Analyze through the four general education lenses.

Specifically, you must address the critical elements listed below.

 

I. Introduction: You will compile a series of critical analyses of a single issue/event in wellness through the four general education lenses: history, humanities, natural and applied sciences, and social sciences.

A. Topic: Using the four lenses, explain how an issue/event within wellness has or has not influenced modern society.

 

II. Lens Connections: In this section of your assignment, you will describe the connections between your issue/event and each of the four general education lenses.

A. What is the connection of your issue/event to the lens of history for determining its impact on various institutions? Utilize evidence from theory and research to support your analysis.

B. What is the connection of your issue/event to the lens of the humanities for determining its impact on various institutions? Utilize evidence from theory and research to support your analysis.

C. What is the connection of your issue/event to the lens of the natural and applied sciences for determining its impact on various institutions? Utilize evidence from theory and research to support your analysis.

D. What is the connection of your issue/event to the lens of the social sciences for determining its impact on various institutions?

 

Utilize evidence from theory and research to support your analysis. Be sure to begin the research process early and use evidence from your research to support your responses. Refer to course resources, the LibGuide for this class, and any other pertinent resources to support your responses. Although at least two sources are required for each lens, note that you may use the same source for more than one lens if applicable. Relevant current news sources may be used with instructor approval.

 

 

4 LENSES OF EDUCATION

The humanities are “disciplines [that] concern the study of distinctively human actions and works; for example history, philology (language, literature, linguistics), philosophy, theology and studies of Antiquity” (Cosgrove, 2009, para. 3). You can see that the humanities cover a wide range of subjects and disciplines, but remember that they focus in on our actions and works as human beings. What does listening to a Beethoven symphony tell us about the time period? How did people value and experience his work at that time and what does that tell us about their culture?

The social science lens looks at how humans act in their social environment. While the humanities also studies human action, social sciences more specifically look at our social relations, our relationships and our societies.  Specific disciplines within the social sciences may sound familiar to you such as: political science, psychology, sociology and anthropology (Social Science, 2017). When thinking about the social sciences, think of all the ways we interact with the people around us.

The natural sciences are best described as “a modern method of understanding the physical universe based on observation, hypothesis formation, and experimental verification” (Haught, 2011, para 1). Understanding our natural world through testable hypotheses gets at the root of this lens. Common disciplines within the natural sciences are:  astronomy, geology, chemistry, physics, and biology, and some cross-disciplines like oceanography, environmental science, and computer science (Haught, 2011). Researchers in these fields are concerned with making hypotheses, testing and proving results through direct data driven evidence.

History may perhaps be the most familiar lens, where it is simply put, the story of humanity’s past. Historians use materials such as books, newspapers, magazines, diaries, photographs, art, artifacts, oral testimonies and more to trace events and look at patterns. They are “concerned with causality, that is, why certain outcomes happened as they did, and how they are linked to earlier events” (History, 2017, para 1). History can inform the future by analyzing what happened and why.

Pennfoster

Study Unit

Improving Your Writing

 

 

Writing a strong letter to apply for a job or putting together a convincing argument for a business report requires more than a collection of nouns, verbs, and punctuation. Good communication skills include the basics, of course, but proper planning, a pleasant style, and close attention to detail also count. This study unit is designed to help you make the best use of the writing tools you already have by making them work for you as you plan, develop, revise, and present your work.

iii

P r e v ie

w P r e v ie

w When you complete this study unit, you’ll be able to

• Identify your audience, medium, and purpose

• Focus your ideas

• Organize your material

• Plan both informal and formal writing projects

• Use words, punctuation, and sentences to achieve the effect you want

• Revise, edit, and proofread to make your final copy accurate, professional, and attractive

 

 

THE PLANNING PROCESS 1

Prewriting 2 Organizing Your Material 6 Patterns of Organization 6 Outline Options 9 Developing an Outline 11 The Formal Outline 16

WRITING YOUR DOCUMENT 21

Types of Writing 21 Key Considerations 25 Writing the First Draft 33

STRENGTHENING YOUR STYLE 36

How to Give Your Writing Punch 36 Choosing the Right Words 41 Informality and Formality 44 Using Words Properly 47

REVISING, EDITING, AND PROOFREADING 55

Revising Your Writing 55 Editing Your Work 58 Proofreading the Final Draft 61 Presenting Your Work 64

PRACTICE EXERCISE ANSWERS 67

SELF-CHECK ANSWERS 73

EXAMINATION 77

v

C o n t e n t s

C o n t e n t s

 

 

1

THE PLANNING PROCESS

Just as there are many ways to write, there are many ways to describe the process of writing. In this study unit, we’ll break down the process into these stages:

• Prewriting

• Planning

• Writing the first draft

• Revising and editing

• Proofreading

• Presenting

The writing process isn’t always linear. That is, writers don’t always include every step or follow each step in order. They may begin writing a first draft without really knowing what they wish to say, for instance, and then go back and plan the revision using an outline. They may proofread as they go along and not make a special effort to do so as a separate step. Or, once they’ve gone through the entire process, they may decide to discard what they have and start again. This may happen in business, for instance, when a proposal is rejected but the company wishes to pursue the project from another angle.

Improving Your Writing

 

 

Improving Your Writing2

Prewriting The first stage in the writing process is actually prewriting. This is what you do before you put pen to paper (or fingers to keyboard). Prewriting comes even before planning because you don’t even have anything specific to plan yet. During prewriting, the first thing to do is to determine your purpose, medium, and audience.

Why are you writing? What do you hope to achieve? The answer is your purpose.

What form will you use—a letter, a memo, a report, a proposal, an essay, a poem, a story, or something else? The answer is your medium.

Who will read the final piece of writing? What are their needs and expectations? That’s your audience.

It’s important to understand your purpose, medium, and audience from the very beginning. Doing so will help you to work through the writing process efficiently and effectively. Without understanding these three elements, you’ll have trouble focusing your ideas and writing with confidence. Or, you may write with ease, yet unintentionally focus on the wrong points and fail to achieve the results you intend.

Once you know your purpose, medium, and audience, it’s time to find out what your thoughts are about your topic so that you can decide how to approach your writing project. Suppose, for instance, you’re asked to write a paragraph about cars. What would you say? Maybe it’s not even a topic that interests you. However, you have to come up with something interesting to say.

Who asked you to write the paragraph, and why? Let’s say, since this course resembles a classroom, that a writing teacher has given you this assignment. Your purpose is to demonstrate that you’ve mastered the basics of written English expression. Your medium is given—a paragraph. Your audience is the teacher and (let’s pretend) the rest of the class. So, what will you say in this paragraph to demon- strate your English skills to your teacher and classmates?

There are many ways you could get ideas. All it really takes to get you started on a writing project is one good idea that excites you. Finding that idea is the goal of any prewriting exercise.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 3

You can take five steps as you prewrite: brainstorming, webbing, freewriting, researching, and journal keeping. We’ll examine each here, beginning with brainstorming.

Brainstorming

What does the topic of “cars” bring to mind? To find out, try brainstorming. Make a list of every idea that comes to mind. Don’t exclude anything. Don’t worry about put- ting these thoughts in order. Right now you’re just writing down everything you think might be a possible focus for your paragraph. You may end up not using most of these ideas.

You might even wish to brainstorm with one or more other people. Ask questions. What do you think of cars? What cars do you like? What would you like to read about cars? Other people may come up with ideas that will trigger even better ideas of your own.

A list on the subject of cars might look something like the list in Figure 1. These are just a few suggestions, of course—you could come up with many more ideas.

Webbing

A similar exercise, called webbing, is perhaps even more useful than brainstorming. It shows relationships between some of the ideas you have. To begin, write your topic (cars, for example) in the middle of a piece of paper (Figure 2). Circle it. Draw a line out from the circle and write another word—the first word that comes to mind about the topic, for example, wheels. Circle that word, too. Draw a line out from there and write another word that comes to mind about the second circled word, for example, hubcaps. Circle the new word and keep going, for example, flat tire, my first flat, learned to change tires in driver’s ed., and nobody stopped to help. Then you can go back and start a new chain from the key word, cars. You can start many chains. Often, you’ll come up with something interesting.

Cars

Big cars Henry Ford

Little cars Model T’s

Are RVs cars? TR7s

My first car Used car lots

Car accidents Drive-in movies

Speeding limits Driveways

Speeding tickets Garage door openers

Drunk driving Car seats

Leather seats Seat belts

FIGURE 1—A Brainstormed List

 

 

Improving Your Writing4

Freewriting

To freewrite, you fill a piece of paper with any idea that comes to mind about your topic. Don’t stop to think. Don’t lift your pen. Just write! Don’t worry about grammar or sentence structure or anything else except your topic. Your goal is to come up with that one good idea, and the best way to do that is to set your creative mind free (Figure 3). Your mind can’t be creative if it’s worried about spelling and semicolons.

Here’s an example of freewriting on the topic of cars.

My car got so hot today. The sun was shining in the windows all afternoon and heated the steering wheel into a fiery circle. My car’s a Geo just a little thing saves me money on gas gets me where I want. My first car was a gigantic Plymouth Fury. We called her Megacar. Mega was used. Geo was new when I bought it but sure looks used now! Mega better in snow. Big cars are probably safer. But it cost a mint to fill Mega’s tank. And that was during the energy crisis. Cars and the energy crisis. Whatever happened to the energy crisis? Aren’t cars still using up resources? And pollut- ing? How come we don’t hear that any more? I need to look into this.

FIGURE 2—Webbing

 

 

Improving Your Writing 5

Researching

Many people like to look to outside sources for ideas for writing. For the assignment on cars, you might go to the library and look for information on cars. Or, if you’ve already decided you’re interested in one of the narrower topics you’ve come up with while brainstorming, clustering, or freewriting, you could look up more information on that idea. Read a biography on Henry Ford, for instance, or do some research on the energy crisis, the history of speed limits, or the pros and cons of small versus big cars.

Journal Keeping

Some people write their most interesting thoughts and expe- riences in a journal, which is a record of events, ideas, or reflections, kept for private use. If you write in your journal regularly, it can be a good source of ideas to write about for other purposes. For instance, perusing the journal entries near the time you bought your last car, you might recall issues that were important to you and come up with a topic like “What to Look for When Buying a Car.”

FIGURE 3—Freewriting on any topic, such as cars, can reveal the many ideas that constantly pass through your mind.

 

 

Improving Your Writing6

Organizing Your Material

Any time you sit down to write something—an e-mail message, a letter, a report, a proposal—you must organize the material you’re going to present (Figure 4). Of course, short documents, such as e-mails and memos, don’t require the same degree of organization as long reports, but the quality of any written document improves when you think through what you want to say and, sometimes, write an outline.

Patterns of Organization

Sometimes the nature of the information you collect deter- mines how you should organize it. Other times, the decision may not be so clear. In this section you’re going to examine the following types of organization:

• Chronological order

• Spatial order

• Classification/division

• Comparison/contrast

• Cause and effect

FIGURE 4—No matter how short or how long your document will be, always take time to organize your material. Sometimes, just jotting down your thoughts and ideas is a good beginning for organizing your topics.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 7

Chronological Order

Chronological order has to do with time and sequence. A document written in chronological order presents the material in the order in which it happened or should happen. For example, suppose you must write a report on the steps necessary to perform a particular production task.

You would start with the first step and proceed in the order in which the steps should occur. Such information fits naturally into the chronological order pattern.

Material written in chronological order uses words like first, second, third, next, then, after, and finally. These terms help the reader establish the order in which things occur.

Spatial Order

Spatial order involves physical space. A document written in spatial order presents the material in the order in which it is physically arranged. For example, suppose you want to describe the arrangement of furniture in a room. You might begin with one corner and work your way around

the walls. Or maybe you’ve been given the responsibility to develop the layout of your production area or office space or the arrangement of products in a showroom. Such material would lend itself to organization in spatial order.

Material written in spatial order uses words and phrases like at the extreme left, next, above, over, under, beneath, to the right, and at the end.

Classification/Division

To use the classification/division pattern to develop a document, you begin with a collection of items of any kind and then group, or classify, them according to some similar property or properties. Or you may begin with one whole item and divide it into various parts.

 

 

Improving Your Writing8

Suppose your boss wants a report on all the clients your department worked with last year and the types of jobs you did for each one. You start out with a list of all the jobs you completed last year. Then you could group them according to client or according to the type of job. This type of information lends itself well to the classification/division pattern of organization.

Comparison/Contrast

When you compare two or more items, you show how they’re similar; when you contrast two or more items, you show how they’re different. When preparing a document, you may use only comparison or only contrast, or you may encounter a subject that should show both.

Suppose the department you work in uses batteries that are produced by Company A. Your supervisor has discovered that Company B produces the same kind of battery but charges approximately 25 percent less. Your supervisor wants you to look into this issue and write up your findings.

This situation is a perfect one for the comparison/contrast pattern. Once you gather all the information on both types of batteries, you can show the similarities and differences between the two types.

In setting up the material for a comparison/contrast docu- ment, you can present all of the information on one item first followed by all of the information on the other item. Or you may decide to discuss the similarities and/or differences one by one, going back and forth from one item to the other.

Cause and Effect

Cause and effect organization involves examining certain elements (causes) to determine what will occur (effects). For example, you may work in a department that produces parts for automobile radios. You want to know how production would

 

 

Improving Your Writing 9

be affected if you added one more machine to your depart- ment. The adding of the machine is the cause, and the change in production is the effect.

Although most reports written in the cause-and-effect organization begin with the cause and proceed to the effect, you can also begin with the effect and work backward to the cause. For example, you may have noticed that the quality control employees in your department have recently been discovering a high percent of defective parts, and you want to know why. In this case, you begin with the effect (a high number of defective parts) and work toward the cause of this problem.

Outline Options

Preparing an outline is an important part of any writing. Don’t be tempted to skip over this task. First of all, with an outline you can see at a glance what you’re going to include in your document. An outline can also reveal to you that you’ve left something out. If so, you can easily add it to your outline. If you decide to revise or reorganize the information, you can do it much more easily with material in outline form than you can with written paragraphs.

The two types of outlines are sentence outlines and topic outlines.

Sentence Outline

A sentence outline consists of complete sentences for each item in the outline. This type of outline has one main advantage—it provides the topic sentences for your main paragraphs. Figure 5 presents part of a sentence outline developed for a market report.

Topic Outline

A topic outline consists of grammatically similar words or phrases, organized according to the way in which they’ll be covered in a written document. Topic outlines are more commonly used than sentence outlines and are often based on your brainstorming or initial note taking.

 

 

Improving Your Writing10

There are three advantages of topic outlines:

1. They’re easier to prepare than sentence outlines.

2. They become the basis of a table of contents for the document.

3. They supply the internal headings for your document.

Figure 5 illustrates a sentence outline, while Figure 6 depicts a topic outline of the same information.

Sentence Outline

I. Our appraisal of the retail market for HomeGym in the Roanoke Valley area of Virginia has reached a satisfactory conclusion.

A. Basic research supplied by the Association of Sporting Goods Manufacturers (ASGM) has provided the following information:

1. The Roanoke Valley area of Virginia is an appropriate market for HomeGym.

2. Competing products should not impinge on a satisfactory market share.

B. In light of the unserved market for HomeGym in the Roanoke Valley, our purpose in this report is to suggest preferred retail outlets in Roanoke and surrounding communities.

1. A research summary provided by the ASGM provides factual summaries on 14 qualified retail outlets in the Roanoke Valley.

2. The report from ASGM also includes a recommended schedule for product insertions into the qualified outlets.

II. Research provided by the ASGM explores our target market region through demographic profiles of three market segments.

FIGURE 5—Partial Sentence Outline for a Market Report

When you’re preparing a topic outline, make sure to write your words or phrases in parallel structure.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 11

Developing an Outline

Brainstorming is an excellent way to help you develop an outline for a report—or for anything you write, for that matter. Suppose you have the responsibility to put together a report on how to evaluate the quality of a used automobile. To get an idea of what you want to include in your report, you con- duct a brainstorming session. After the session, you have a pile of index cards. Each card contains an item that a person should inspect before purchasing a used car.

Next, you study the items on the cards and eliminate those that you feel are unnecessary or irrelevant. After you’ve done this, you’re left with a stack of cards that contain topics you want to cover in your report. Suppose the topics you have are those listed in Figure 7.

Once you have the topics you want to cover, you can begin to categorize them. To do this, you must arrange the items in some logical sequence or order. As you study the list of topics in Figure 7, you notice that the items fall into three main categories: exterior inspection items, interior inspection items, and engine inspection items. You arrange the cards into three separate piles, grouping them according to these three categories. Once you’ve done that, you have the start of a good outline.

