prob- lem, repeats the central claim of the article, and gives Kohn’s purpose: to refute the idea that grade inflation is a problem.]

2. He observes that contemporary students are at least as knowledgeable as those of a century ago, [The second sentence gives the major reason supporting Kohn’s claim]

3. and suggests that concerns about grade inflation rest on misreading data not directly relevant to measuring student learning, [and the reason why the other side is wrong.]

4. He concludes that claims about grade inflation derive from an uncritical accept- ance of the idea of competitive grading [The third sentence shows Kohn’s reasons for discrediting the warrant for the other side (which constitutes much of Kohn’s strategy in this article) . . .]

5. and proposes that competitive grading itself is destructive of intellectual effort and detrimental to educational excellence. [. . . and gives Kohn’s conclusion, which attests to the larger implications of his argument]

Notice that this summary covers the entire argument specifically; it does not move to a higher level of generality than the author uses, but it does leave out the supporting evi- dence and most of the context. It is preferable to keep a summary as near as possible to the level of specificity in the source. For example, this summary could move to a more general level by starting with a statement that Alfie Kohn addresses an issue in American higher education of considerable concern to faculty, students, and parents; this may be true, but that statement is too general to begin a short summary of Kohn’s article.

The summary also includes the author’s name; a final draft would indicate page numbers (when available) for any material closely derived from the source, meeting the need for accurate documentation. If a longer summary is required, more detailed sup- port could be added to each of the four sections, and the line of reasoning established, in order to more fully describe Kohn’s argument. In the example below, the additions have been bolded. Notice that the additions are primarily the main reasons for his position.

EXAMPLE 6.2 A More Detailed Summary

Alfie Kohn raises the issue of grade inflation in order to argue that it is not really a problem

in most universities, suggesting that grade inflation is actually a myth based on false

 

 

110 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

information, insufficient proof, and an unjustified belief in the objective validity of

grades. He documents the unreliability of research attesting to grade inflation and

attributes the conclusion that grade inflation is undermining American higher educa-

tion to the conservative political bias of some researchers. Kohn observes that contem-

porary students are at least as knowledgeable as those of a century ago, citing data from a

U.S. Department of Education analysis of student grades, and suggests that concerns

about grade inflation rest on misreading data not directly relevant to measuring student

learning. He concludes that claims about grade inflation derive from an uncritical acceptance

of the idea that grading should be competitive and from the assumption that stringent

grading effectively motivates learning. Kohn proposes that competitive grading itself is

detrimental to education and destructive to educational excellence, citing evidence that

students learn better from internal motives and from teachers who expect them to

succeed than from competition for grades.

Quest/on What would you expect to be the key words in this article?

How Purpose Affects Summary Clearly, summarizing is an important step in progressing from taking notes to writing an argument of your own. You can shape summaries to the purpose of your projects as you go along, and later synthesize summaries of multiple sources to develop your thinking about your topic even further. In the Readings, the excerpt from the introduction to Mike Rose’s Possible Lives: The Promise of Public Education in America summarizes the book and explains the order of the evidence used to argue that there is much that is good in American public education. His evidence is embedded in his account of site visits to a range of schools across the country that, he argues, can and should be considered success- ful. He begins and ends by addressing the purpose of the book: “I hope not so much for prescription as for an opening up of the way we think and talk about public schools” (9).

A writer using Rose’s book as a source might summarize this passage in ways that are relevant for a number of different purposes. Each of these sample summaries uses a differ- ent aspect of Rose’s introduction as a starting point for a response, analysis, or argument.

1. To support a position or offer evidence for it:

Not everyone believes that public school education in America is hopeless. For example,

Mike Rose assembles case histories of schools that provide effective and engaging instruc-

tion to support his argument that American public education for the most part works (8-9).

Notice that even though this summary is setting us up for a response—probably a positive response—to Rose’s argument, it nonetheless accurately conveys what the passage says.

Writing an Annotated Bibliography 111

2. To argue against its conclusions, assumptions, or methodologies or to point out weaknesses in the evidence it uses:

Mike Rose assembles case histories of selected American schools to argue for the success

of American public education and for the “decency and achievement” these schools foster.

However, the actual experience of the majority of teachers and students cannot be ade-

quately represented through a handful of case studies, which may or may not be typical.