Topic Outline

I. Results of appraisal

A. Research from Association of Sporting Goods Manufacturers (ASGM)

1. Appropriateness of Roanoke Valley as market for HomeGym

2. Competing products

B. Preferred retail outlets in Roanoke and surrounding communities

1. Research summary from ASGM

2. Schedule for product insertions

II. Demographic profiles of three market segments

FIGURE 6—Partial Topic Outline for a Market Report

 

 

Improving Your Writing12

Here’s what you have now:

I. Exterior inspection items Body Headlights Dents Turn signals Scratches Brake lights Rust Lights

II. Interior inspection items Air conditioner Radio Speedometer Gas gauge Passenger safety devices Door locks Seat belts Instrumentation Accessories

FIGURE 7—Here are the ideas you generated during your brainstorming session.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 13

III. Engine inspection items Fan belt Cooling system Air filter Oil filter Water pump Filters Radiator Fuel filter

Now that you have this initial outline, examine the items in each of the three major topics again. Try to determine if you can divide these main sections even further.

As you examine your beginning outline, you discover that each of the sections can be divided into two or three sub- divisions. Once you make adjustments for these subdivisions, you’re outline looks like this:

I. Exterior inspection items A. Body

1. Dents 2. Scratches 3. Rust

B. Lights 1. Turn signals 2. Headlights 3. Brake lights

II. Interior inspection items A. Instrumentation

1. Gas gauge 2. Speedometer

B. Accessories 1 Radio 2. Air conditioner

C. Passenger safety devices 1. Door locks 2. Seat belts

III. Engine inspection items A. Filters

1. Air filter 2. Oil filter 3. Fuel filter

Including headings in a report helps your readers understand the order of your material. Headings also help readers find the infor- mation they need.

 

 

Improving Your Writing14

B. Cooling system 1. Radiator 2. Fan belt 3. Water pump

Now you have something you can work with as you begin your writing. The outline gives you direction. Notice, too, that you can use this outline as your table of contents. Then, as you prepare your report, you can also use these topics as headings for the body of the document. Including them gives your readers some direction and focus as they read your information.

Practice Exercise 1 To practice sorting ideas, rearrange the following groups of ideas as instructed. Write your arrangements on a separate piece of paper.

Example A: Listen to bird-call records; Preparing for bird watching; Study bird guide; Clean and focus binoculars

Example format:

Preparing for bird watching

A. Study bird guide

B. Listen to bird-call records

C. Clean and focus binoculars

1–6: Each of the following groups contains one main idea and several other ideas that are merely examples, illustrations, or explanations of the main idea. Write the main idea and then list under it the ideas that explain or develop it more fully. Use the format in Example A for your answers.

1. Remember the Maine; Make the world safe for democracy; War slogans; Remember Pearl Harbor

2. Open Door Policy; Truman Doctrine; American foreign policy; Monroe Doctrine

3. Dirty living conditions; Causes of poor health; Absence of medical care; Poor diet

4. Overemphasis on athletics; Too much emphasis on winning; Evils of college sports; Failure to provide for the poor or average athlete

5. The actual writing; Gathering ideas; Steps in writing; Making a plan

6. The interview; Studying the help-wanted ads; How I got the job; Sending a letter of application

(Continued)

 

 

Improving Your Writing 15

Practice Exercise 1 Example B: Assembling the required utensils; Following the recipe; Decorating techniques; Baking a cake; Making the frosting; Icing the cake; Assembling the ingredients; Decorating the cake

Example format:

I. Baking a cake

A. Assembling the ingredients

B. Assembling the required utensils

C. Following the recipe

II. Decorating the cake

A. Making the frosting

B. Icing the cake

C. Decorating techniques

7–10: Each of the following groups of words and statements contains two main ideas and several other ideas that are merely examples, illustrations, or explanations of the main ideas. Find the two main ideas, and then, under each, list the ideas that explain or develop the main ones more fully as shown in Example B.

7. Eagles; Ducks; Quail; Game birds; Owls; Birds of prey; Pheasants; Hawks

8. Ice skating; Swimming; Baseball; Winter sports; Tennis; Skiing; Summer sports

9. Foul shooting; Batting; Fielding; Floor play; Set shooting; Pitching; Basketball; Guarding; Baseball

10. Sarcastic talk; Attractive appearance; Skill in conversation; Reasons for unpopularity; Pleasing personality; Selfishness; Consideration for others; Sense of humor; Reasons for popularity

Check your answers with those on page 67.

 

 

Improving Your Writing16

The Formal Outline While a formal outline may vary in structure according to the nature of a report, most outlines have three sections, which correspond to the three main sections of any written document:

1. Introduction (A, or abstract)

2. Body (B)

3 Summary (C, or conclusion)

The following paragraphs briefly review these three sections.

Introduction (Abstract)

The introduction establishes the purpose of your report. To make that purpose clear or to put it in context, you may also include background information that explains the history of the problem and the reasons it demands attention. Perhaps the most important part of the introduction is a list of the major topics discussed in the body of the report. Needless to say, the topics should be listed in the order in which they’ll be covered in the body of the report.

Body

The body of your report should contain the information needed to fulfill the purpose of your report. It will elaborate on each of the major topics given in the introduction. Your outline of the body of your report should be logically ordered in terms of major headings, secondary headings, and possibly detailed headings under the secondary headings.

Summary (Conclusion)

The summary of most reports briefly repeats the main topics and draws conclusions that lead to recommendations. A purely technical report, however, may simply come to a conclusion that’s the basis of the report. For example, a discussion of the utility of a particular kind of circuit board may simply end with a concluding statement that declares the thing useful in a certain context.

A formal outline generally follows a particular pattern, as shown in Figure 8.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 17

The Structure of a Formal Outline

I. Introduction

A. Background

B. Statement of purpose

C. Sources of researched information

D. Explanation of why some data is unavailable

E. Definitions of terms or concepts

F. Sequence of major topics discussed in report:

1. Major topic #1

2. Major topic #2

3. Major topic #3

II. Major topic #1

A. First subtopic

1. Detail of first subtopic

2. Detail of first subtopic

B. Second subtopic

1. Detail of second subtopic

2. Detail of second subtopic

a. Subdetail of second subtopic

b. Subdetail of second subtopic

III. Major topic #2

(This topic follows the same developmental structure as major topic #1.)

IV. Major topic #3

(This topic follows the same developmental structure as major topic #1.)

V. Summary

A. Restatement of main theme or concept

B. Conclusion(s)

C. Recommendation(s)

FIGURE 8—A formal out- line generally follows the structure shown here.

 

 

Improving Your Writing18

In a formal outline, you may have only two major topics, or you may have many more. Some major topics will have subtopics and details of those subtopics; other major topics may have no subtopics at all.

Finally, if you divide a topic into subtopics, you must include at least two subtopics. Never list only one item under a topic.

Incorrect: Correct:

I. Introduction I. Introduction A. Topic 1 A. Topic 1

1. Subtopic 1. Subtopic 1 B. Topic 2 2. Subtopic 2

B. Topic 2

In the incorrect example, “Topic 1” has only one subtopic. This is an incorrect construction. The correct outline lists two subtopics under “Topic 1.” Think of it this way: You can’t divide something and end up with only one part. When you divide a topic, you must list at least two subtopics.

Remember that your outline, whether informal or formal, is a working document that can be changed if necessary. If you discover that a topic requires further breakdown or that one of your subtopics is worthy of more attention, by all means, revise your plan. After all, the outline is meant to help you organize your work, not discourage curiosity or hinder inspiration.

Now take some time to practice what you’ve learned. Complete Practice Exercise 2, then go on to Self-Check 1.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 19

Practice Exercise 2 Now that you’ve learned the basics of outlining, try developing your own formal outline. You may have to research your subject if you need general information or details to complete your outline. Choose a topic that interests you and decide on the pattern of organization you’ll use, because we’ll be building on this outline for future writing assignments.

Prepare a formal topic outline for a composition on one of the following subjects. Use words or phrases for your outline.

How to Work with a Business Partner

Florence Nightingale: A Woman with a Vision

Getting Ahead through Education

My Plan for Professional Advancement

The Advantages of Online Education

Professional Journals: Something for Everyone

The Best Boss I Ever Had

Three Things I Learned on My First Job

Check your outline against the suggestions on page 69. This exercise is for your own benefit. Do not send your outline to the school.

 

 

Improving Your Writing20

Self-Check 1

At the end of each section of Improving Your Writing, you’ll be asked to pause and check your understanding of what you’ve just read by completing a “self-check” exercise. Answering these questions will help you review what you’ve studied so far. Please complete Self-Check 1 now.

1. a. Five types of prewriting are

__________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________

b. During prewriting, the three things you must determine are

__________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________

c. The goal of prewriting exercises is to find

__________________________________________________________

2. Looking to outside sources for ideas or information is called _______.

3. What pattern of organization would be most appropriate for the following subjects?

a. Why production is down in Department A b. Whether you should purchase your supplies from Company A or Company B c. The steps in the process of producing your product d. The physical rearrangement of a manufacturing plant e. The reason for poor morale f. Items to be included on a routine safety inspection

4. Explain the advantages of sentence and topic outlines.

__________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________

__________________________________________________________

Check your answers with those on page 73.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 21

WRITING YOUR DOCUMENT

Types of Writing

No matter what type of writing assignment you’re planning to do, each one requires the same basic approach. Whether you’re jotting an informal note to a friend or composing an important business report, you can rely on the same process you’ve been practicing. Generally, in the prewriting and planning stages, you’ll be making decisions about your topic, your audience, and your purpose. You’ll organize your ideas and determine whether you have the information you need to complete the assignment. You may even have to do some research to fill in the details of your outline.

For very informal writing, some of these steps may take place inside your head—after all, if you’re only writing a thank-you note to Aunt Ethel, you already know the audience, the purpose, and the topic. But you still might scribble a quick list before you begin, so you don’t forget anything you wanted to say.

Once you’ve organized your material, the next stage is writing the first draft. Using your outline or map diagram, you should try to write straight through without doing any revising along the way. Then you’ll get all your ideas down, and if there’s missing information or facts you need to check, you can take care of them during the first revision. As you revise and rewrite, follow along on your outline to make sure all your facts and details are in the right places and you’ve developed your topic logically. Also check for run-on sentences and fragments.

Once you’ve completed and edited the assignment to your satisfaction, it’s best to set it aside for a few hours, or even a day or two, if you have the time, so you can look at it with fresh eyes when you proofread. That way you’re less likely to overlook simple mistakes, such as missing or misspelled words, awkward phrases, or punctuation errors.

 

 

Improving Your Writing22

The final step in the writing process is presenting your writing—that is, allowing your audience to read it. Whether you’re e-mailing a memo to coworkers or sending your com- pany’s advertising flier to the printer, your finished document is a reflection of your professionalism and the care you put into your work.

Now let’s take a closer look at two kinds of writing: informal and formal.

Informal Writing

Planning what you want to write can often be done in your mind, but you might also make a list. For example, if you want to leave instructions for your babysitter, you might quickly write the following list:

• Snack at 8:30

• Bedtime at 9:00

• Read story

• Turn on nightlight

• Number to reach me

From this list, you can write your note (Figure 9).

Notice that the note in Figure 9 includes one bit of information that wasn’t on the list—the time the couple will return home. People often think of things to add when they work from a writing plan.

Judy,

If you need me, call the Grady residence at 555-2343. Please give Jason a snack of two cookies and milk at 8:30. His bedtime is 9:00. Get him started to bed by 8:45. When he’s in bed, read him a story. He likes Goodnight Moon. Be sure to turn on his bedroom nightlight before turning off his bedstand light.

We should be back by 12:00 at the latest. FIGURE 9—Here’s one possible note you might write from the list.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 23

This is a short, simple note, so what you’ve written may be your final draft. However, you should always reread what you’ve written. Correct spelling errors, and make sure you’ve given complete instructions.

Suppose you want to write a personal letter to an old friend (Figure 10). You haven’t written to her in a while, but you’ve just learned that she has a new job. You’re curious about how that’s going. You would also like to get back in touch with your friend.

In writing a personal letter, you’ll almost surely want to plan what you have to say. You may do that in your mind or by making a note or two on scratch paper.

Next, you write a first draft and then edit that draft. As you edit, you may decide to add a sentence or two. You may decide to cross out a sentence or two. You may want to reword something. And, of course, you’ll correct any errors you find.

After writing your final draft, you would be wise to go over it again.

Formal Writing

Formal and impersonal writing generally refers to business letters and reports that are not of a personal nature.

Letters. Suppose you decide to apply for a sales position at the local Mazda dealership. You would write and then send a formal application letter with your resume. You definitely want to plan and research the information for this letter. You’ll make sure you know how to spell the name of the deal- ership manager. You’ll make sure you understand what the job requires. Talking to someone who already has a job at the dealership may be a good idea. Finally, you should refer to your strongest qualifications, including appropriate job experience, education, and references, as listed in your resume.

FIGURE 10—Personal letters, once a common means of communication, have gone out of style with the advent of e-mail. However, most people appreciate a handwritten personal note or letter.

 

 

Improving Your Writing24

How do you write the first draft of your application letter? Very carefully. An application letter is a sales letter. You’re selling yourself. You want to make a positive impression, because first impressions really do matter.

As you edit your first draft, ask yourself these questions: If you were getting this letter from someone you didn’t know, how would you like it? Would you be impressed? Would you want to hire this person?

The final draft of your letter should be stronger than your first draft. Even so, you’ll be wise to let it rest overnight before you reread it. If more editing is necessary, edit away.

Reports and records. Reports and business or medical records are other kinds of formal writing you may need to do. While memos and business e-mails are somewhat less formal, they’re still in the realm of professional writing that requires proper organization, accuracy, and a businesslike tone. While each office generally has its own style and requirements, in which you’ll be trained, your knowledge of the basics of stan- dard writing should apply to all of them.

Using a Style Guide

The company you work for may use a standard style guide, such as The Chicago Manual of Style, to standardize language use in its documents. Your company may have a style sheet to standardize formatting, as well. By using established styles, company documents—from business letters to client files to reports to major publications—remain consistent. Consistency makes documents look professional and helps ensure accuracy, as well as readability, as they pass from employee to employee, department to department, or out into the business world. A standard style also saves time, since once you’re familiar with it, you won’t have to make decisions for each project, rely on reference books, or ask questions about format or other details.

A company style sheet may include a variety of formatting guidelines, including which paper to use and when and how you may abbreviate the company name. In some cases, these items won’t be written into a formal handbook, but will be

 

 

Improving Your Writing 25

used as standards throughout the company. If that’s the case, you may find it useful to make your own reference list as you learn your company’s style.

Style sheets often include standards such as the following:

• Proper use of company name and logo

• Use of letterhead

• Preferred abbreviations

• Preferred spellings

• Standard typefaces

• Heading styles

• Standard document sizes

• Standard margins

• Stationery choices

• Cover or binding options

Key Considerations

As mentioned earlier, when you develop any piece of writing, you must remember these three factors:

1. The purpose of your message. Some messages are meant to give instructions. Some messages are e-mails or personal letters. Other things you may write might explain what you’ve learned, whether it be about a new medical proce- dure or redesigning a kitchen. Or you may want to convince your employer to purchase a different software version. Always think about the purpose of your message.

2. Your audience. What you write should always be aimed at your audience—that is, the people who will read the message. A note to your babysitter will be written in simple language. A report to your employer will be written in more formal language.

 

 

Improving Your Writing26

3. The medium, or how best to send your message. The way you send your message goes along with its purpose and its audience. For example, a short, informative message to a friend may be sent by e-mail, and the language can be casual. A letter to your state representative, on the other hand, should be formal and carefully edited. It should be sent on proper letter stationery. A report for your history class may have to be in a special format. For example, your instructor may want your paper to be double-spaced and have a cover page.

Because what you write must be based on your purpose and audience, we’ll now look at some examples of how to put those elements together. The best way to understand how to accomplish that is to consider how the same topic would be treated for different audiences. For instance, suppose a nurse at the hospital where you work has developed a program

to encourage female students to study science and math in high school and to promote interest in nursing as a profession (Figure 11). Here are examples of three different approaches that might be used to write about this topic, guided by purpose and audience.

Introduction to an article for the hospital newsletter; general audience; less formal

Helen Bloom, MSN, an education specialist in the Birth and Family Education program, loves her job. She loves it so much that she wants young women to know how varied, challenging, and satisfying a career in nursing can be. That’s why Helen spends two morn- ings a week traveling to middle schools and high schools around the state, sharing her story with the students and helping math and science faculty set up a program to encourage girls to prepare for a career in nursing. She calls her program Chem Girls Rock.

FIGURE 11—Three different approaches to writing about the same topic, such as nursing, will produce very different results.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 27

Recommendation to hospital board of trustees; executive audience; more formal

I am pleased to recommend Helen R. Bloom, MSN, education specialist, for this year’s Volunteer Hero award. Ms. Bloom has shown generosity, enthusiasm, and consistent dedication to her field by developing an educational program to encourage female students to prepare for a career in nursing. Her program, Chem Girls Rock, which includes working with high school faculty and guidance departments to promote girls’ study of math and science, organizing Chem Girls clubs, and individually counseling girls, has resulted in an average 36 percent increase in girls’ participation in advanced science classes in the seven counties where she has introduced her program. Ms. Bloom’s efforts have also been acknowledged as a key influence in nearly tripling the number of applications for the nursing programs at Community College, State University, and Fairdale College.

Personal letter; private audience; informal

Dear Jess,

Guess what? I can’t believe it, but I’ve won the Volunteer Hero award at the hospital! I’m so excited—I really didn’t expect it at all. But I’m also proud of what we’ve accomplished with Chem Girls, and the numbers look really good, at least on paper. How many girls actually graduate with their RNs or BSNs may be another story. But this award includes a pretty hefty grant, so maybe now I can expand into a support program at the colleges to make sure we get those graduates.

Here’s another situation that could require several different approaches for different audiences. Suppose there have been three accidents in Martell’s department in the past two months and people are nervous about what might happen next if the situation doesn’t improve. As the department safety officer, Martell needs to write to his division manager asking for maintenance expenditures to make repairs that may prevent further accidents. He’d also like funds for a workshop on safety for the staff (even though there’s a budget freeze). Then he needs to write a memo to the staff

 

 

Improving Your Writing28

to let them know he’s working on the problem. Finally, he has to write a brief, factual report on what has happened and why, which will go to the assistant manager and the general manager of the company. Each requires a different level of formality and a different tone.

For the division manager; executive audience; more formal

As you know, our department has experienced several accidents recently, two of which were directly related to this year’s spending cap for maintenance. While I understand the need for some cutbacks, our department is literally falling apart, with a ceiling vent falling on one of the clerks and a piece of broken moulding tripping a technician. I strongly advise that the repairs be taken care of immediately, regardless of cost, to prevent further injuries and potential lawsuits. In addition, I would like to bring in a speaker from Safety Tech, Inc. to address other safety issues, such as hotplates in offices, two-way swinging doors, and proper lifting techniques. The cost would be approximately $250 for a two-hour workshop for our 14 staff members. I hope you will find these expenses to be in the best interest of the company and its employees.

For the staff; general audience; less formal

Memo

To: Commercial Planning Staff

From: Martell Williams

Date: May 22, 2006

Re: Safety Issues

We’re all aware of the recent accidents and injuries in our department. I want you to know that I’ve addressed the issue with Joe Perez and he assures me that repairs will be made as soon as he can arrange them. In the meantime, please e-mail me regarding any problems you notice and I’ll add them to the list of areas for the maintenance survey. Also, I’ve arranged a safety workshop to be held on June 4, which will help us prevent further problems. If you have any other concerns, please let me know.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 29

For the report; executive audience; more formal

Deferred Maintenance Issues

In the past two months, the Commercial Planning Department has experienced several accidents, all of which were preventable had normal maintenance procedures and safety routines been followed. The incidents occurred as follows:

• April 4, 3:15 PM: Maike Schott was hit when an overhead vent fell on her, resulting in bruises and a small abrasion to her shoulder.

• April 19, 11:45 AM: Richard Sabbatini burned his left hand while using an unauthorized electric hotplate.

• May 17, 9:25 AM: Julian O’Reilly fractured his right wrist after tripping on fallen moulding in the pathway.

Specifics

Ms. Schott had reported on March 29 that the vent was hanging and seemed to be in imminent danger of falling, so I immediately called maintenance. Cal Stephens told me there was a freeze on “optional repairs,” but he would assess the situation and do what he could. The next day the vent appeared to be fastened up with duct tape. No further effort at repair was made.

Regarding the second incident, while heat-producing appliances are clearly against safety regulations, I was not aware the hotplate was in Mr. Sabbatini’s office. Evidently, I need to be more vigilant in my monthly safety inspections.

The last incident occurred after a piece of moulding fell to the floor; Mr. O’Reilly was carrying a bulky piece of equipment and was unable to regain his balance after tripping over the moulding. I have removed the moulding and stored it in a closet until repairs can be made.

 

 

Improving Your Writing30

Recommendation

Our department has several additional areas in need of repair; they should be addressed immediately if we are to prevent further injuries and potential lawsuits. As safety officer, I recommend a complete maintenance survey of the department and prompt repair, replace- ment, or removal of equipment and systems found to be damaged or deteriorating.

As you keep your reader’s perspective in mind, you may find that in certain instances, the passive voice is more useful than the active voice. This is particularly true when you want to emphasize what’s being done, rather than who’s doing it. For instance, if you’re writing a letter or e-mail to answer a client’s question, it’s best if sentences don’t begin with I or We. Rather than saying, “I consulted the technician to see how we might resolve your problem as soon as possible,” you may say, “Your problem is being addressed by the technician and should be resolved within two days.” In this case, the passive sounds more direct to the reader, because he or she is more concerned about the problem than who is addressing it.

The passive voice is also useful for delivering a negative message. It helps by focusing attention on the action, not the person performing it, while maintaining a professional tone. For instance, suppose employees received this memo regarding the company dress code.

Preston Casey, General Manager, has announced a new dress code that bans any article of clothing that is decorated with political statements, lewd or suggestive pictures or language, fringe, chains, or similar deco- rations, as well as overly loose or tight clothing. Mr. Casey said that safety and morale issues are behind the new rules.

People would probably be angry and resentful of the manager, even if they understood the reason for the rule. But by considering the audience’s perspective and using the passive voice, you might soften the blow by writing a memo more like this:

Due to safety considerations, clothing decorated with fringe, chains, or other long or loose materials may no longer be worn to work. Clothing should fit the wearer

 

 

Improving Your Writing 31

in a way that minimizes the risk of its catching in machinery or causing tripping. Also, to maintain an atmosphere of mutual respect among employees, clothing, posters, and stickers conveying political statements and lewd or suggestive pictures and language are also excluded.

While the message is basically the same, the second example offers reasons first and doesn’t feel as much like a direct order from the general manager. It also stresses benefits to the reader (avoiding accidents, mutual respect), which may not always be possible to emphasize in a negative message.

Practice Exercise 3 Now use this opportunity to practice what you’ve learned. In this exercise, you’ll write three messages, each with a different purpose and audience, based on the situation given. Use the pattern of organization indicated for each message.

A friend of yours recently was struck and injured by a driver who was talking on a cell phone. In response, write the following:

1. A letter to a state representative urging a law banning cell phone use while driving (cause-and-effect order)

2. An e-mail to another friend telling her what happened (chronological order)

3. The first paragraph of a research paper on the effects of using a cell phone while driving (compare/contrast with other dangerous driving behavior)

(Continued)

 

 

Improving Your Writing32

Practice Exercise 3 The following are writing examples that are badly in need of rewriting. Based on the ideas presented, use what you’ve learned so far to identify the errors. Then revise each example and make it more appropriate to its purpose and audience.

4. Business letter requesting a speaker

Dear George,

How are you? I am new at MDI and was told to write and see if I could get a trainer for our workshop this spring. I guess you’re on the cutting edge of all the new equipment, and we need to bring everyone up to speed, so that will be good. Just let me know if you can come and what the bottom line is.

Thanks for your help.

Simon Smith

5. Memo inviting employees to company picnic

Interoffice Memorandum

To: MY ESTEEMED SUBORDINATES

From: HARRISON Q. SPLENDID, CEO

Subject: INTRACORPORATIONAL GALA

Date: 10 JUNE 2006

Mr. Harrison Q. Splendid, CEO requests the honour of your presence

at the gala of the millennium celebrating another lucrative year

for Splendid Products, Inc. Friday, the twenty-first of July

Two thousand and six at eleven o’clock in the morning

Church Street Park West Orange, Florida

Weather-appropriate garb Luncheon and diversions to follow

Check your messages against the suggestions on page 69. This exercise is for your own benefit. Do not send your writing to the school.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 33

Writing the First Draft

Once you’ve ordered the main points you wish to make, you’re ready to write the first draft. Some writers work laboriously, trying to get every word and every comma perfect in the first draft. However, the typical human mind simply isn’t set up to work that way. You shouldn’t put that sort of “perfection pressure” on yourself. You’ll find that your thoughts and your language flow much more smoothly if you write without stopping.

Don’t try to do too many things at one time when writing. Don’t attempt to write, edit, and rewrite each sentence and paragraph as you proceed. You’ll only get bogged down in the process and lose track of what you’re trying to communi- cate. You can avoid this problem by doing what many profes- sional writers do—write straight through, letting your thoughts come out in writing as best they can. Follow your outline or map, but don’t stop to edit or rewrite.

If you veer away from the planned topic for a little while, don’t worry about it—your creative mind may be leading you to even better material (Figure 12). Any irrelevant digressions can be deleted later. (If you don’t know the meaning of digressions, look up the verb form digress in your diction- ary.) Just let the writing flow. You’ll get the tough part behind you, and often the writing will be less stilted because you’re more apt to write the way you speak.

Whether you hand- write or work on a typewriter or word processor, it’s wise to double-space your work. Doing so will give you the space you’ll need for revi- sions.

FIGURE 12—Don’t worry if you wander off your topic a bit in your first draft—detours sometimes lead to wonderful discov- eries.

 

 

Improving Your Writing34

Practice Exercise 4 Using the outline you wrote for Practice Exercise 2, write a first draft of your introduction, major topics, and conclusion. Follow your outline as you write, writing straight through without stopping to revise or edit your work, but keep in mind your audience, purpose, and pattern of organization. Keep this draft, because you’ll be working with it again later.

Check your draft against the suggestions given on page 71. This exercise is for your own benefit. Do not send your first draft to the school.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 35

Self-Check 2

1. You’re more likely to _______ in your writing if you let it rest for a day or two.

2. A brief report to your supervisor on client complaints is an example of _______ writing.

3. The purpose of a _______ is to maintain consistency throughout a company’s documents.

4. When you write your _______, it’s best to write without stopping.

5. _______ in your first draft sometimes lead to better material for your topic.

6. Your _______ serves as a map, guiding you to your conclusion.

7. A letter to an old friend is an example of _______ writing

8. The language you choose for your message should match its _______.

9. If you _______ your work, it will be easier to insert revisions later.

10. Your approach to any piece of writing is determined by its _______.

Check your answers with those on page 73.

 

 

Improving Your Writing36

STRENGTHENING YOUR STYLE

How to Give Your Writing Punch This section is called “How to Give Your Writing Punch.” Do you think it would have been better to call it “How Added Punch Can Be Given to Your Writing?” No; you can easily see that it wouldn’t. But just why is “How to Give Your Writing Punch” better than “How Added Punch Can Be Given to Your Writing?”

Let’s look a little more closely at the two titles. First of all, “How to Give Your Writing Punch” is shorter. It has six words, and the other title has nine. Second, the verb is in the active voice (give) in one title and in the passive voice (be given) in the other. Third, “How to Give Your Writing Punch” has the main word, punch, at the end, whereas the other title buries it in the middle. So our title is better than “How Added Punch Can Be Given to Your Writing” because it follows these four rules:

1. Be brief.

2. Use active verbs.

3. Wind up with a bang.

4. Arrange your words and sentences effectively.

We’ve already discussed being brief, and you learned about active and passive voice in an earlier study unit. The active voice, you remember, makes for stronger sentences because they’re generally shorter, lead with the subject, and use an active verb.

Alfredo disarmed the robber.

The passive voice begins with the object and depends on some form of the verb to be.

The robber was disarmed by Alfredo.

The passive voice is useful when it’s important to emphasize the object, rather than the subject. For instance, in business, you’re likely to say “Results of the survey will be released by the company at a later date” (passive voice), because the

 

 

Improving Your Writing 37

emphasis is on the results, not the company. But when you’re making direct statements or, especially, writing persuasively, use the active voice.

Now let’s go on to the third point, winding up with a bang. How does that contribute to good writing? Actually, it’s the most important guideline for giving your writing punch. If you’re like most people and save the best bite of your sandwich or the frosting on your cake until last, then you won’t have much trouble with this rule. Another way of seeing this idea is to picture the grand finale of a fireworks display. The principle is exactly the same: You save the most important or most effective word or idea to use at the end of the sentence. If you always start with the choice bits, you won’t have any icing left to top off your sentences. If you pay a little attention, however, you’ll learn to build all your sentences to a rousing conclusion.

There’s no general rule for ending with a bang. You must know which word or idea in each sentence you want to lead up to. You must make up your mind what word to put at the end, where it will stick in the reader’s mind.

Suppose Richard is your best friend. He owns his own busi- ness, and he has a beautiful daughter, Becky. You want to write something about Richard and include all these things about him. But the question is, in what order? The choice depends on you—on the thing you consider most important and most remarkable about Richard, the thing you really want to tell your reader about him. Whatever it is, the trick is to put it last (Figure 13).

This is how you write about Richard, father of Becky:

My best friend Richard, a busi- ness owner, has a beautiful daugh- ter named Becky.

FIGURE 13—Richard is a business owner, a father, and your best friend. Which fact is most important about your subject? Put that fact at the end of your sentence.

 

 

Improving Your Writing38

This is how you write about Richard, the business owner:

My best friend Richard (Becky’s father) owns his own business.

And this is how you write about Richard, your best friend:

Becky’s father Richard, a business owner, is my best friend.

Adding Punch with Punctuation

The dash (—) is an attention getter. Sometimes a phrase set off with dashes can add meaning and emphasis to your writing. Compare the following two sentences:

For Christmas, I got a sweater, a couple of books, and an accordion.

For Christmas, I got a sweater, a couple of books, and—what I wanted most—an accordion.

The first sentence is merely a list of gifts that the writer received. No single gift is given more importance than the others. But in the second sentence, one gift, an accordion, is singled out from the others through the use of the phrase what I wanted most, which is set off with dashes.

When printed in a book or article, a dash is a single line that’s longer than a hyphen. In your typing, you may indicate a dash by using two hyphens in a row–like this. Some word processing programs automatically change the two hyphens into a dash.

A word of caution: Don’t overuse dashes. If you use dashes repeatedly in the same piece of writing, they soon lose their punch. Dashes can easily become a distraction when used over and over.

Exclamation points, too, should be used with care. Don’t try to use them to dress up a sentence that isn’t exciting in the first place. The punch must come from the inside—that is, from the words. If you haven’t built up to an idea, then you can’t expect it to make an impression just because it’s followed by an exclamation point. In this sentence, for instance, the exclamation point doesn’t help at all:

 

 

Improving Your Writing 39

There were blooming magnolia trees, I noticed, when I was walking along Elm Street last Wednesday!

But if you build up your idea properly, you can stress the important point without using an exclamation point:

Walking along Elm Street last Wednesday, I had an unforgettable experience: I saw the street lined with 100 magnolia trees in full bloom.

Word and Sentence Patterns

Dashes and exclamation points are handy tools to use once in a while. But you can add more punch by other means. You can build up to your final word by preparing the reader’s mind for what’s going to come. You can form your words and sentences into patterns so that the idea you want to play up comes at a natural high point. You can arrange your words in such a way that they build in power (Figure 14).

There’s no single rule for doing this. You can build word patterns in many different ways. You can form a pattern by repeating a word or phrase; by following three or four long sentences with a short one; by putting a few short sentences before a long one; by writing your words in a rhythmical pattern; or by doing several of these things together. In other words, you can play with your language and make it do tricks. Of course, you wouldn’t want to do this always, but it’s useful to know how to make your words more effective when you need them to be.

Suppose you’re writing about the first time you flew in an airplane. There wouldn’t be much punch in it if you wrote it this way:

FIGURE 14—If you’re writing about an exciting experience, you want your reader to feel the same thrill you felt during the event.

 

 

Improving Your Writing40

Then the plane turned and left the ground, and I thought that this was the first time I was flying and looked out of the window. I had to be strapped to my seat with a belt.

But here’s how you can build the idea up by repeating the word flying:

The plane turned and left the ground. We were in the air. All my life I had been thinking about flying. I had been reading about flying. I had been dreaming about flying. The moment was here. It was 7:35 A.M., Sunday, July 26. I was flying.

Another way to add drama is to put your idea into a short sentence that follows three long ones. That’s called a crack- of-a-whip ending:

Strapped to my seat with a belt, I sat tense and excited and looked out the window. Now the plane made a sharp turn and, with the engines roaring, gathered speed and finally left the ground. The moment that I had been thinking and dreaming about ever since I could remember had come. I was flying.

And now show your excitement by the rhythm of the words:

Gathering speed, the plane rolled on. It left the ground and rose into the air. The moment had come: I was flying.

Finally, here are a few tricks in combination: word rhythm, a repeated phrase, and a crack-of-a-whip ending:

The plane turned, the engines started roaring again, and up we went. The airport buildings sank away. “This is it,” I said to myself. “This is it at last. I’m flying.”

If you’re reading for revision and find a sentence that just doesn’t sound right, try reviewing these points to see if your sentence needs rearrangement or rewriting to give it more weight. By cutting unnecessary words, using the active voice, and saving the best for last, you may find your sentences are more effective in expressing your ideas clearly and with just enough punch.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 41

Choosing the Right Words Finding the right words can be challenging. However, some tools that apply to business writing are available to help you in this task:

• Use concrete and specific words.

• Avoid jargon.

• Be cautious about choosing informality over formality.

• Avoid pomposity.

• Eliminate sexist language.

• Use words properly.