The phrase “selected American schools” prepares for a negative response by emphasizing the selectivity of this sample, whereas the first summary empha- sized its geographic breadth. The summary, even though asking us for a negative response to the material, accurately states what the passage says.

3. To explain (and possibly adopt) a writer’s methodology:

Mike Rose describes his travels from school to school across America, observing class-

es, talking with high school teachers, university faculty, and students, considering

particular practices and projects in terms of their local populations and their condi-

tions of life. This study will follow a similar plan, but limit the “journey” to neighbor-

hoods within a single city.

This short summary offers more details about Rose’s methodology, which the writer intends to imitate.

4. To gather evidence about one focus of the writer’s work. (For example, a writer examining urban education might summarize only Rose’s references to schools in Los Angeles, Chicago, and New York City):

When considering urban schools, Mike Rose examines the interplay of relationships

between students and teachers, schools and communities, and reform movements and

individual lives.

This writer may be moving into an analysis of the interactions among similar rela- tionships in some other aspect of urban life, summarizing this aspect of Rose’s work to establish the terms of analysis.

As you work with sources, you will find additional purposes for summarizing sources; the direction your argument takes and the kinds of claims you make will deter- mine what information should be summarized from a source and the appropriate length of the summary. It cannot be stressed too often, however, that it is crucial to sum- marize accurately and fairly, which means making sure you do not change the author’s ideas, even when you take them out of their original context, and especially when you disagree with them. As well as being unethical, such inaccuracy would seriously under- mine your credibility—your ethos as a writer.

WRITING AN ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY

An annotated bibliography is a list of sources relevant to an inquiry, alphabetized by the author’s last name. Each source is summarized and evaluated, usually in no more than

 

 

112 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

a short paragraph or two. Published annotated bibliographies serve as reference guides for other researchers, and finding a recent one related to your research can offer an expert introduction to the literature and a strategy for navigating through it. Sometimes researchers write more informal annotated bibliographies for themselves, in order to keep track of their sources when working on a long-term project. They are often assigned in upper-level courses in the humanities.

m Copy the citations from the working bibliography into a new file; focus on sources you have read and are likely to use in later projects.

m Evaluate your sources in terms of reliability. See the Focus Points on Evaluating Sources and Evaluating Materials on the Web in Chapter 2, pages 29 and 40. Discard sources that do not seem reliable or that are irrelevant to your inquiry, unless you have a special reason for including them, for example, exposing their unreliability as part of your response.

• Find additional reliable and relevant sources to add to the bibliography until you have enough to demonstrate the scope of your inquiry and to meet the require- ments of the assignment.

a Consider your audience: your class and your instructor. Are you writing for a research group with considerable knowledge in common, or for an audience that has an interest in your topic but less knowledge about it than you do? Consider the balance of common and disciplinary knowledge appropriate for this audience.

e Write a summary for each source chosen. For some of the sources you may be able to draw on notes, summaries, and responses from previous exercises. Revise this earlier work to fit into the summary/response format and to reflect what you have learned later in your inquiry; write new annotations for sources not yet summarized.

m Write a new or revised response to each source. Start by considering criteria for evaluating the entries: • what part the source plays in your emerging argument, • how it relates to the other sources, • how it has affected your thinking, and • how you might use it in another project.

m Compare your earlier responses to these new ones, and consider how they have changed. Consider how the sources may be useful for future projects based on this inquiry.

% Make sure the entries are in alphabetical order, and write a short introduction to the bibliography that describes its purpose, how much of the inquiry it covers, and what other sources or kinds of sources are needed to complete the inquiry,

is In a longer bibliography (30 or more sources), you can divide the bibliography into sections with subtitles; if you do so, the introduction should also explain what each section covers.

Writing an Annotated Bibliography 113

EXAMPLE 6.3 Sample Annotated Bibliography for a Paper on Plagiarism

Plagiarism: An Annotated Bibliography

This bibliography describes and documents my reading so far for an investigation of

plagiarism and possible solutions to it at American universities. I decided to focus my early

reading on specific cases and places, in order to give me a sense of the “common

understanding” of the issues. Most of the articles examine specific cases of plagiarism or

responses to it, at specific American schools. They identify plagiarism as a problem that

needs to be solved, without paying much attention to defining it or questioning whether it is

a problem at all. The pieces by Rebecca Moore Howard and Candace Spigelman, however, do

make the issue more questionable, and I will need to examine the individual cases reported in

the popular press to distinguish between fraud and mistakes. At the same time, it is

important to test that distinction against descriptions of specific cases to make an argument

about whether or not it is a useful distinction.