Let’s examine each one of these principles individually.

Concrete and Specific Words

People who write novels and short stories use concrete words to place their reader in a specific setting, to make that person feel the situation. For example, in fiction, a novelist might write, “The asphalt smelled of rain and diesel fuel,” instead of “The asphalt was wet.” In business writing, however, your main goal is to help your reader know, not feel. In both literature and business writing, concreteness is about getting your reader’s undivided attention. Consider and compare the general and specific approaches in the following sentences.

General: Our report covered the entire problem at the Bluefield plant.

Specific: Our January 18 report analyzed, located, and solved the parts-supply problems that have been reducing output at the Bluefield assembly plant.

General: The cost of the new forklift is justified by its need.

Specific: The $30,000 spent on the new forklift is justified by the 25% increase in business over the last year and by the $500,000 in additional stock we now have in our warehouse.

The art of word choice is referred to as diction. Selecting the correct word and using it effectively is known as rhetoric.

 

 

Improving Your Writing42

The general statements in the preceding examples are accurate and factual, but they lack important information. They lack facts and figures. Notice how much more the reader learns from the specific statements. Rather than making mere assertions (our report covered the entire problem) and generalizations (the cost of the new forklift), present your information in a clear, specific, and logical way. A reader is more likely to pay attention to specific sentences than to general ones, because they present information the reader needs.

Jargon

Jargon refers to the specialized vocabulary of a specific activity or group. Generally, there are two kinds of jargon:

1. It may be the specialized technical language peculiar to some academic or industrial environment. For example, electrical engineers, mathematicians, and accountants each have a vocabulary that relates specifically to their area of expertise. This type of jargon is intelligible and useful to specialists in the field, but it can be very confusing to outsiders.

2. It may be a special language that has developed within a corporation. In this case, jargon is a kind of insider language that separates “us” from “them.” This type of jargon is also confusing to outsiders.

As an example of a specialized technical language, consider two archeologists working at an excavation. You overhear one of them ask, “Did you notice the supraorbital torus on that skull fragment from S-14?” His companion’s reply might be, “I did. Definitely distinctive.” You may read that conversation over and over and never understand its meaning, unless you’re familiar with the jargon of archeologists. To the two specialists, however, the exchange is crystal clear: The skull fragment from the S-14 location designated by the site coor- dinate map has a pronounced or unusual brow ridge. You can see that specialized language, which is unintelligible to nonspecialists, is useful shorthand for the archeologists.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 43

As an example of insider language, suppose you overhear yourself referred to as the “person in green” at “meat processing.” It may take you a while to understand that you’ve simply been referred to as a new employee in the human resources department.

This type of insider jargon isn’t likely to show up in a memo or letter. However, some kinds of jargon—typically the technical kind—are often used inappropriately. For example, a stockbroker may write a follow-up letter to a potential investor. In the letter, the broker says, “You’ll be pleased to know how well our firm stays on top of P/E ratios.” This investor may know that a P/E ratio refers to a price-earnings ratio, but she may not be certain just what that means. When you write, be alert to the jargon you use. Unless you’re writing to someone familiar with your field, make sure you use terms that nonspecialists can understand.

The use of personal computers and electronic communication has created a whole new world of computer jargon. Today, almost everyone who engages in business or personal writing uses a computer. However, that doesn’t mean that everyone who uses a computer understands terms like http, ISP, ICQ, URL, and ftp. Even if people know what the letters stand for, they may not understand what these letters real- ly mean. Be judicious in your use of high-tech terms, even if you’re knowledgeable about those expres- sions (Figure 15). When you must use technical terms to an audience that may be unfamiliar with them, always include an explanation.

In business writing, the problem with jargon is always the same: It obscures information. And obscured information is seldom useful. If you’re tempted to use insider or technical jargon in an effort to impress your reader, think again. Confusing people to impress

“Before we start, I want everyone to disable the antivirus program. Please right-click on

the icon in your System Tray, and uncheck the appropriate box.”

FIGURE 15—The leader of this seminar may be familiar with jargon like disable, antivirus, right-click, icon, sys- tem tray, and uncheck, but the beginners in his class are probably thoroughly confused.

 

 

Improving Your Writing44

them is poor communication. If you feel the need to use a specialized term, ask yourself if your audience will clearly understand it. If they won’t, you’re offering jargon. When in doubt, explain, revise, or delete.

Informality and Formality How do you determine whether to develop a specific piece of writing in a formal or an informal tone? The answer is the same as that for determining the jargon you should use— know your audience. As e-mails increasingly dominate com- munication between businesses, the temptation to engage in sloppy informality seems to have increased as well. That’s why it’s so important to know your audience. An informal, sketchy e-mail to your friend in the shipping department may be fine. However, a document prepared for a supervisor or an executive should be framed somewhat more formally, at least in terms of emphasizing a courteous, professional tone.

The key to most effective business communication is the use of professional, yet conversational, language. In general, memos, letters, reports, and even brief e-mails should exhibit a positive, warm, friendly, conversational, and professional tone. Use plain language that you’re comfortable and familiar with. Use familiar pronouns such as I, we, and you; avoid third-person expressions such as the undersigned or the affected party.

Although you want to be friendly and conversational, don’t be tempted to use slang or colloquial expressions like bummed out, lousy, get my act together, and sacked. These phrases may be permissible in everyday conversations, but they’re out of place in business writing.

Examine the three sentences in Figure 16. In business and technical writing, your goal is to be friendly and polite, with- out being too casual or too formal. As you can see from this illustration, the stiff language in the formal version is more difficult to read than that in the informal version. Also, the formal version may actually seem offensive to many who read it. On the other hand, the casual colloquial version is out of place in business writing.

Know your audience. That’s the key to whether you use technical jargon or common language, to whether you use a formal or an informal tone.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 45

Pomposity

Pomposity is formality carried to extremes. Your writing is likely to be considered pompous if you use words like aforementioned instead of previous, ubiquitous instead of widespread, superfluous instead of extra, or deleterious instead of harmful. Consider these two paragraphs:

Pompous: It has become evident through complaints proffered to management that the resistance of employees to standards of conformity with linguistic cafeteria decorum has become ubiquitous and, thereby, has placed a deleterious burden on the cafeteria staff.

Conversational: Some of us in the front office have been receiving complaints about the frequent use of careless language in the company cafeteria. Remember to be courteous to your fellow employees, including the hard-working cafeteria staff.

In general, to avoid seeming pompous in your writing, use clear, plain language and a conversational tone (Figure 17). Above all, remember that your objective is to convey clear, logical, and accurate information.

Casual (Colloquial and Slang Usage)

I was totally bummed out when my boss nixed my vacation.

Informal (Polite, but

Conversational Tone)

I was disappointed when my supervisor did not approve my vacation.

Formal (Wordy and Stiff

Language)

It was with sincere disappoint- ment that I learned my request for vacation did not meet with my supervisor’s approbation.

FIGURE 16—Here are three ways to say the same thing—from the extreme casual to the formal. In your business writing, strive for the middle ground of polite, but conversational. Above all, however, always keep your audience in mind.

 

 

Improving Your Writing46

Sexist Language

The sensitive and wise business writer should remember to use inclusive language. Doing so can be something of a problem in English, since not that long ago, writers referred to mankind instead of humankind, and the pronoun he served for both men and women. Study the following example.

Exclusive: When a worker completes his task, he should return tools to the tool crib.

Inclusive: When workers complete their tasks, they should return tools to the tool crib.

“THE ALTERCATION BETWEEN

HILDE AND LUPE ORIGINATED

PURSUANT TO THE DISSENSION.” “THE FIGHT BETWEEN HILDE

AND LUPE BEGAN AFTER

A QUARREL.”

FIGURE 17—If you speak or write in a pompous manner, your audience may lose interest because your information is so difficult to follow. If you want to communicate effectively, use conversational language that’s familiar to your audience.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 47

Simply changing the necessary nouns and pronouns to their plural forms eliminated the exclusiveness in the first sentence. When the people you’re addressing include both men and women, always use inclusive language to refer to members of the audience. In general, use gender-neutral pronouns and alternative constructions, as shown in the following examples.

Sexist: During our Friday meeting, each supervisor will have ten minutes to read his report.

Alternative: During our Friday meeting, supervisors will have ten minutes to read their reports. (plural pronoun and plural noun)

Alternative: During our Friday meeting, supervisors will have ten minutes to read reports. (plural noun and omitted pronoun)

Alternative: During our Friday meeting, each supervisor will have ten minutes to read a report. (an article in place of the pronoun)

Alternative: During our Friday meeting, each supervisor will have ten minutes to read his or her report. (a masculine and a feminine pronoun)

Although the final alternative is acceptable, it’s a bit awkward. Whenever possible, use the other alternatives.

You should also be sensitive about sexist job titles like mail- man, fireman, policeman, chairman, and salesman. Replace them with gender neutral terms like postal carrier, firefighter, police officer, committee chair, and salesperson.

Using Words Properly

Words convey specific meanings. In your writing, you must make sure to use words that say exactly what you mean. You learn how to write by actually sitting down and writing. In the same way, you learn how to use words correctly by being diligent in finding their precise meanings. Remember, busi- ness writing should be practical, efficient, and logical. To make your work as clear and as accurate as it can be, you must avoid using words incorrectly. On the contrary, you should strive to use the best word for each situation.

Inclusive language is that which doesn’t discriminate against an individual’s gen- der, race, age, and so on.

 

 

Improving Your Writing48

The following list includes words that are commonly misused. Study these words and then make it a practice to use your dictionary often. Even if you think you know the meaning of a word and how to use it correctly, look it up. Regular use of a dictionary is a good habit to form.

ability/capacity You may have the ability to perform well, but not the capacity to perform well hour after hour. Ability refers to competence; capacity refers to an amount of something, given a specified space or time. (She has the ability to become a professional pianist. He didn’t have the capacity to complete the marathon.)

advise/tell To advise someone is to counsel, caution, or warn; to tell is merely to relate information. You might advise someone to avoid Jake in the accounting department, while you might simply tell someone you’re going to play golf on Sunday. (She asked me to advise her on which car to buy. I like to listen to him tell stories about his travels.)

affect/effect To affect means to influence the outcome; an effect is the result of an influence of some sort. Affect is almost always a verb; effect is usually a noun. (Will the high price of raw materials affect the manufacturer’s profit? The high winds had a devastating effect on small structures like mobile homes.)

among/between Among suggests distribution to three or more; between limits distribution to two. (You must choose the winner from among three contestants. The prize for the contest must be shared between the two people with the highest scores.)

anticipate/expect To anticipate is to prepare for something in advance, even if you’re uncertain it will take place; to expect an event is to be assured that it will take place. (He anticipates my needs and is always there to help me. I expect my children to behave at other people’s homes.)

apparent/evident If something is apparent, it only seems to be; if something is evident, it almost assuredly is. (The afternoon weather is apparently going to be wet and rainy. His anger made it evident that he didn’t agree with her.)

 

 

Improving Your Writing 49

appreciate/understand To appreciate something is to recognize its value; to understand something is to know how it works. (The civil engineer appreciated the complexity of the structure because he understood what went into building it.)

assume/presume To assume something is to take it on, such as a mortgage or employment; to presume is to conclude without clear justification. (She will assume her new position at the bank on Monday. You must presume the innocence of suspects until they’re proven guilty.)

balance/remainder A balance is that which is currently available; a remainder is that which is left after subtraction. You may have a balance in your account regardless of whether or not you’ve recently withdrawn money. Your account remainder is what’s left after you’ve subtracted your last expenditure. (The balance in her savings account showed that she had saved enough to purchase a new sound system. The students who wanted to see the movie went to the gymnasium; the remainder stayed in their room to play games.)

bimonthly/semimonthly Bimonthly means every two months (six times a year); semimonthly means twice a month (24 times a year). (The magazine is published bimonthly [six times a year]. Elaine does her semimonthly grocery shopping on Saturday.)

conclude/decide To conclude is to reach a decision based on evidence; to decide is to consider any number of alter- natives before choosing one. (Based on your knowledge of a particular orchestra, you concluded that its concert will be worth attending. Now, you must decide among alternative ways of getting to the concert.)

continual/continuous Continual means ongoing or in rapid succession, such as the periodic chiming of a clock; continuous means uninterrupted, as in the sustained sound of a milling machine. (The country had a history of continual invasions by their neighbors to the north. The cheering from the crowd was continuous.)

cooperate/collaborate To cooperate means to work togeth- er, but it may also mean to comply or conform; to collabo- rate also means to work together, but usually on a project

 

 

Improving Your Writing50

that involves mental rather than physical effort. (She’s always willing to cooperate with the preparation of dinner. If you don’t cooperate [comply], we’ll have to change our plans. I plan to collaborate with Marie in writing a paper on the history of our university.)

deteriorate/degenerate If something deteriorates, it sinks to a lower quality; if something degenerates, it returns to an earlier or lower state of being. (The quality of service at this bank has deteriorated. Leaves that fall during the autumn gradually degenerate into mulch.)

encounter/experience To encounter is to meet, especially by chance; to experience is to have a direct observation of or participation in events. (Carol encountered Jake in the new downtown restaurant. I experienced a feeling of great pride as I watched my daughter graduate from college.)

essential/basic If something is essential, it’s necessary; if something is basic, it’s fundamental, that is, it serves as a starting point. (She was allowed to take only the bare essentials on her backpacking trip. Students must learn the basics of mathematics before they can expect to solve complex equations.)

fewer/less Fewer means not as many in number; less means a smaller amount of something. As a general rule, use fewer to refer to things you can count and less with things you can’t count. (Carla hit fewer home runs than Sharon. James had less paint than he thought he did.)

further/farther Farther has to do with physical distance; further has to do with nonphysical things. (We traveled farther that day than any other day of our trip. I must consider your request further before I make a decision.)

imply/infer To imply is to suggest something to someone indirectly; to infer is to form a conclusion based on facts or apparent evidence. (The speaker seemed to imply that jobs will be cut in the next quarter. As I read his memo, I inferred that he had already made his decision.)

learn/teach To learn is to gain knowledge; to teach is to educate, that is, to give information to someone so he or she may learn. (My latest challenge is to learn how to knit. She can teach even the most difficult student.)

 

 

Improving Your Writing 51

liable/likely Liable has to do with obligation and responsibility; likely has to do with probability. (You may be liable for damages if your car door damages another car in a parking lot. You’re likely to damage another car if you park improperly.)

maximum/optimum Maximum has to do with a limit; optimum has to do with the most desirable level of quality or performance. (The maximum speed limit may be 65 miles an hour, but the optimum performance of your new sports car permits a speed of 120 miles per hour.)

predicament/situation Predicament suggests an undesirable state; a situation can be any set of circumstances you find yourself in. (Our predicament was to find a way to get our car out of the snow bank. We were in the envious situation of having front seats for the performance.)

principle/principal A principle is a fundamental law or guideline; a principal is an authority figure, such as a school principal. As an adjective, the word principal means most important. (The business was based on sound accounting principles. The school principal decided to close the school two hours early. The principal speaker at the banquet was my brother’s high school football coach.)

reaction/opinion A reaction is a response to something definite; an opinion is an idea, a belief, or a conviction. (My immediate reaction was to ignore his embarrassing question. In my opinion, the play accurately depicted the assassination of President Lincoln.)

theory/idea A theory is a suggested explanation for some action, happening, or set of phenomena; an idea is a concept or thought. (I have a theory about why people have stopped buying our product, but I have no idea how to improve sales.)

use/utilize Both use and utilize mean to employ something. However, the word utilize also means to put into practical use. (I can use the money I received for my birthday to buy a new dress. The committee was unable to utilize the new software in their old computers.)

 

 

Improving Your Writing52

Practice Exercise 5 Rewrite the following sentences on a separate sheet of paper. Arrange the ideas in each sentence so that the idea you want to emphasize comes last. Completely rewrite the sentences if that’s what it takes to give them punch.

1. We found the little girl in the attic, sleeping peacefully, after we had searched for hours and had notified the police.

2. The tornado left ruin and death in its wake and tore down every building in the village.

3. The mysterious visitor had stolen the ruby, rifled my desk, and broken open the safe.

Check your answers with the suggestions on page 72. Do not send your practice writing to the school.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 53

Self-Check 3

1. All of the following sentences contain weaknesses in diction. Rewrite each sentence using the tools you learned in this section. For example, replace general terms with concrete ones and informal words with more appropriate formal ones.

a. The survey evaluated the attitudes of each guy in our department. __________________________________________________________

b. A lot of my buddies from our gang were sacked because of their lousy production records. __________________________________________________________

c. My boss was too cheap to fork over the dough for the new lab equipment. __________________________________________________________

d. A girl came by to check out the inventory records. __________________________________________________________

e. The new drill presses have done a great job. __________________________________________________________

2. Some of the sentences below include misused words. Carefully read each sentence. Cross out the errors and write the correct word above the mistakes. If all of the words are used correctly, write “Correct” in the space provided. If necessary, consult the list of misused words in this study unit.

______ a. The increased work load had surprisingly positive affects on the

employees’ morale.