Feldt, Brandon. “English Professors Discuss Solutions for Plagiarism.” Daily Vidette. Illinois

State University, 27 Jan. 2003. Web. 17 Nov. 2008.

This university newspaper article describes how professors at Illinois State University

consider possible solutions for the growing plagiarism issue. They discuss preparation for writing

in both college and high school atmospheres, and suggest that some students do not understand

the different aspects of plagiarism and/or how to cite correctly. They also consider the impact of

the fact that some teachers tend to give nonspecific directions for papers and assignments.

This article supports my research by providing several different problems that cause

plagiarism as well as a few possible solutions. It considers many of the same issues I plan

to touch upon, particularly the unexplained issues.

Foster, Andrea L. “Plagiarism Tool Creates Legal Quandary.” Chronide.com. Chronicle of

Higher Education, 17 May 2003. Web. 17 Nov. 2008.

This article touches upon the law and copyright infringement. It shows the critical

issues concerning computer programs that have emerged since universities began using

them. The article also gives reactions to the possible copyright infringing services.

The article can help my argument by covering the legal aspects of the situation. It

also helps me get a broader understanding of plagiarism as an intellectual property issue.

 

 

114 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

By being able to fully understand the situation, I can write a thorough report on the issue,

addressing legal issues as well as moral issues.

Garinger, Alex. “Plagiarism Cases Jump During Fall.” Chronicle. Duke University, 13 Jan.

2003. Web. 17 Nov. 2008.

This article reaffirms the increasing rate of plagiarism in our school systems. It focuses on

a study done at Duke University, discussing problems with plagiarism over the past few years.

This article might work as additional background information for my research.

Haberling, Michael. “Maintaining Academic Integrity in Online Education.” Online Journal of

Distance Learning Administration 5.1 (2002): n. pag. 3 Dec. 2003. Web. 11 Nov. 2008.

This article refutes the idea that plagiarism and other forms of cheating occur more

often in online courses than in face-to-face courses. Comparing plagiarism cases in both

kinds of classes at Baker College in Michigan, the author (the president of the college) argues

that this is not necessarily so. In fact, it may be easier to detect plagiarism in online courses.

For one thing, teachers of online classes have a larger record of students’ writing, since most

class participation is done in writing. It can be easier for a teacher to spot plagiarism when

he or she is used to a student’s normal writing style and abilities. The article describes how to

do a “search in reverse” on search engines to detect plagiarism and includes a pretty funny

story about students plagiarizing their college application essays and getting caught.

This article extends the question of plagiarism to online courses, which I have not

really thought much about in this project.

Howard, Rebecca Moore. “Forget about Policing Plagiarism. Just Teach.” Chronicle.com.

Chronicle of Higher Education, 16 Nov. 2001. Web. 17 Jan. 2008.

This article seems like a simpler version of the earlier article in College English. Instead

of considering what students do when writing, it tells teachers how to deal with plagiarism in

their courses. Howard does not seem to think that there is a “plague” of plagiarism, and she

reminds teachers that they do not want to be police. She looks into some of the reasons why

students may cheat, and talks about how professors’ working conditions can help them assign

papers that students do not want to cheat on.

This article seems to be blaming colleges and professors for students’ cheating. It

does raise the question of how professors should be teaching classes.

Writing an Annotated Bibliography 115

—. “Plagiarisms, Authorships, and the Academic Death Penalty.” College English 57.7

(1995): 788-806. Print.

This article makes the issue of plagiarism much more complicated than some of the

others. The author thinks that plagiarism should be given a different definition, so that

cheating is seen differently than “patchwriting.” Both of them are bad, but they are not the

same thing, in her opinion. Schools should rewrite policies to make that difference clear, and

teachers should teach students how to use sources better, even though it takes a long time.