______ b. The supervisor divided the project between Joe, Dave, and me.

______ c. Our company’s president and the president of Abbott Electronic collaborated on

the report for the merger committee.

______ d. From the description George gave at the meeting, we have decided that the new

computer software will make our jobs easier.

______ e. We found a way to utilize the equipment donated to our small business.

______ f. If you replace mica wafers with beryllium oxide wafers, you’re liable to get the

same results.

(Continued)

 

 

Improving Your Writing54

Self-Check 3 ______ g. In her speech at the department meeting, our supervisor inferred that if

production didn’t increase, a few workers may be dismissed.

______ h. Susan’s theory was that all thermal conductors work equally well when used in identical situations.

______ i. When Stan Crawford went on vacation, I assumed his role as assistant production coordinator.

______ j. The transistor degenerated when the thermal joint compound failed to conduct the heat rapidly to the heat sink.

3. Substitute the active for the passive voice to make the following sentences more forceful.

a. In my neighborhood, many new apartment houses are being built by developers. b. Our plans were changed abruptly when her message was received by us. c. After the soup was served, the turkey was served by them. d. Mistakes were made by several companies involved in building the bridge. e. The wrong medication was given to Mrs. Brown by her grandson, who was visiting.

4. In the spaces provided, indicate whether each of the following statements is True or False.

______ a. You can make your words build in power by writing your words in a

rhythmical pattern.

______ b. A dash—used wisely and sparingly—can add meaning and emphasis to

your writing.

______ c. An exclamation point will add punch to an otherwise boring sentence.

Check your answers with those on page 74.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 55

REVISING, EDITING, AND PROOFREADING

Revising Your Writing

The word revise means “see again.” To see again suggests more than cleaning up minor errors. To see again suggests a new way of looking at what you’ve done. Revision requires you to look at your work as if you were the target audience, seeing the document for the first time. You still shouldn’t be worried about little mistakes at this point. Your concern at this point is the big picture. Looking for little mistakes can bog you down and make it difficult to see bigger, more important problems in organization. Why spend time fiddling with little details that might end up getting cut or rewritten entirely? The best way is to get the whole piece of writing the way you want it, and then go through to fix mistakes line by line, word by word.

When you’re revising, these are the sorts of questions to ask yourself about the piece of writing as a whole:

• Is it clear in purpose and in meaning? If not, rethink your organization and your approach. You may need to start over with different ideas and a different outline.

• Are there parts that should be cut? Cross them out or delete them, if you’re working on the computer.

• Are there parts that should be developed further? Add parts by writing between the lines and in the margins.

• Are there parts that should be moved elsewhere? Move parts by cutting and pasting or, if you’re writing by hand, circling them and drawing arrows to wherever you wish to insert the words (Figure 18).

• Are there parts that should be condensed or combined with other parts within the document? Cross out those parts and rewrite between the lines and in the margins. Then rewrite the corrected copy (Figure 19).

 

 

Improving Your Writing56

FIGURE 18—Sample Revision

When I think of cars, I inevitably think of my first flat tire. It happened the same day I got my first car—and it was raining. Luckily, I knew how to change tires. Nobody stopped to help me. I was late to pick up my friend for a joy ride in my new car, and I was wet, muddy, and miser- able. It seemed only fitting when my hubcap fell off on the way home.

FIGURE 19—Corrected Copy of Sample Revision

 

 

Improving Your Writing 57

Use the symbols in Figure 20, called proofreaders’ marks, to indicate corrections in your work. You’ll find that they help you to streamline the process. Using these symbols will be easier and clearer than writing out directions to yourself.

FIGURE 20—Frequently Used Proofreaders’ Marks

 

 

Improving Your Writing58

Editing Your Work Once you have your major changes in place, it’s time to put to use what you’ve learned about grammar, sentence structure, word usage, punctuation, and spelling (Figure 21). Strive for a clear, concise style. To help you with your editing, here are some tips, many of which will sound familiar to you:

• Vary sentence lengths. Mix it up. Don’t have all short, choppy sentences, but don’t have all long ones, either. Strive for sentence lengths of 10–20 words. A few sentences may be shorter, but seldom should one be much longer.

• Look for and delete unnecessary words. Try to concentrate wordy ideas into a single word. Make shapeless sentences clear, and cut out any dead or repetitious words.

• Eliminate irrelevant information. Don’t tell your audience every little detail about a subject. Stick to what adds to the informa- tion or to your argument.

• Get rid of dry, stilted, or cliché-laden language. The technical term for worn- out expressions is cliché (Figure 22).

Practice Exercise 6 Using proofreaders’ marks, revise the first draft of your writing from Practice Exercise 4. If you’ve typed it on a computer, double space it and print it out, so you can view it as your readers will see it. Keep your outline handy, so you can make sure you haven’t drifted too far from your original intention or your pattern of organization. Mark changes with proofreaders’ marks and write in the changes between the lines or in the margins. If you need to make extensive revisions, you may want to type the new material into a separate file and copy and paste it into your document once you’re sure of the changes.

This exercise is for your own benefit. Do not send your writing to the school.

FIGURE 21—When you edit your work, check for choppy sentences, clichés, and negative messages, as well as grammar and punctua- tion errors.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 59

Like all languages, English has in it a body of expressions that are overused. Here are some expressions that are currently overused:

in a perfect world, interface, the big picture, leverage resources, be proactive, it’s a no-brainer, core competency, paradigm shift, value-added, push the envelope, cutting edge, all things considered, as a matter of fact, call on the carpet, circumstances beyond control, finishing touch, foregone conclusion, in the final analysis, in this day and age, it stands to reason, overall picture, point of no return, read between the lines, second to none, sell like hotcakes, behind the eight ball, face the music . . .

The following phrases were, at one time, used in everyday conversation. Constant repetition, however, has robbed them of the fresh imagery they once conveyed.

at the drop of a hat, break the ice, clean bill of health, close to the soil, come apart at the seams, handle with kid gloves, lead a dog’s life, mention in the same breath, raise one’s sights, rub the wrong way . . .

Some clichés, like the following, have been around for centuries.

bring home the bacon, speak of the devil, you can’t have your cake and eat it too, busy as a bee, thin as a rail, quiet as a mouse, white as a sheet, sharp as a tack, slippery as an eel, slow as molasses in January, bury the hatchet, split hairs, put your shoulder to the wheel, let the cat out of the bag, put the cart before the horse, cook one’s goose, kill two birds with one stone, bite off more than one can chew, get up on the wrong side of the bed . . .

And these:

down in the dumps, face the facts, lap of luxury, live and learn, point with pride, slow but sure, spic and span, sure as shooting, through thick and thin, by hook or by crook, fair and square, haste makes waste, high and dry, wear and tear, wine and dine, blow hot and cold, by means fair or foul, feast or famine, kill or cure, move heaven and earth, neither here nor there, open and shut, rain or shine, sink or swim, the long and short of it . . .

The list goes on:

bag and baggage, fits and starts, hale and hearty, house and home, kith and kin, lord and master, part and parcel, pure and simple, toss and turn, well and good, boon to mankind, bow in defeat, brave the elements, by the same token, deem it a privilege, explore every avenue, irony of fate, paragon of virtue, picture of health . . .

How much better and more persuasive it sounds to say “It is my privilege to work with all of you in this department” than to say “I deem it a privilege to work with all of you.”

Should clichés ever be used? The answer is yes, when they’re employed consciously, effectively, and with purpose. Consider the person who offered a violin for sale “with no strings attached” and the writer who described amateur parachutists as “jumping for joy.” Both were using clichés consciously, and they achieved delightful, original expressions. It’s reliance upon clichés—not the clichés themselves—that rubs the wrong way.

FIGURE 22—Clichés can weaken your writing. Try to invent your own ways of saying what you want to say.

 

 

Improving Your Writing60

• Substitute specific strong verbs for weak or overused ones. Remember to use active voice, rather than passive, for a clear, direct style.

• Replace generalities with specifics. It’s better to mention that 200 samples were distributed during a convention than to say that a “substantial number” were given out.

Making comparisons is an effective way to replace generalities with specifics. Comparisons put the information into a recog- nizable and understandable context (Figure 23).

General: That building is huge and ornate.

Specific comparison: That building looks like a castle.

• When possible, change negative messages to positive. Rather than saying “We can’t meet until this project is finished in three weeks,” say “We can meet anytime after this project finishes in three weeks.” The positive approach shows that you really do want to meet with the person.

• Use lists judiciously to break up copy and to make read- ing quick and easy. Remember to keep the list entries paral- lel in grammatical structure.

• Check and correct the grammar. Be especially alert to subject/pronoun agreement, subject/verb agreement, and proper pronoun form.

FIGURE 23—Watch for generalities that could be made more effective with specific information or a comparison to something familiar to the reader.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 61

Proofreading the Final Draft

Theyr’e not spellnig errrors; they’r ejust typls.

How did you react to the previous sentence? The mistakes are typographical errors. The sentence should read

They’re not spelling errors; they’re just typos.

Typographical and spelling errors interfere with the clarity of ideas. They cast doubt on the accuracy of the entire docu- ment. If the attention to little details is careless, the reader wonders, might not the big details be carelessly handled, too?

Everybody makes mistakes. Even the best typists make typos, even the best spellers misspell, even the best English teachers confuse who and whom, and even the best writers sometimes find that they’ve quickly scribbled their for they’re, or to for too. Most of the mistakes that make it into final documents don’t result from stupidity or even carelessness, though care- less mistakes do happen too often. Most mistakes are simply overlooked because of our inability to see what’s really on the page. Instead, we see what we thought we put there.

Familiarity with material makes it difficult to pick out errors that practically leap off the page to someone else.

Practice Exercise 7 Edit your revised draft from Practice Exercise 6. Print out your revision (double spaced) and, using standard proofreaders’ marks, correct any errors in spelling, punctuation, and grammar. Also delete unnecessary words, irrelevant information, sexist language or ineffective expressions, such as clichés. While you shouldn’t need extensive revisions at this stage, if you notice that you’ve drifted from your topic or that your points aren’t in logical order, make the changes now. This should give you a clean draft that reflects what you’ve learned in this study unit.

This exercise is for your own benefit. Do not send your edited draft to the school.

 

 

Improving Your Writing62

How can you avoid making simple proofreading mistakes that make you look careless when really you’re a perfectionist? Well, you won’t be able to catch all the mistakes, but you’ll come close if you apply all the skills you’ve acquired and you understand why the majority of mistakes occur. Here are some suggestions:

• Be consistent in the way that you handle paragraph indentation. Either indent the first sentence of each paragraph or, if you don’t indent the first sentence, skip a line between each paragraph.

• Check for correct punctuation, including capitalization.

• Watch for grammatical errors. Keep an alert eye out for errors such as fragments, run-ons, faulty agreement, and incorrect comparisons.

• Make sure you haven’t mistaken commonly confused pairs of words, such as there, their, and they’re.

• Read backwards (from the end to the beginning of the document) to concentrate on small details of usage. If you tend to read fast, you might also cover the page with a plain-colored bookmark or piece of paper to slow yourself down and keep your eyes focused on one line of text at a time.

• Be on the lookout for mistakes that may happen when you rewrite or type a new copy of a revision. These mis- takes include repeated words, sentences, or lines; and skipped lines, sentences, or paragraphs.

• Learn to spell the words you use. Learn the spelling rules and the exceptions to those rules.

• Become familiar with the look of words in print. The next time you’re tempted to turn on the TV, pick up a book instead. Or, write a letter to a friend. While you’re reading or writing, keep a dictionary at your side and look up unfamiliar words. In fact, look up familiar words, too, if they’re the least bit tricky. You can make mistakes by assuming you know something and not checking to make sure you’re right.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 63

• Say the word aloud when you look it up in a dictionary. See the word. Copy the word correctly. Try to spell it with your eyes closed.

• Spell by syllables. Make sure that you pronounce the word correctly and that you hear all the syllables. Many people spell words wrong because they pronounce them wrong. Probably, for instance, is commonly misspelled as probly. Take the time to look at what you’ve written and pronounce it correctly.

• Pay special attention to words that aren’t spelled the way they’re pronounced. Many people misspell words containing silent letters (debt, sign, exhaust, knife, night, pneumonia). Others have trouble with two-letter combinations that sound like one letter (phone, rough, school).

• Watch for homonyms, words that sound alike but have different meanings. Two/too/to, there/their/they’re, your/you’re, hear/here, no/know, and weather/whether are just a few examples.

• Keep a list of words you’ve misspelled and looked up. Use your list as a reference when you write, edit, and proofread your work.

When typing, people tend to make the same sorts of mistakes. If you type your work on a typewriter or word processor, study it and see if you notice any patterns in your spelling typing errors. Pay attention to the details shown in Figure 24. It may be helpful to add frequently misspelled or mistyped words into your word processing program’s dictionary or autocorrect feature.

COMMON TYPOS

Common Mistake Typing Error

Dropped letters Ther car is red. Added letters Theirr car is red. Transposed letters Thier car is red. Wrong letters Rheir car is red. Substituted letters Yjrot vst od trf/ Spacing errors Thei rcar is red. Wrong word There car is red.

Corrected sentence: Their car is red.

FIGURE 24—Common Typos

 

 

Improving Your Writing64

Presenting Your Work

The final stage of the writing process is presenting—giving the final copy to the intended audience (Figure 25). Professional writers, and some classroom teachers, call this stage publishing. We’re calling it pre- senting.

Every time you pick up a magazine, newspaper, print advertisement, flyer, brochure, report, or anything else in print, you’re reading what some other writer has presented.

You present your writing when you send notes and letters to friends and relatives. In your working life, you’re likely to present writing in various forms, from resumes to business letters to reports on projects.

Once you’ve reached the presenting stage, most of the hard work has already taken place. Now, before sending your work out into the world, make sure it’s as polished as you can make it. Carefully proofread it. Be sure that it’s formatted according to the conventions of the medium you’re using, and that it’s presented as cleanly and neatly as possible.

FIGURE 25—The final step in a writing project is presenting it for someone to read.

Practice Exercise 8 After letting your clean, edited draft “rest” for a day or two, carefully proofread your work. Read it backwards. Double-check all the details you checked when editing, and watch for additional typos, repeated words, and inconsistencies in style. When you’re sure you’ve made it as perfect as it can be, print out your final draft. Now you’ve learned to make your writing ready for presentation.

This exercise is for your own benefit. Do not send your final draft to the school.

 

 

Improving Your Writing 65

Self-Check 4 Questions 1–5: Answer the following questions.

1. List the stages of the writing process as discussed in this study unit. __________________________________________________________

2. During the first stage of the writing process, you must define your _______, _______, and _______.

3. Name and briefly describe five prewriting activities that can help you decide what to write about. __________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________

4. What is the difference between outlining and webbing? __________________________________________________________

5. What does revision mean? How is revising different from editing? __________________________________________________________

Questions 6–12: Read each sentence and draw a line through the cliché. Write a fresh phrase in place of each cliché.

6. I thought that Robertson had won the game fair and square. ______________________

7. This medicine will either kill you or cure you. __________________________________

8. Shirley believes in this policy heart and soul. __________________________________

9. I’ve been leading a dog’s life since Mona went to Cincinnati. ______________________

10. Benton decided to surrender and face the music. ________________________________

11. I know where you’re coming from, Alan, but we still have to work within company policy. __________________________________________________________________

12. If we aren’t careful, this contract is going to come apart at the seams. ______________

Check your answers with those on page 75.

 

 

Improving Your Writing66

NOTES

 

 

PRACTICE EXERCISES

Practice Exercise 1 1. War slogans

A. Remember the Maine

B. Remember Pearl Harbor

C. Make the world safe for democracy

2. American foreign policy

A. Monroe Doctrine

B. Open Door Policy

C. Truman Doctrine

3. Causes of poor health

A. Dirty living conditions

B. Absence of medical care

C. Poor diet

4. Evils of college sports

A. Overemphasis on athletics

B. Too much emphasis on winning

C. Failure to provide for the poor or average athlete

5. Steps in writing

A. Gathering ideas

B. Making a plan

C. Writing the first draft

6. How I got the job

A. Studying the help-wanted ads

B. Sending a letter of application

C. Interviewing

67

A n s w e r s

A n s w e r s

 

 

7. I. Game birds

A. Ducks

B. Quail

C. Pheasants

II. Birds of prey

A. Eagles

B. Owls

C. Hawks

8. I. Winter sports

A. Ice skating

B. Skiing

II. Summer sports

A. Swimming

B. Baseball

C. Tennis

9. I. Baseball

A. Batting

B. Fielding

C. Pitching

II. Basketball

A. Foul shooting

B. Set shooting

C. Floor play

D. Guarding

10. I. Reasons for popularity

A. Consideration for others

B. Pleasing personality

C. Sense of humor

D. Skill in conversation

E. Attractive appearance

II. Reasons for unpopularity

A. Sarcastic talk

B. Selfishness

Answers68

 

 

Practice Exercise 2 Your formal outline should

• Begin with an introduction to your topic

• Follow your pattern of organization

• List at least two major topics

• Include at least two subtopics within each major topic

• List two or more details for each subtopic

• Add specific facts as necessary

• Follow a logical order

• Fully develop your topic

• End with a summary or conclusion

Practice Exercise 3 1. This letter should be formal, with extra care given

to ensure there are no errors. Also, it should use persuasive language and facts, where possible, to make a strong argument.