This article makes my thinking about this research more complicated. It also makes

me wonder how the schools and teachers in the other articles defined plagiarism. Which

cases were really cheating, as compared to making mistakes?

Jerome, Richard, and Pam Grout. “Cheat Wave.” People 17 June 2002: 82-83. Print.

This article discusses one specific disagreement that occurred in Piper, Kansas, and

one legal outcome of the current debate on plagiarism. It also considers the effect of the

court decision upon the student and the school.

This article provides a strong case study of the impact of plagiarism on a community.

Also, by showing that there is more than one side to the issue, I should be able to raise

awareness of the importance and growing magnitude of the issue at hand.

McGrath, Charles. “Plagiarism: Everybody Into the Pool.” New York Times 7 Jan. 2007: 33. Print.

This article talks about some high-profile plagiarism cases that have occurred over

the last couple of years. It also discusses how students that plagiarize often suffer harsher

consequences than their professors who are guilty of the same thing.

I will probably use one of the statistics from the end of the article about students

who reported cheating by using the Internet. The article also discusses Richard A. Posner’s

The Little Book of Plagiarism, which may be another good source to consider.

Robillard, Amy E. “We Won’t Get Fooled Again: On the Absence of Angry Responses to

Plagiarism in Composition Studies.” College English 70.1 (2007): 10-31. Print.

This article talks about plagiarism from the side of the Composition instructor. It tells

how frustrating it can be for teachers to play the role of a policeman when grading papers,

but it also explains the dilemma involved with dealing out punishment to plagiarizing

students and what that means for their self-esteem and careers.

 

 

116 Chapter 6 • Using Sources Effectively

This article supports the point of view of the teacher on plagiarism and will contrast nicely

to other articles that discuss it from the student’s point of view and that of other professionals.

Silverman, Gillian. “Ifs a Bird, It’s a Plane, It’s Plagiarism Buster!” Newsweek

15 July 2002: 12. Print.

This article pertains specifically to students stealing from the Internet. It raises the

idea that plagiarism is partially due to the nature of students’ lives. It suggests that

students are either too busy or too free to do other things, and so they tend to do

homework at the last minute, which causes them to turn to plagiarism.

This article supports different points of view on plagiarism, the point of view of the

schools and the point of view of the student. By looking at several different viewpoints I

can make a better response to the issue.

Spigelman, Candace. “The Ethics of Appropriation in Peer Writing Groups.” Perspectives on

Plagiarism and Intellectual Property in a Postmodern World. Ed. Lise Buranen and Alice

M. Roy. Albany, NY: SUNY P, 1999. 231-40. Print.

This article discusses how students talk about and think about intellectual property in

writing groups that are part of a class. It discusses the problem that some courses want

students to work alone, so that their ideas are always theirs alone. The writer quotes the

students discussing their feelings about where ideas come from and the need to credit

people as well as books for influencing their thinking.

This article will be useful because it makes the idea of plagiarism more complicated.

The author doesn’t just quote people for and against plagiarism, but students trying to

understand what to do in different situations.

Straw, Deborah. “The Plagiarism of Generation ‘Why Not?'” Community College Week 14.24

(2002): 4-6. Print.

This article explains the rising complications with plagiarism specifically upon the high-

school level and also on the collegiate level. It uses statistics from universities and high

schools around the country to represent this idea while also including quotes from various

school officials. The article considers the part the Internet has played in the growing incidence

of plagiarism. After introducing the problem, the article questions who is likely to be an

offender. It suggests that the higher entrance requirements at colleges cause students in high

Moving from Summary to Synthesis: Establishing Relationships 117

schools to try and get the highest grade point averages that they can, even if it means

plagiarizing. The article concludes by providing possible ways of attacking the dilemma.

The source is a credible one that gives me ample information to create a sound base

for my research. This article provides a background scene I can use to help the audience to

better understand the situation. Also, it gives me statistics to prove that the situation

exists and is becoming more of a problem every year.

Questions 1. What kinds of sources does the writer of the bibliography use? How directly do

they address his particular project? 2. Do you agree with the writer’s assessment of the reh’ability of the sources in this

bibliography? Which ones seem questionable? Why? 3. How precise are the summaries? Where should they be clearer? 4. What are the criteria for the responses? Are they applied consistently? Do they