2. E-mail to friends may be very informal and casual; the writing generally reflects the way a person speaks. However, errors should be corrected before the message is sent.

3. Research papers are written in formal language. Your introductory paragraph should establish your purpose and put it into context. It should also include the major topics you’ll be discussing in the order in which they’ll appear in the paper.

Answers 69

 

 

4. Letter requesting a speaker

This letter is too informal, uses clichés and jargon, and doesn’t include sufficient details for the request. Your revision might look something like this:

Dear Mr. Jeffers:

Our small medical laboratory is planning a spring work- shop to train our interns in the use of some new, updated laboratory equipment we have ordered. Since you have been recommended as both an excellent instructor and an expert technician, we would very much like to have you supervise the training.

The workshop will be held on May 23 at Mayfield Diagnostics, Inc., located at 168 Front Street in Mayfield. We’ll need two, two-hour sessions, which can be scheduled for morning or afternoon, at your convenience. If you are able to participate, I will inform you of the exact models of the equipment we’ll be using. Please let me know the details of your fees and any set-up materials you’ll need for your presentation.

We would appreciate your response by April 1. We look forward to hearing from you.

Yours truly,

Simon Smith

Simon Smith Administrative Assistant

Answers70

 

 

5. Memo inviting employees to company picnic

This memo is clearly much too formal for the occasion or the audience, and is also pompous and condescending. Your memo might look something like this:

** Splendid Products, Inc. **

Memo

To: All Employees

From: Harrison Splendid, CEO

Date: June 10, 2006

Re: Company Picnic

In appreciation of your reliable effort and excellent productivity, our company will celebrate another successful year with a picnic at Church Street Park in West Orange on July 21 at 11 AM. Lunch will begin at 11:30 and there will be games and entertainment all afternoon. Please plan to join us. Dress comfortably.

Practice Exercise 4 Check your draft against your outline to make sure you followed your original intention and pattern of organization. If you’ve made changes in your major topics or their order, make sure you adjust the outline to accommodate the changes. If there are any gaps in information or logical sequence, make a note of what’s missing.

Answers 71

 

 

Practice Exercise 5 Your sentences may differ from these suggestions:

1. After we had searched for hours and had notified the police, we found the little girl in the attic, sleeping peacefully.

2. The tornado tore down every building in the village, leaving in its wake ruin and death.

3. The mysterious visitor had rifled my desk, broken open the safe, and stolen the ruby.

Practice Exercises 6–8 After you complete each step in revising, editing, and proofreading your work, review the relevant material in the study unit to be sure you’ve made the corrections according to what you’ve learned.

Answers72

 

 

SELF-CHECKS

Self-Check 1 1. a. brainstorming, webbing, freewriting, researching, and

journal keeping.

b.purpose, medium, and audience.

c. one good idea that excites you.

2. researching

3. a. Cause and effect

b. Comparison/contrast

c. Chronological order

d. Spatial order

e. Cause and effect

f. Classification/division

4. The main advantage of sentence outlines is that they provide the topic sentences for your main paragraphs. The main advantages of topic outlines are that they’re easier to prepare, they become the basis for your table of contents, and they supply the internal headings for your document.

Self-Check 2 1. notice errors

2. formal

3. style sheet

4. first draft

5. Digressions

6. outline

7. informal

8. purpose

9. double-space

10. audience

Answers 73

 

 

Self-Check 3 1. Note: These are just sample answers. Your responses

will be different from those given here.

a. The employee morale survey administered on November 16 evaluated the job satisfaction of each member of our department. (Note: Be careful not to replace guy with man, since women probably also work in the department.)

b. Seven of my fellow production workers were dismissed because their unexcused absenteeism resulted in a 38 percent decline in production.

c. My production supervisor refused to appropriate funds for the new lab equipment.

d. An inventory control specialist from the central office in Madison was sent to evaluate our inventory records.

e. The 124T Addison drill presses installed in March of 2001 have increased production 82 percent, decreased downtime 90 percent, and initiated an overall expansion of the production division.

2. a. The increased workload had surprisingly positive effects on the employee morale.

b. The supervisor divided the project among Joe, Dave, and me.

c. Correct

d. From the description George gave at the meeting, we have concluded that the new computer software will make our jobs easier.

e. Correct

f. If you replace mica wafers with beryllium oxide wafers, you’re likely to get the same results.

g. In her speech at the department meeting, our super- visor implied that if production didn’t increase, a few workers may be dismissed.

h. Correct

i. Correct

Answers74

 

 

j. The transistor deteriorated when the thermal joint compound failed to conduct the heat rapidly to the heat sink.

3. a. In my neighborhood, developers are building many new apartment houses.

b. We changed our plans abruptly when we received her message.

c. After serving the soup, they served the turkey.

d. Several companies involved in building the bridge made mistakes.

e. Mrs. Brown’s grandson, who was visiting, gave her the wrong medication.

4. a. True

b. True

c. False

Self-Check 4 1. Prewriting, Planning, Writing the First Draft, Revising

and Editing, Proofreading, Presenting

2. purpose, medium, audience

3. Brainstorming: Make a list of any ideas that come to mind about your general topic.

Clustering/webbing: This is a branching exercise. In the middle of a piece of paper, write your topic and circle it. Write and circle other ideas as they come to mind, connecting them with lines.

Freewriting: Without stopping, write sentence after sentence about your topic—whatever comes to mind.

Researching: Collect information from outside sources.

Journal keeping: Write in a journal every day, and turn to it when you’re looking for topic ideas.

Answers 75

 

 

4. A formal outline is strictly organized and follows a set format:

I.

A.

1.

2.

B.

1.

2.

Webbing is a branching activity that shows the relationship between ideas. The format is more flexible than outlining.

5. To revise is “to see again.” You read as if you were seeing the work for the first time and make changes to the over- all organization of the piece. To edit is to make changes sentence by sentence and word by word to improve the flow of language and correct errors.

6. fair and square—honorably (or without cheating)

7. kill you or cure you—This medicine should cure you, but it may have negative side effects.

8. heart and soul—completely; utterly

9. leading a dog’s life—I’ve been lonely

10. face the music—accept the consequences.

11. I know where you’re coming from—I understand your concerns

12. come apart at the seams—this contract isn’t going to satisfy the client (or stand up in court)

Answers76

 

 

77

GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS Read and complete the requirements for this examination only after

you’ve completed the previous study units.

1. Refer to your previous study units, the practice exercises, the Writing Process Review, and the self-checks as you write your exam paragraphs.

2. Refer to the Evaluation Criteria to ensure your exam paragraphs meet the criteria to the best of your ability.

3. Include the following information at the top of each page.

Name Student Number (eight digits) Exam number Page X

Mailing Address

Email Address

Example:

Jane Smith 12345678 02800502 Page 1

111 Education Drive, Any Town, PA 18515

jlsmith@pfpfpf.com

To insert a header on each page that includes page numbers,

a. Double-click in the top margin of your Word document; this will open the Insert tool bar and Header and Footer tools.

b. Click on the Page Number button. Choose the Plain Number 1 option to insert the page number at the top left corner of your page.

E x a m in a tio

n E x a m in a tio

n Improving Your Writing

EXAMINATION NUMBER

02800502 Whichever method you use in submitting your exam

answers to the school, you must use the number above.

 

 

Examination78

c. Place your cursor in front of the number to type your name and other identifying information as you see it in your study guide. Do not change the page number; it will adjust auto- matically to each new page of your document. Note: You can type and format text in the header as you would in the body of your paper.

d. When you’re finished, click the Close Header and Footer button or double-click in the body of your document.

Note: If you don’t include this information at the top of each

page, you’ll lose points in the format section. If you fail to

include your name and student number, your exam may not be

processed for grading.

4. Double-space your work and use Times New Roman font, size 12. After preparing a rough draft, read the evaluation criteria and revise your work carefully, correcting any errors you find. Make sure to spell-check and grammar-check your work, too. Submit only your final drafts. Do not include your prewriting, drafting, or revising work.

5. Save your document as a Rich Text Format (RTF) file using your name, student number, and exam number (Example: Jane Doe 12345678 028005).

6. Submit your examination in one of these two ways:

• Submit the exam online. To do so, go to your My Courses page and click on the Take Exam button for Exam 028005. On the next page, click Browse and locate your saved file on your com- puter, then upload.

• Mail the exam in the envelope provided or your own business-size envelope. From your computer, type or print the exam on 8½-by- 11-inch white paper. Send your exam to the following address:

Penn Foster Student Service Center

925 Oak Street Scranton, PA 18515

 

 

Examination 79

ASSIGNMENT

Purpose You demonstrate that you’re able to work through all stages of the writ-

ing process to produce persuasive writing. To accomplish this assign-

ment, you apply skills and rules taught in the first five study units.

Background Ten years ago, you started working as a clerk for DMD Medical Supplies.

Six months ago, Liz Jakowski, the human resources director, promoted

you to office manager. You manage two employees: Jack Snyder and

Ruth Disselkoen. Your office provides secretarial support for the four

members of the executive team. Two years ago, Liz had assigned Jack to

support Ralph Alane and Jessica Hilo. Ruth was assigned to Samuel

Daley and Frank Daley. The work flow was equally balanced.

You’ve noticed that in the last three months Ruth has cut her breaks

short to complete her work, complains of being tired, and at least twice

a month requires overtime hours costing the company an additional

$200 a month. In the last three weeks, Frank Daley has complained to

you a few times about the poor quality of Ruth’s work.

On the other hand, over the last three months, Jack frequently seems to

have little to do. He has begun coming in late a

couple times a week and taking more than the allotted break times.

What work he does have, however, is always professionally completed.

Clearly, you must investigate to determine what is causing this change

and how to improve the situation. Since nothing has changed in the per-

sonal lives of either Jack or Ruth, you conclude you must focus on the

in-office work situation. You learn the following facts:

• Samuel and Frank Daley share a part-time administrative assis-

tant who works only 15 hours a week.

• Ralph Alane and Jessica Hilo share a full-time administrative

assistant.

• Jessica Hilo has been on medical leave for the last four months,

and Liz Jakowski isn’t sure whether Jessica will be able to return

to work.

 

 

Examination80

• Jessica’s duties have been temporarily reassigned to Ralph and

Frank.

Although you don’t have the authority to change who Jack and Ruth are

assigned to work for, you clearly need to change the work the two do so

that both Jack and Ruth work regularly without requiring overtime.

Process Adhere to the following outlined process when writing your exam.

Planning

1. The background explains the primary cause of the workflow prob-

lem and the negative effects resulting from it. Your task is to make

up a realistic plan which solves the uneven productivity between

Jack and Ruth. Use prewriting tools like brainstorming, cluster or

webbing diagrams, and freewriting to outline the cause-effect situa-

tion and to develop a specific solution that best solves the problem.

Also ask yourself the following questions to expand your prewriting.

• How long has this situation been going on?

• Why did the problems begin when they did?

• Am I able to solve the problem at its root cause or am I only

able to manage the impact of the problem?

• Is this a temporary or permanent problem?

• How has the company been affected?

• How have the employees been affected?

• What’s in my power to change? What must stay the same?

• What are two or three ways to improve the efficiency of my

office?

• How much work, time, and money would be required to imple-

ment each solution?

• Does each solution stop all the negative effects?

• Are there any benefits to the change beyond stopping what is

occurring?

 

 

Examination 81

• How exactly would each change affect Jack, Ruth, and the exec-

utive team?

• What would I have to do to make sure each change goes

through as planned and to monitor the situation once the solu-

tion is in place?

2. From your prewriting, develop the single best solution to the situa-

tion described in the background. Obviously, you won’t be able to

use everything you’ve prewritten, so your first step is to choose

what’s most important for the purpose and audience. As you out-

line a solution, you may need to make up more specific details that

define the steps of the plan and describe particular benefits of the

plan.

Drafting

3. Next, sort your details and information about the problem and the

plan into one of the two sections given below. Don’t worry about

complete sentences for this sorting stage; merely list the informa-

tion under the appropriate section. Use information from both the

background and your prewriting.

Section 1

• Facts and figures that define the problem (the cause)

• Details that show the impact of the problem (effects) on Jack,

Ruth, and the company

Section 2

• The steps needed to change the situation

• Reason to implement each step, including the benefits to your

employees, your supervisor, and the company

• Information about your role in the change

4. After sorting the information, draft a first-try, rough paragraph for

Section 1 and another paragraph for Section 2. Your goal is to

place the listed information in the most logical order using sentence

and paragraph format. Leave all spelling, grammar, punctuation,

and other mistakes exactly as they are. Don’t do any editing as you

write this first draft. The worse it looks at this stage, the better

your final product will appear in contrast.

 

 

Examination82

5. Set your rough draft aside and don’t work any further on this

assignment for at least 24 hours.

6. After your break, reread the background information and the ques-

tions guiding your prewriting in Step 1. Then reread the rough

paragraphs you drafted for Section 1 and 2 to refresh your memo-

ry. If you came up with new ideas since you wrote the draft, add

your thoughts before you go further.

Revising

7. Focus on the rough draft of Section 2, which you wrote in Step 4.

Divide the paragraph into two main ideas and reorganize your

information accordingly to develop two separate paragraphs based

on Section 2. The paragraphs must first describe your solution and

then persuade your supervisor to implement that solution. Each

paragraph must have one main idea related to this purpose and

audience.

Note: Don’t revise Section 1. Revise only the rough draft you wrote

for Section 2, expanding the single paragraph into two paragraphs.

8. Prewrite further if needed to develop more details and explanation

to flesh out the two paragraphs based on Section 2. Next, apply

the drafting and revising strategies taught in this and previous

study units to produce two properly developed paragraphs.

Together these two paragraphs must total between 200 to 300

words.

9. Once again, set your work aside for at least 24 hours.

10. Read the evaluation criteria given on the next page, which will be

used to score your work. Continue to revise, edit, and proofread

the two paragraphs from Section 2 to meet each of the criteria.

11. Once you have a final, polished version of the two paragraphs

based on Section 2, open a new document on your computer’s

word-processing program and type your work. Format the docu-

ment to double space, using a standard font, size 12, left justifica-

tion (also called align left and ragged right). Set 1-inch or

1.25-inch margins for both left and right sides of the page. Indent

the first line of each paragraph by 0.5-inch tab. Hit Enter only once

after the first paragraph to begin the second paragraph. Don’t use

any other type of format, such as a letter or memo. Merely type

the two paragraphs.

 

 

Examination 83

12. After typing your work, make sure you edit and proofread at least

one more time. Use the computer’s grammar and spell checks cau-

tiously. Not everything the computer suggests is correct, particular-

ly for the purpose and audience.

EVALUATION CRITERIA The school will use the following criteria to evaluate your two para-

graphs. Be sure you’ve revised and edited your work after reviewing

these guidelines.

• Ideas and content (development and unity) (20 points)

You’ve thoughtfully divided the Section 2 information into two bal-

anced paragraphs. In each paragraph, you present one clear main

idea. Each of the two main ideas directly relates to the assigned

purpose and audience: persuading Liz Jakowski to implement your

solution. You effectively combine applicable information from the

Background with insightful details of your own to develop a step-

by-step plan. Those details are knitted together with reasonable

explanation that includes the benefits from implementing your plan.

(20 points)

• Organization (coherence and paragraph structure) (20 points)

You develop the main idea of each paragraph in a logical direction.

The first paragraph flows naturally into the second paragraph with-

out blurring the two main ideas. Your details fit naturally where

placed. You effectively use connective wording to weave informa-

tion and explanation into a cohesive whole.

• Voice (10 points)

Each paragraph maintains a single point of view using appropriate

pronouns and verbs in active voice. In an informal business fash-

ion, you connect with your supervisor. Your tone and voice give an

engaging flavor to the message; they are appropriate for both the

audience and purpose.

• Word choice (15 points)

Each word works smoothly with the other words to convey the

intended message in a precise, appealing, and original way. The

words you choose are specific, accurate, and energetic. You don’t

use slang, clichés, or jargon.

 

 

Examination84

• Sentence fluency (15 points)

Your sentences are well built, with varied length, type, and struc- ture to give each paragraph a sense of controlled yet graceful movement. When read aloud, the two paragraphs have a natural, pleasant rhythm.

• Conventions (20 points)

You demonstrate a skillful grasp of the standard writing conventions

for American English, using correct grammar, usage, punctuation,

capitalization, and spelling. Your choices guide the reader through

the text with ease.

• The two paragraphs together total 200 to 300 words. (20 points)

• Follow the submission guidelines in the general instruc- tions to format and upload your exam for grading.

Compare and contrast the below essays Jensen, “Forget Shorter Showers,” p. 564 and McKibben, “Waste Not, Want Not,” p. 557

Compare and contrast

Topic: Compare and contrast the below essays

Jensen, “Forget Shorter Showers,” p. 564 and McKibben, “Waste Not, Want Not,” p. 557

 

This essay is a comparison and contrast assignment that will compare two essays on a similar theme. Essays to analyze must be chosen from the list below. Your essay will let your reader (the class in this case) see the points that both essays are trying to make and your perspective on the topic.

 

Writing Tips

Look at how the authors present this topic. Does it add to your understanding or make you think of something related to the topic? Remember your essay must have a reader and a purpose in mind. In planning this essay, you must answer these questions:

  • Why is this matter of interest to the individual to whom you are writing?
  • What is your position on this topic?
  • What are the key points you will use in developing your topic?
  • What examples can you use from each text to develop your analysis? (Hint: you will have already done this in Discussion 9.)

Use these answers in writing your essay. Your essay will compare and contrast the two essays according to whatever criteria you set. Focus your essay on your purpose and provide examples and details from both essays in developing your points.

Upload the assignment to the Essay 3 Dropbox.

Grading

The minimum length for this assignment is 750 words. This does not include the revision write-up.

Essay 3 Grading Criteria

Criteria Level 5 Level 4 Level 3 Level 2 Level 1
Introduction and Thesis (15 points) Introduction is creative and gets the reader’s attention.

The purpose is clearly stated.

The thesis declares the author’s stance on a debatable point.

The purpose is clear.

The thesis declares the author’s stance on a debatable point.

Thesis declares the author’s stance on a debatable point but the overall purpose of the essay is not clear The thesis is not clear or the author needs to take a stance. Does not meet the assignment requirements.
Criteria

(15 points)

The criteria for comparison are clearly stated. The criteria for comparison are given. The criteria for comparison need to be more specific. The criteria for comparison are unclear. There are no apparent criteria for comparison.
Development (30 points) Argument is well-developed, using specific examples from the essays to illustrate key points. Argument is well-developed, but does not provide detailed examples from the essays to support. The comparison is not clearly developed. Development is uneven; does not follow the pattern established in the introduction. Assertions are made without adequate development or support.
Textual Analysis

(20 points)

Usage of material from essays is clear and well developed.

Presented and developed in essay.

Quotations and paraphrases of the text are cited.

Clear reference to the text.

Quotations and paraphrasing are cited.

Usage of material from essays is not always clear or given correctly. Needs more specific textual analysis, using material from essays. Makes assertions without examples. Analysis of essays, using examples is missing.
Conclusion (15 points) Summarizes the points made, restates ideas in the thesis, and mirrors the introduction. Provides a sense of closure.; Restates main idea in the thesis and provides a sense of closure. Provides a sense of closure, but makes no reference to the thesis. Not well developed. Thesis concept and stance not apparent. Conclusion is not apparent. Ends abruptly or Introduces a new topic.
Mechanics (15 points) Essay is almost error free of problems with word choice, spelling, punctuation, grammar, and sentence structure. Relatively free of errors. Minor problems with one or two elements of grammar. Two or more major errors such as sentence fragments, comma splices, or run-on sentences Too many errors interfere with the reader’s ability to understand the writer. Error rate will keep the reader from respecting the writer and his/her meaning.
Revision

(15 points)

Provides a detailed description of the process used for revision, including the areas of the essay worked on and sources of feedback used. Revision process reflects substantive changes to the content or focus of the essay. Provides a good description of the revision process, but does not provide much detail about the areas worked on or the sources of feedback used. Provides limited comments on the revision process. Does not reflect thoughtful analysis or response to feedback. Essay does not reflect substantive revisions or response to feedback. No revision statement included.

The Stranger By Albert Camus- Meursault’s Character Perspective Assignment.

Based on the following prompt craft a 4 to 5 page essay. Strictly adhering to the gulidlines. Use the following attachments intext and the book itself. Must be MLA format.

 

 

The Character(psychological) Perspective: Some literary critics call this the “psychological”

 

perspective because its purpose is to examine the internal motivations of literary characters.

 

When we hear actors say that they are searching for their character’s motivation, they are using

 

something like this perspective. As a form of criticism, this perspective deals with works of

 

literature as expressions of the personality, state of mind, feelings, and desires of the author or

 

of a character within the literary work. As readers, we investigate the psychology of a character

 

or an author to figure out the meaning of a text (although sometimes an examination of the

 

author’s psychology is considered biographical criticism, depending on your point of view).

Albert Camus’s Critical Reception: From Celebration to Controversy

Matthew H. Bowker

Much as Walt Whitman’s poetry captured the tumultuous spirit of democracy and change in mid-nineteenth-century America, Albert Camus’s ambitious work articulated the moral and intellectual crisis that tested mid-twentieth-century Europe. And like Whitman, Camus contained multitudes, for while his fiction plumbed the depths of ab- surdity, his philosophical essays and journalistic writings defended ethical action, meaningful dialogue, and a cosmopolitan ideal of jus- tice. In nearly all areas of his life and work, Camus met with both ac- claim and condemnation: While some praised his original literary voice, many protested his sentimental style, his inexact philosophiz- ing, and his unconventional political message. All of these forces have come to define contemporary critical debates about Albert Camus: his celebrity, his complexities, and the public controversies in which he found himself embroiled.

Absurdity is undoubtedly Camus’s central concept, and although the idea of “absurdity” may be traced back to Søren Kierkegaard, Friedrich Nietzsche, or even the Book of Ecclesiastes, Camus’s writ- ings were the first serious attempts to explore absurdity’s meaning in a systematic way. Camus’s early triad of works, The Stranger, The Myth of Sisyphus, and Caligula, all confronted absurdity, but not in the man- ner of Surrealists or dramatists of the absurd. As Martin Esslin pointed out in his landmark study of the latter: “If Camus argued that in our dis- illusioned age the world has ceased to make sense, he did so in the ele- gantly rationalistic and discursive style of an eighteenth-century mor- alist” (24). This stylistic choice alone may help to explain why Camus is remembered equally as a philosopher and a writer of literature, and why Camus’s plays are among the least celebrated aspects of his oeuvre.

In addition to The Stranger and The Myth of Sisyphus, Camus’s

82 Critical Insights

 

 

novel of occupation and resistance, The Plague, his essay on revolt and revolution, The Rebel, and his introspective novel about guilt, vanity, and vice, The Fall, spoke to shared experiences of struggle, loss, and meaninglessness set off by the terrors of the mid-twentieth century. In fact, Camus’s “actualité” (a French word meaning both relevance and current-ness) was very much a part of his early success. In 1945, Camus was considered “France’s leading public intellectual . . . the moral voice of his era” (Judt 88), partly for his fiction and philosophy, partly for his writing in the French Resistance journal Combat. In the 1940s and 1950s, the publication of a new book by Camus was a worldwide literary event (Brée 4). In 1952, the Jewish German philos- opher Hannah Arendt wrote that Camus was “undoubtedly, the best man now in France . . . head and shoulders above the other intellectu- als” (qtd. in Judt 87). In 1957, the Swedish Academy agreed, and, at the age of only forty-four, Camus was awarded the Nobel Prize in Literature.

Such victories, however, almost always were accompanied by con- troversy and critical setbacks. Particularly damaging to Camus’s repu- tation were his rejection of communist doctrine, his public rift with Jean-Paul Sartre, and his profoundly unpopular stance on Algerian in- dependence. Beside Camus’s “actualité,” therefore, we must place his “inactualité”: the degree to which he was out of step with the political movements and intellectual fashions of his time. Especially near the end of his life, critics from all sides “fell over one another to bury [Camus]” for his “philosophical naïveté” (qtd. in Judt 88), while his moralistic tone, once the source of his esteem, ultimately earned him mockery as a “secular saint” (qtd. in Todd 374). Jacques Laurent de- scribed Camus’s Nobel Prize as the crowning of “a finished oeuvre” (qtd. in Judt 87), while Lucien Rebatet wrote cruelly that “this prize which falls most often to septuagenarians is not at all premature in this case, because since his allegorical La Peste, Camus has been diag- nosed with an arteriosclerosis of style” (qtd. in Todd 373).

Further muddying Camus’s reputation was a persistent confusion of

Critical Reception 83

 

 

his work with that of famous existentialists, such as Jean-Paul Sartre. In response, Camus made several public comments, such as: “I am not an existentialist. Sartre and I . . . have even thought of publishing a short statement in which the undersigned declare that they have noth- ing in common with each other. . . . It’s a joke, actually. Sartre and I published all our books . . . before we had ever met. When we did get to know each other, it was to realize how much we differed” (Lyrical and Critical 345). In fact, one would not be wrong to consider The Myth of Sisyphus a direct attack upon existentialism. Sartre recognized this, be- ing among the first to insist that Camus belonged not in the tradition of existentialist philosophers but alongside moralists such as Michel de Montaigne, Blaise Pascal, Voltaire, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, and André Gide. In 1952, the weight of political events proved too much for Camus’s and Sartre’s fragile friendship, and the differences between the two men erupted into a bitter public quarrel.

Today, Camus’s books have been translated and read throughout the world. His novels are taught regularly in French and Francophone schools, where they have earned him the status of a modern master. Even in Germany, the nation whose intellectual and political culture Camus often denounced, no foreign writer of the postwar era “achieved a greater or more immediate popularity” than Camus (Ziolkowski 132). And Avi Sagi has noted that, in Israel, a country contending with extraordinary violence and conflict, Camus’s thought has “found paths to the hearts of young men and women thirsty for a human voice at once consoling and demanding” (3). Yet, Camus’s work remains relevant not because it is universally adored, but because it addresses, and sometimes raises, troubling ethical and political ques- tions. Indeed, the posthumous (1994) publication of Camus’s unfin- ished autobiographical novel, The First Man, reignited debates about Camus’s colonial and racial politics, in part because it coincided with a period of renewed Western political and military intervention in Mus- lim countries. Insofar as questions of occupation, colonialism, terror- ism, and cultural misunderstanding are at the forefront of contempo-

84 Critical Insights

 

 

rary consciousness, even half a century after his death, Camus seems to have something significant, and often controversial, to contribute to the discussion.

But to understand contemporary debates in context, we must begin with the earliest questions posed by Camus’s critics and readers. This chapter does not attempt to answer these questions definitively, but rather to trace the evolution of critical attention to Camus’s work across three domains: the meaning of absurdity in Camus’s early work; the reception of Camus’s political message in the second “cycle” of his career; and the controversy over Algerian independence that survived Camus’s tragic death in 1960.

The Meaning of Absurdity While many writers struggle in obscurity for decades or even entire

lifetimes, fame came quickly and abundantly to the young Camus upon the 1942 publication of The Stranger. When Jean-Paul Sartre, certainly among the world’s most respected intellectuals at the time, wrote a favorable review of the novel, Camus was welcomed into Eu- ropean literary and philosophical circles as something of a new hero.

Like much of Camus’s work, The Stranger seemed to captivate readers’ imaginations because it addressed questions both timely and eternal. In the wake of the violence and terror of World War II, Meursault’s absurd behavior evoked a familiar feeling of shell-shock, but it also recalled a more distant, Eastern quietism. Meursault’s clear estrangement from his society invited both lofty philosophical reflec- tion on the nature of humanity and political commentary about the ef- fects of modernity and alienation. Perhaps readers were equally curi- ous about Camus, himself: a young man educated in the French system, but a foreigner born and raised in the North African colony of Algeria. Camus’s unique voice was both youthful and weary of the trials of poverty, war, and suffering.

These complexities in Camus’s life and work, coupled with the im-

Critical Reception 85

 

 

mensely conflictual political events of Camus’s era, most notably the rise of the Nazi Party and the German occupation of France, seemed destined to produce in Camus what John Cruickshank called an “inevi- table attitude” of absurdity (6). Camus described his own writing as an effort to contend with the absurd experience of his generation, one that had seen “too many contradictory, irreconcilable things” (qtd. in Cruickshank 4). Germaine Brée understood Camus’s absurd art as a di- rect reflection of the cultural, intellectual, and moral crisis of the day, a crisis she boldly compared with the end of the Roman Empire. Brée therefore found Camus’s notion of absurdity to be representative of “a whole trend of twentieth-century European thought which grew out of a painful awareness of the impossibility of finding a rational justifica- tion for any system of moral values” (26).

Yet, in spite of its powerful moral and emotional resonance, many readers found Camus’s notion of absurdity to be unfortunately ambig- uous. John Cruickshank claimed that Camus’s theory of absurdity con- tained circular arguments, and that Camus’s “different meanings of the term ‘absurd’ involve three different kinds of relationship and are both confused and confusing” (63). In his authoritative biography, Olivier Todd agreed that Camus’s thought-process in The Myth of Sisyphus was most often “rapid, punchy, and fluid. [Camus] sought a certain lucidity without quite attaining it” (144).

Over the years, vastly different interpretations of Camus’s “absur- dity” have been offered, from Robert de Luppé’s claim that absurdity is “the meaninglessness of life,” indeed, the meaninglessness of “ev- erything” (5), to Jean Onimus’s explanation of absurdity as the condi- tion represented by the life of Christ, but only if “the final pages of the gospel are ripped out” (49). To be fair, Camus, himself, was not terribly clear about the scope and application of the concept. In the first essay of The Myth of Sisyphus alone, Camus described absurdity in an as- tounding variety of ways, including: “a feeling that deprives the mind of sleep” (6), an “odd state of soul in which the void becomes elo- quent” (12), “the confrontation between the human need and the un-

86 Critical Insights

 

 

reasonable silence of the world” (28), a “contradiction” (18), a “pas- sion” (22), a “revolt” (25), an “equation” (50), and a “wager” (52).

Thus, critics have often infused Camus’s vision of absurdity with their own. Sartre’s influential review, “An Explication of The Stranger,” praised Camus for having articulated the “facts” of absur- dity: that “the world is chaos,” that “tomorrow does not exist,” and that “man is not the world” (110, emphasis in original). This reading drew heavily upon Sartre’s own philosophy in which human consciousness is superfluous in a non-rational world. It also drew upon Sartre’s argu- ment that The Myth of Sisyphus was Camus’s “precise commentary upon [The Stranger]” (108). Sartre’s linking of the two texts together has likely guided more interpretations of Camus’s work than any other.

Roger Quilliot’s study, The Sea and Prisons, saw Meursault as sim- ple, indifferent, and even primal, yet “born to duplicity,” for “between that smile that he tries to express and the grimace that his tin plate flashes back to him, there is a kind of rift; already, a fall from inno- cence” (81-82). Quilliot saw in Meursault a moral complexity that is a source of much critical disagreement. For instance, Donald Lazere ar- gued that “Meursault is not in the least disturbed by his subjectivity . . . he is more an object than a subject” (154). In his description of Meursault as a “distorting mirror held up to us” (83), Quilliot’s charac- terization of Meursault may be equally appropriate to Clamence, the hero of The Fall, who so memorably struggles with duplicity and self- consciousness.

Although Sartre’s and Quilliot’s interpretations were influential, Camus was particularly upset by critics such as Wyndham Lewis, Pi- erre Lafue, and Aimé Patri, who saw Meursault as “‘a schizophrenic,’ or ‘a moron,’ or . . . an example of the mechanization and depersonal- ization of modern life” (Lyrical and Critical 336n). Such approaches to Meursault have remained common. For instance, Arthur Scherr has argued that Meursault had “low self-esteem” and “thwarted ambition” attributable to his unloving mother (150), while Colin Wilson recently described Meursault as “basically a brainless idiot” (qtd. in Scherr

Critical Reception 87

 

 

150). Camus replied to this sort of criticism in his Preface to the Amer- ican University Edition of The Stranger: “Meursault is not a piece of social wreckage, but a poor and naked man enamored of a sun that leaves no shadows. Far from being bereft of all feeling, he is animated by a passion that is deep because it is stubborn, a passion for the abso- lute and for truth” (Lyrical and Critical 336).

Most critics today understand Meursault’s absurdity, and the idea of absurdity in general, as the lack of correspondence between human culture and the natural world. John Cruickshank’s seminal work, Al- bert Camus and the Literature of Revolt, attempted to clarify Camus’s absurdity in just this way, as “something which arises from a confron- tation between the human desire for coherence, for understanding, and the irrationality, the opacity, of the world” (xiii). Cruickshank’s inter- pretation of absurdity as a kind of intellectual disappointment has in- fluenced many, if not most, subsequent critical readings of Camus.

Yet, debates about the meaning of absurdity were not, and are not, merely academic. At stake has been the question of absurdity’s conse- quence: To what type of action does absurdity lead? Thus, while the ambiguity of Camus’s idea of absurdity certainly impacted his critical reception, disagreements about the appropriate moral and political consequences of absurdity have played an even more significant role in shaping Camus’s legacy.

Resistance, Revolt, or Rebellion? No single argument in Camus’s life was more widely publicized

than the quarrel between Sartre and Camus that began with the 1952 publication of an unsparing critique of The Rebel in Sartre’s literary journal, Les Temps modernes. If, in our day, it is difficult to imagine great popular interest in a squabble between two philosophers, at the time it had something of a tabloid attraction, perhaps not entirely un- like the fever surrounding a scandalous Hollywood divorce.

The review, written by Sartre’s disciple, Francis Jeanson, accused

88 Critical Insights

 

 

Camus of being “separated from reality” and of having become “an un- repentant idealist” who had lost touch with history (qtd. in Aronson 143). Against these charges, Camus wrote a bitter reply defending his book and accusing Jeanson and Sartre of intentionally misreading it. Sartre then retorted by “publicly flay[ing] Camus in the most personal terms,” by “explain[ing] Camus’s anti-communism as an evasion of personal growth and a refusal to fully live in the changing and de- manding real world,” and by leveling charges that Camus’s response evinced “a racism of moral beauty” (qtd. in Aronson 148-149). “You rebelled against death,” Sartre wrote, “but in the industrial belts which surround cities, other men rebelled against social conditions that raise the mortality rates. When a child died, you blamed the absurdity of the world and the deaf and blind God that you created in order to be able to spit in his face. But the child’s father, if he was unemployed or an un- skilled laborer, blamed men. He knew very well that the absurdity of our condition is not the same in Passy as in Billancourt” (qtd. in Aronson 153).

Here, it is possible to see how a disagreement about the scope and meaning of absurdity informed a much more heated debate about the appropriateness of moral and political action. In The Rebel, Camus had attacked the practice of historical revolution and the justifications of violence offered by revolutionary thought, while Sartre and his com- panions, especially those in the Communist Party, championed “the revolutionary . . . [who] is actively concerned to change the world of which he disapproves” (Cruickshank 103), even if that change de- manded violence. Sartre and the Communists held great influence over progressive opinion in France at the time, and their advocacy of violent means to achieve a communist end was, at least momentarily, the or- thodoxy of the radical Left. Thus, Camus’s refusal of this position, which concerned first the legitimacy of communist revolution, and later, the proper course of action in Algeria, was shocking to his con- temporaries, and has since become one of the most significant topics of critical attention to Camus’s work.

Critical Reception 89

 

 

Camus’s hesitancy to endorse revolutionary violence was at times attributed to a secret conservatism on Camus’s part, at times to a loss of nerve. Camus’s second novel, The Plague, had drawn criticism along the same lines because its explicit subject was a natural occurrence, a disease, rather than a war or military occupation. Conservative voices praised the book, while many of Camus’s allies were confused if not dismayed by its message (Zaretsky 79-80). Since the novel clearly re- ferred to the recent war and to France’s occupation by Germany, critics such as Roland Barthes and Simone de Beauvoir found its symbolism dangerously misleading. Why write an allegory of a plague, they asked, which denounces no historical evils and which oversimplifies the dilemmas of resistance and revolution? Camus defended his novel in a well-known letter to Barthes that claimed that The Plague was ap- plicable to “any resistance against any tyranny” because “terror has several faces” (Lyrical and Critical 340).

At issue here was whether Camus’s philosophy of absurdity could support a strong ethical and political stance, or whether it condemned one to indecisiveness, passivity, or bourgeois complacency. There is a valid theoretical debate at the heart of this issue, one clarified by John Cruickshank, Herbert Hochberg, and others who have fairly criticized Camus for confusing his descriptive account of the absurdity of the hu- man condition with his normative account of the ethic appropriate to absurd individuals. Yet some critics have offered solutions, such as Donald Lazere’s postulate that absurdity suggests the supreme impor- tance of individual life. “Once we affirm every individual conscious- ness as an absolute value,” Lazere wrote, “we become bound to seek a social system that promotes maximal length, intensity, and freedom for each individual’s life. Hence we must oppose war, capital punishment, and any ideology that subordinates human flesh and blood to abstrac- tions such as nationalism or bourgeois property” (138).

Fred Willhoite Jr.’s Beyond Nihilism: Albert Camus’s Contribution to Political Thought remains a greatly influential interpretation of Camus’s work in which Camus’s political aim is defined as “dialogic

90 Critical Insights

 

 

communion,” drawn in part from Martin Buber’s ideas of dialogue and intersubjective relationships (64-69). The appropriate attitude of the absurd person, according to this view, is that of the “genuinely free dialogic attitude that exalts and enhances life” as opposed to the “monological hardness and fanaticism that leads to death” (66).

Jeffrey Isaac’s well-known Arendt, Camus and Modern Rebellion argues that Camus’s goal was to find a way between all or nothing, to discover a relative ethical stance that could withstand the pressures of both absolutism and nihilism. Isaac’s book contends that Camus en- dorsed democratic politics, dialogic communities, and a posture of eth- ical reflexivity. “Absurdity involves, then, not just the absence of an ultimate answer, but a question, as well as a questioner, whose inquiry attests to the value of human life and to the importance of the freedom to ask elusive questions and dream elusive dreams” (120).

Some attempts to resolve Camus’s ethical and political dilemmas have been even more complex. As we explore absurdity, says the phi- losopher Avi Sagi, we are elaborating a kind of self-knowledge, which is “ethical, in the sense of a return to concrete existence moulded by ac- quaintance with its foundations” (282). Other critics, however, have seen in absurdity only an evil to be combated. For example, Thomas Merton claimed that “[Camus] wants his reader to recognize ‘the ab- surd’ in order to resist it” (182). Absurdity, for Merton, was “simply one face of ‘the plague’which we must resist in all its aspects” (182).

Curiously, the question of which absurdities to reject and which ab- surdities to accept was the question that defined Camus’s career. Most recently, this question has been examined in the context of French co- lonialism and the Algerian War for independence (1954-1962). Al- though a child of Europeans and a citizen of France, Camus was deeply connected to Algeria, the land of his birth. So when the longstanding conflict over independence erupted into full-scale violence, Camus found himself in an extremely difficult position.

Critical Reception 91

 

 

The Algerian Controversy: What If Camus Was Wrong? Today, it is not uncommon for discussions of Camus to pass over his

most celebrated fiction and essays, concentrating instead on his jour- nalism, his letters and reports on Algeria, and his unfinished novel, The First Man. But these seemingly unusual points of focus are not without justification, for Camus’s position on Algerian independence was complex and, by most contemporary standards, lamentable. At various points in his career, Camus both criticized the idea of complete Alge- rian independence and sought to rectify the deplorable conditions of Arab Algerians living under French rule. He denounced the use of ter- rorism as a tactic of the National Liberation Front (FLN), but also criti- cized the repressive methods of the French administration (Resistance 115). He advocated moderate steps toward peaceful resolution, but also desired to keep the French colonial system intact, even claiming that it was necessary for Algeria to be “conquered a second time” (Hughes 2). What Camus meant by this most unfortunate phrase, how- ever, was that the full rights of French citizenship should be extended to all Algerians: Europeans, Arabs, and Berbers.

For several decades, critics have decried Camus’s position as vacil- lation, collaboration, even racism. Raymond Aron’s lament that Camus was simply unable to escape the attitude of a “well-intentioned colonizer” (Judt 119), has become a common contemporary assess- ment of Camus’s writings and speeches of the time. In 1957, after sev- eral passionate editorials, speeches, and failed attempts to intercede, Camus refused to make any more public statements about Algeria at all. Of course, critics then took issue with Camus’s silence. Simone de Beauvoir at first denounced Camus’s “hollow” language on the Alge- rian conflict, then later declared herself “revolted by [Camus’] refusal to speak” (qtd. in Zaretsky 140-142).

The question that informs critical fascination with Camus’s Alge- rian politics is really the question of how Camus, hero of the French Resistance, untiring advocate of justice, and passionate moralist of The

92 Critical Insights

 

 

Plague and The Rebel could reasonably defend colonization and the permanent occupation of a foreign land. If Camus was “wrong” on this matter, then what are readers to make of his moral intuition, his politi- cal writing, and his overall contribution? On his own account, Camus had been “wrong” before, particularly in supporting the capital punish- ment of Nazi collaborators such as Robert Brasillach (Zaretsky 63-74; Foley 34). In Camus’s later retraction of his position on Brasillach, one may remark the beginnings of Camus’s developing political stance, from his immoderate demand for justice on behalf of the liberated French nation to his measured and arguably timid solution to the war for Algeria’s independence.

Many critics take issue not only with Camus’s political writings on Algeria, but with his novels and stories for their treatment of colonial problems of power, race, and identity. Albert Memmi and Pierre Nora argued that colonialist racism and sadism could be read between the lines of Camus’s fiction, and since then, numerous critics have fol- lowed suit. While it is true that critics tend to read Camus quite se- lectively on this issue, many have found Camus’s fiction to be em- blematic of a Eurocentric mindset unable to confront the realities of inequality, systematic violence, and racism in North Africa and, by extension, elsewhere around the globe.

Conor Cruise O’Brien’s Albert Camus of Europe and Africa has made the greatest impact in examining issues of colonialism with re- spect to Camus’s life and work. Like many others, O’Brien was puz- zled that Camus could recognize the injustice of Germany’s invasion of France, and the injustice of the plague’s invasion of Oran, while ig- noring the French invasion and colonization of North Africa. Few would maintain that Camus consciously sought to perpetuate injus- tice, but O’Brien argued that Camus was blinded by his proximity to the French/Algerian issue, perhaps even resorting to a willful self- delusion to justify his colonial stance.

More than anything else, it was Camus’s idea of an Algeria to which he belonged that was the source of O’Brien’s and, later, Edward Said’s

Critical Reception 93

 

 

famous indictments. Said’s Culture and Imperialism accused Camus of being an oppressor of indigenous Algerians and, effectively, a usurper of their homeland, while O’Brien argued that Camus drew the wrong conclusions about Algeria because he suffered from the colo- nial hallucination of a shared cultural heritage. Subsequently, and rather cleverly, referred to as his “nostalgérie” (Carroll 2007 15), Camus’s “idealized . . . fantasy of ‘Mediterranean man,’” has been crit- icized often as a dangerous delusion, one Camus should have dis- carded amidst the extreme desperation and violence of the Algerian War (Apter 508).

Critics have noted that Arabs are often depicted as little more than “stick figures holding up the scenery” in Camus’s fiction (Apter 503). O’Brien went further, describing Camus’s treatment of Arabs in The Plague as Camus’s “artistic final solution of the problem of the Arabs of Oran” (56). In The Stranger, it is true that Meursault’s victim, “l’Arabe,” is given no other name in the text; like many other Arab Al- gerian characters in Camus’s work, he is little more than a ghost. Simi- larly, in The Plague, the Arab quarter is ravaged by pestilence but is al- most completely ignored; even the heroes of the tale, Rieux and Tarrou, do not carry their struggle against the plague that far.

Although O’Brien, Said, and others have been correct in claiming that Camus was unable to imagine an Algeria without him (and other European settlers) in it, there has been a recent attempt to rescue Camus from the condemnations of postcolonial criticism. Notably, Da- vid Carroll has described Camus’s vision of a unifying Algerian iden- tity more generously as one of “an original sharing and being-together before separation, difference, and conflict” (“Camus’s Algeria” 529). And Carroll’s recent book, Albert Camus the Algerian, both departs from and extends this effort by examining Camus in terms of his “Algerianness.” John Foley’s recent book Albert Camus: From the Ab- surd to Revolt also lays out a fair critique of O’Brien and Said, defending Camus against many of their accusations.

Perhaps surprisingly, in spite of his controversial stance, Camus

94 Critical Insights

 

 

now is claimed by Algerian writers such as Assia Djebar as a national literary hero and one of their own (Djebar; Kelly). At the same time, French President Nicolas Sarkozy led a controversial effort to move Camus’s body to the Pantheon, Paris’s mausoleum for the greatest con- tributors to French life and culture. At the time of this writing, it seems doubtful that Camus will be memorialized alongside Voltaire, Rous- seau, Zola, and others. But the controversy itself serves as a reminder that, even amid vocal criticism of his work, possession of Camus’s leg- acy is still sought after by the many traditions, cultures, and ideologies in which his complex work took part. Perhaps the most one can say about the future of Camus’s critical reception, therefore, is that the controversies of his life and death have not detracted from his celebrity but have become an integral part of it, attracting new generations of readers to Camus who are likely to discover in his work the same origi- nality, complexity, and actualité that has engaged readers for nearly seventy years.

Works Cited Apter, Emily. “Out of Character: Camus’s French Algerian Subjects.” MLN 112.4

(1997): 499-516. Aronson, Ronald. Camus and Sartre: The Story of a Friendship and the Quarrel

That Ended It. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 2004. Brée, Germaine. Camus. Re- vised ed. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers U P, 1964.

Camus, Albert. Albert Camus: Lyrical and Critical Essays. Ed. P. Thody. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1968.

____________. Caligula and Three Other Plays. Trans. S. Gilbert. New York: Vintage, 1958.

____________. The Fall. Trans. J. O’Brien. New York: Vintage, 1956. ____________. The First Man. 1994. Trans. D. Hapgood. New York: Vintage,

1995. ____________. The Myth of Sisyphus and Other Essays. 1942. Trans. J. O’Brien.

New York: Vintage, 1955. ____________. The Plague. Trans. S. Gilbert. New York: Vintage, 1948. ____________. The Rebel: An Essay on Man in Revolt. 1951. Trans. A. Bower.

New York: Vintage, 1956. ____________. Resistance, Rebellion, and Death. Trans. J. O’Brien. New York:

Vintage, 1960.

Critical Reception 95

 

 

____________. The Stranger. 1942. Trans. M. Ward. New York: Vintage, 1988. Carroll, David. Albert Camus the Algerian: Colonialism, Terrorism, Justice. New

York: Columbia UP, 2007. ____________. “Camus’s Algeria: Birthrights, Colonial Injustice, and the Fiction

of a French-Algerian People.” MLN 112.4 (1997): 517-49. Cruickshank, John. Albert Camus and the Literature of Revolt. New York: Oxford

UP, 1960. Djebar, Assia. Le Blanc de L’Algérie. Paris: Albin Michel, 1995. Esslin, Martin. The Theatre of the Absurd. 1961. Third ed. New York: Vintage, 2001. Foley, John. Albert Camus: From the Absurd to Revolt. Montreal: McGill-Queens

UP, 2008. Hochberg, Herbert. “Albert Camus and the Ethic of Absurdity.” Ethics 75.2

(1965): 87-102. Isaac, Jeffrey. Arendt, Camus, and Modern Rebellion. New Haven, CT: Yale UP,

1992. Judt, Tony. The Burden of Responsibility: Blum, Camus, Aron, and the French

Twentieth Century. Chicago: U of Chicago P, 1998. Kelly, Debra. “Le Premier Homme and the Literature of Loss.” The Cambridge

Companion to Camus. Ed. E. J. Hughes. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2007. 191-202.

Lazere, Donald. The Unique Creation of Albert Camus. New Haven, CT: Yale UP, 1973.

Luppé, Robert de. Albert Camus. Trans. J. Cumming and J. Hargreaves. London: Merlin, 1966.

Memmi, Albert. The Colonizer and the Colonized. Trans. H. Greenfield. Boston: Beacon P, 1965.

Merton, Thomas. The Literary Essays of Thomas Merton. Ed. Patrick Hart. New York: New Directions, 1981.

Nora, Pierre. Les Français d’Algérie. Paris: René Julliard, 1961. O’Brien, Conor Cruise. Albert Camus of Europe and Africa. New York: Viking,

1970. Onimus, Jean. Albert Camus and Christianity. Trans. E. Parker. Tuscaloosa: U of

Alabama P, 1965. Quilliot, Roger. The Sea and Prisons: A Commentary on the Life and Thought of

Albert Camus. 1956. Trans. E. Parker. Tuscaloosa: U of Alabama P, 1970. Sagi, Avi. Albert Camus and the Philosophy of the Absurd. Trans. B. Stein. Am-

sterdam: Rodopi, 2002. ____________. “‘Is the Absurd the Problem or the Solution?’ The Myth of Sisy-

phus Reconsidered.” Philosophy Today 38.3 (1994): 278-284. Said, Edward. Culture and Imperialism. New York: Vintage, 1993. Sartre, Jean Paul. “An Explication of The Stranger.” Camus: A Collection of Criti-

cal Essays. Ed. G. Brée. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall, 1962. 108-21. Scherr, Arthur. “Camus’s The Stranger.” Explicator 59.3 (2001): 149-53. Todd, Olivier. Albert Camus: A Life. Trans. B. Ivry. New York: Carroll and Graf,

2000.

96 Critical Insights

 

 

Willhoite, Fred, Jr. Beyond Nihilism: Albert Camus’s Contribution to Political Thought. Baton Rouge: Louisiana State UP, 1968.

Zaretsky, Robert. Albert Camus: Elements of a Life. Ithaca: Cornell UP, 2010. Ziolkowski, Theodore. “Camus in Germany, or the Return of the Prodigal Son.”

Yale French Studies 25 (1960): 132-37.

Critical Reception 97

 

 

Copyright of Critical Insights: Albert Camus is the property of Salem Press and its content may not be copied or

emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder’s express written permission.

However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.